If you're lemon-obsessed, you'll want to learn how to make lemon bars using this vintage recipe.
We Tried the Simple Lemon Bar Recipe That’s Taking over Reddit
Updated Nov. 18, 2019
When it comes to dessert, anything made with lemon has my attention!
I recently stumbled across the recipe for Grandma’s Lemon Bars on Reddit, and knew I had to see what all of the fuss was about. The recipe is posted on r/Old_Recipes over and over again, and people have left thousands of comments about how amazing they taste. I’ve always wanted to learn how to make lemon bars like the ones my grandma used to make. Here’s what happened when I tested this heirloom recipe.
Psst: You can make all kinds of vintage desserts with fresh lemon.
How to Make Grandma’s Lemon Bars
The original recipe from u/JustHood calls for butter or margarine. But when it comes to baking, I’m 100% about butter, so that’s my suggestion for the best flavor. Learn the actual difference between butter and margarine.
Ingredients
- 2 cups plus 4 tablespoons flour, divided
- 1 cup butter
- 4 eggs
- 5-7 tablespoons lemon juice
- 2 cups sugar
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1/2 cup powdered sugar
Here’s why you should always bake with room-temperature eggs.
Instructions
Step 1: Prepare the crust
Preheat your oven to 350°F. Cream together 2 cups of flour and butter. Then, press into an ungreased 9×12-inch pan and bake for 20 minutes. Remove the crust from the oven when it’s light golden.
Note that I decided to grease the pan with cooking spray because I was convinced that the bars would never come out if I didn’t apply some sort of oil!
Step 2: Prepare the lemon filling
Beat together eggs and tablespoons of lemon juice. I used 7 tablespoons for an extra lemony flavor and I suggest that you do the same. Add in the remaining 4 tablespoons of flour, sugar and salt, and mix to combine. Pour the lemon mixture on top of the crust and bake for an additional 25 minutes.
Step 3: Sprinkle with powdered sugar
The original recipe says to sprinkle with powdered sugar while still warm. However, sprinkling on the powdered sugar while the bars were still warm resulted in the sugar melting. I’ve always had powdered sugar showing on top of my bars, so I sprinkled some additional sugar on top once they cooled.
I also suggest waiting until the bars cool completely before cutting them. See our Test Kitchen’s guide on how to cut bars.
The Verdict
These lemon bars were absolutely amazing! I wouldn’t use any less than 7 tablespoons of fresh lemon juice if you want to maximize the tart lemon flavor. I also would suggest greasing the pan if you want the bars to come out looking gorgeous.
I shared these lemon bars with my co-workers, and they were gone in an instant. Everyone agreed that they tasted very classic, much like their own grandmothers used to make. The group also said that they preferred to eat the bars when chilled because they were less messy/gooey.
It turns out this classic recipe is popular for good reason!
Find More Vintage Desserts Worth Trying
My husband loved his Mamaw's strawberry cake recipe. He thought no one could duplicate it. I made it, and it’s just as scrumptious as he remembers. —Jennifer Bruce, Manitou, Kentucky
Peanut Butter CookiesWe cream shortening instead of butter for this dough, resulting in an ultra-rich-tasting version of traditional peanut butter cookies. Also nice? They take less than 30 minutes to prepare.Â
(You'll love grandma's classic spritz cookie recipe!)
Gran's Apple CakeMy grandmother occasionally brought over this wonderful cake warm from the oven. The spicy apple flavor combined with the sweet cream cheese frosting made this recipe one that we treasured. Even though I've lightened it up, it's still a family favorite. —Lauris Conrad, Turlock, California
Oatmeal Coconut CookiesWith our oatmeal coconut cookies, there's no need to choose between a crispy cookie and a chewy one. You can have the best of both worlds with this recipe.
Pina Colada Icebox CakeThis icebox cake has all the flavors of a pina colada. It takes just one bite to escape to a tropical island! —Rachel Lewis, Danville, Virginia
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Zucchini CakeYears ago, I added some zucchini to a peanut butter bar I had created, and this time I wanted to try adding it to a cake. The zucchini makes the cake super moist but doesn’t get in the way of the chocolate and peanut butter goodness. —Marilyn Blankschien, Clintonville, Wisconsin
Apple PieBaking apple pie from scratch is a fall baking tradition we treasure. Perfect your technique with our apple pie recipe, full of all the tips and tricks you'll need.
Blackberry-Orange CakeMy grandmother made luscious fruit pies and cobblers using blackberries from her garden. I decided to follow her lead and create a blackberry cake that's always lovely with a summer meal. —Lisa M. Varner, El Paso, Texas
How to Make Our Quick and Easy Recipe for Cocoa BrowniesThis brownie recipe with cocoa powder is heaven fresh out of the oven.
Carrot CakeMy family's best carrot cake recipe dates back to my great-grandmother! We bake up a few of these carrot cakes for special occasions to make sure there's enough to go around. You'll love the texture this pretty, moist treat gets from pineapple, coconut and, of course, carrots! —Debbie Terenzini-Wilkerson, Lusby, Maryland
Irresistible Coconut Cream PieMy husband and I grow 500 acres of wheat on the farm his family homesteaded in 1889. I grind my own flour and love to use it in this recipe. The easy pat-in crust has a rich grain flavor. It’s irresistible filled with old-fashioned coconut cream and topped with a fluffy meringue. —Roberta Foster, Kingfisher, Oklahoma
Cookie Jar GingersnapsThis gingersnap cookie recipe results in fluffy, delicious cookies that'll satiate your sweet tooth.
Banana Bread PuddingWarm and indulgent, this banana bread pudding makes a wonderful main dish for a weekend brunch or a family breakfast.
Sugar Cream PieThis rich, custardy sugar cream pie is an Indiana specialty. With just one bite of this decadent dessert, you’ll see why!
7UP Pound CakeThis classic 7UP cake recipe uses the carbonated beverage to bake a tall pound cake with hints of lemon and lime. We also use the soda in the glaze to really drive home its iconic flavor.
Strawberry CookiesThese Strawberry Cookies use flavored gelatin powder and jelly to create intensely flavored, chewy cookies with a sweet drizzle of icing. They look and taste terrific and you can make the dough ahead of time for easy preparation.
Italian Lemon CookiesBright, light and full of citrusy flavor, these zesty Italian lemon cookies are a real treat. Top them with the simple colored sugar called for in this recipe, or switch it up with a glaze or frosting for a richer cookie.
Banana Skillet Upside-Down CakeMy grandmother gave me my first cast iron skillet, and I've been cooking and baking with it ever since. Sometimes I add drained maraschino cherries to this banana skillet dessert and serve it with a ice cream. —Terri Merritts, Nashville, Tennessee
Orange CookiesSoft, tender and filled with bright, zippy orange juice and zest, our orange cookies with a homemade icing are sure to please—and pucker!
Pinwheel MintsBoth my grandmother and my mom used to make these eye-catching confections as a replacement for ordinary mints. When I offer them at parties, guests tell me the candies are wonderful, and then ask how I created the pretty swirl pattern. —Marilou Roth, Milford, Nebraska
Grandma's Old-Fashioned Strawberry ShortcakeMy grandma topped this treat with homemade vanilla ice cream. —Angela Lively, Conroe, Texas
Crisp Sugar CookiesMy grandmother always had sugar cookies in her pantry, and we grandchildren would empty that big jar quickly because they were the best! I now regularly bake these wonderful cookies to share with friends. —Evelyn Poteet, Hancock, Maryland
Moist Chocolate CakeThis moist chocolate cake recipe with coffee reminds me of my grandmother because it was one of her specialties. I bake it often for family parties, and it always brings back fond memories. The cake is light and airy with a delicious chocolate taste. This recipe is a keeper! —Patricia Kreitz, Richland, Pennsylvania
Martha Washington CandyMartha Washington candy is a nostalgic confection that’s been passed down for generations. Don’t let the word “candy” intimidate you! This confection is very easy to make, with zero fancy tools required.
Black Forest CakeMake a homemade Black Forest cake with chocolate cake, cherry filling and whipped cream. Its impressive, colorful layers make it a great dessert for showing off to guests.
Date Pinwheel CookiesA delightful nut-and-date filling swirls through these sweet, buttery date pinwheel cookies. Enjoy them during the holidays or as an everyday treat with coffee.
Strawberry Rhubarb PieWhile growing up on a farm, I often ate rhubarb, so it's natural for me to use it in a pie. I prefer to use lard for the flaky pie crust and thin red rhubarb stalks for the filling. These two little secrets helped this strawberry rhubarb pie recipe win top honors at the 2013 Iowa State Fair. —Marianne Carlson, Jefferson, Iowa
Grossmutter's PeppernutsBefore Christmas, my grandmother would bake peppernuts and store them until the big day. When we came home from school, the whole house would smell like anise and we knew the holiday season was about to begin. —Marilyn Kutzli, Clinton, Iowa
Apple Cornbread CrispWith hearty ingredients and quick prep time, this warm apple crisp makes a delicious, wholesome dessert for any fall night. It reminds me of the recipe my grandmother would serve after our big family seafood dinners. It's absolutely wonderful topped with ice cream. —Julie Peterson, Crofton, Maryland
Peppermint BrowniesOur peppermint brownies topped with a shiny chocolate glaze are a festive Christmas dessert that’s easy to pull off.
Bittersweet Chocolate CheesecakeI'm a great-grandmother, and my whole family enjoys this dessert. I received this recipe from my niece. It's very chocolaty. —Amelia Gregory, Omemee, Ontario
German Apple Cake (Apfelkuchen)Embrace nostalgic flavors and homey feelings with German apple cake—an old-fashioned dessert that's so delicious, we keep making it today.
Coconut Creme ChocolatesI'm a proud wife, mom of three and grandma of many. I've cooked many things over the years, including these marshmallowy chocolates. —Dolores Wilder, Texas City, Texas
Apricot Pinwheel CookiesMy grandmother always made these cookies for the holidays. The recipe has been passed down through generations to me, and now from me to you. — Robert Logan, Clayton, California
Nanny’s Fruitcake CookiesMy grandmother always made a holiday fruitcake. I turned her recipe into cookies that are perfect anytime, especially with a cup of tea. —Amanda Digges, South Windsor, Connecticut
Chocolate Pear Hazelnut TartAs a teenage foreign exchange student in the south of France, I was horribly homesick. Then my host family's Grandmother Miette arrived and asked if I'd like to help her bake this nutty tart from scratch. It turned my trip around and inspired my lifelong passion for baking. Weighing ingredients, roasting nuts, kneading dough—the art of baking transcends language. —Lexi McKeown, Los Angeles, California
Caramel Rhubarb CobblerI came up with this recipe after hearing a friend fondly recall his grandmother's rhubarb dumplings. My son especially likes rhubarb, and this old-fashioned dessert lets those special stalks star.
-Beverly Shebs, Pinehurst, North Carolina
Mint Chocolate WafersMy grandmother gave me a cookbook stuffed with recipes. This is a slight twist on one of the first—and best—recipes I made from the book. It's best to store these in the refrigerator. —Mary Murphy, Evansville, Indiana
Icebox CookiesThis cookie recipe from my 91-year-old grandmother was my grandfather's favorite. She still makes them and sends us home with the dough so that we can make more whenever we want, I love to make a fresh batch when company drops in. —Chris Paulsen, Glendale, Arizona
Chocolate Chip Red Velvet Whoopie PiesBaking a fun treat is a must when my four grandchildren come to stay for "grandma camp." Sometimes the grandkids help by piping the cake batter. —Linda Schend, Kenosha, Wisconsin
Cranberry-Almond Apple PieMy grandmother made this treat every year for Christmas. It’s much better than everyday apple pie. The recipe is a family treasure. —Maxine Theriauit, Nashua, New Hampshire
Meringue Snowballs In CustardMy family has passed down this elegant dessert generation by generation. It started with my Russian great-grandmother, who traveled to America more than 100 years ago. I love continuing the tradition with her recipe. —Tonya Burkhard, Palm Coast, Florida
Lime & Spice Peach CobblerThis was my grandmother’s favorite recipe to make when they had bushels of peaches. Now I love to bake it whenever I can for my family and friends. —Mary Ann Dell of Phoenixville, Pennsylvania
Gingerbread Meringue BarsFor the best of both worlds, I combined my grandmother's gingerbread recipe with my aunt's special brown sugar meringue. The result? These lovable holiday-perfect bars that have become a new family tradition. —Eden Dranger, Los Angeles, California
LebkuchenDense, chewy lebkuchen is a great addition to your Christmas-cookie routine, but you can make it any time of year. While most lebkuchen contains ginger, this is a ginger-free version that uses other spices and molasses to achieve a similar flavor.
Triple Ginger CookiesMy dad loved ginger cookies. I tinkered with the recipe my grandma handed down by using fresh, ground and crystallized ginger for more pizazz. —Trisha Kruse, Eagle, Idaho
Six-Layer Coconut Cake with Lemon FillingI found this recipe when going through my grandmother's old files. It was originally made with an orange filling, but using lemon pudding in the filling makes it easier to prepare. It is simply the best. —Angela Leinenbach, Mechanicsvlle, Virginia
Gingersnap Crumb Pear PieThis basic recipe was one my grandmother used for making crumble pies from fresh fruit. She simply substituted oats, gingersnaps or vanilla wafers depending on the fruit. Pear was always my favorite, and I added the ginger and caramel to give it a new twist. —Fay Moreland, Wichita Falls, Texas
Banana Butter Pecan KabobsDesserts with bananas remind me of Grandma. She and my mom taught me to cook. I rarely measure. For this dish, I set out pecans and butterscotch with kabobs so everyone can customize. —Crystal Schlueter, Northglenn, Colorado
Zucchini CupcakesI asked my grandmother for this recipe after trying these irresistible spice cupcakes at her home. I love their creamy caramel frosting. They're such a scrumptious dessert, you actually forget you're eating your vegetables, too! —Virginia Lapierre, Greensboro Bend, Vermont
Mexican Chocolate Sugar CrispsMy grandma loved these so much, she would hide them from my grandpa! I think of her every time I make a batch. Like Mexican spice? Try stirring in a little chili powder. —Michele Lovio, Thousand Oaks, California
Lemon-Berry ShortcakeThis simple lemon shortcake is tender and not overly sweet. Enjoy this summertime classic with a generous layer of whipped topping and berries. —Meryl Herr, Overland Park, Kansas
Honey-Lime Almond CookiesDecades ago my grandmother passed this buttery lime cookie recipe to me. Through years of baking, our cookie memories keep the family connected, although we’re miles apart. —Paula Marchesi, Lenhartsville, Pennsylvania
Grandma Davidson’s Baked Apple PuddingMy savvy grandmother whipped up recipes like this homey cinnamon-scented apple pudding in the Depression years. Many of us still make them today. —Holly Sharp, Warren, Ontario
Anise & Wine CookiesMy grandmother did not speak English very well, but she knew the language of great food. These wine cookies are crisp and best eaten after being dunked in even more wine.—Julia Meyers, Scottsdale, Arizona
Grandma's Pecan Rum BarsMy grandmother handed down the recipe for these gooey bars that we all love. The candied cherries are a must. —Deborah Pennington, Falkville, Alabama
Up Next: Discover the highest-rated, most-popular desserts that came out on top this year.
Originally Published: November 18, 2019
