This Lobster Dinner Is Easier Than You’d Think. Here’s How to Make It.
Updated: May 28, 2019
Rich, buttery and melt-in-your-mouth delicious, lobster is a special occasion favorite. Learn how to make a simple and scrumptious lobster recipe right at home–our Test Kitchen will walk you through with four easy steps.
When it comes to special occasion dinners, there’s no beating lobster. The lavish presentation, the drawn butter, the melt-in-your-mouth consistency all make lobster a meal to savor. But you don’t have to limit your lobster cravings to your favorite seafood restaurant or steakhouse (and when it comes to steakhouse-style recipes, we’ve got you covered). In fact, learning how to cook lobster tail is simple.
If you haven’t tried your hand at homemade lobster before, don’t worry. Our Test Kitchen staff has broken this down into four easy steps. All it takes is a little patience and a little extra butter. Let’s dive right in and learn how to make this special occasion seafood.
How to Cook Lobster Tail at Home
For this special occasion treat, we’ll follow this five-star recipe here. You’ll need:
- 4 lobster tails (5 to 6 ounces each), thawed
- 1/4 cup cold butter, cut into thin slices
- Salt and pepper to taste
- Lemon wedges
Step 1: Snip
To make the perfect lobster at home, we recommend you start by making lobster tails. The tail holds most of the crustacean’s meat and they’re readily available in your grocer’s freezer section.
Now, to get going on your homemade lobster tail, careful use kitchen scissors to cut and remove a two-inch wide rectangle from the top shell of each lobster tail. Be mindful not to dig in too deeply and mar the meat inside.
Step 2: Loosen
With that section of the tail removed, loosen the shells edges to release the meat.
Step 3: Separate
Once the meat is loosened slightly, gently pry the lobster meat loose from the bottom shell, keeping it attached at the tail end. You don’t want to remove the meat from the shell, but you do want it to be easy to remove once it’s cooked and you’re ready to eat.
Step 4: Broil
Place your lobster tails on an aluminum foil-lined baking sheet. Line butter slices along the meat where that two-inch section of shell once was. Broil these in the oven, about five to six inches away from the heat. Cook until the meat is opaque, five to eight minutes. Once your lobster is cooked, season with salt and pepper and serve with a few lemon wedges.
Test Kitchen tip: If you want to add even more flavor to your lobster, substitute flavored compound butters for plain butter pats. We’ve got a few great variations for you, but our favorite for this application: the Old Bay and lemon compound butter. Mmmm!
Now, we know that this lobster recipe is delicious enough on its own, but real lobster-lovers might want to take this tail one step farther with drawn butter. To make your own clarified butter at home is simple, and we highly recommend it for the richest lobster possible.
How to Make Clarified Butter
Step 1: Simmer
In a heavy saucepan, melt one cup of unsalted butter over low heat. Let this simmer until the solids and fats from the butter separate—about ten minutes. Be mindful to keep this over low heat and to not let the butter brown—then you’d be on your way to browned butter which is something else entirely (and is exceptionally tasty in desserts like these pumpkin bars).
Step 2: Skim
Once your butter is entirely melted, remove from the heat and skim the surface foam. This should leave you with clear, yellow liquid.
Step 3: Strain
Skimming your butter should remove most of those milk solids, but to make the clearest clarified butter possible, our Test Kitchen recommends pouring it through a fine mesh strainer or a strainer lined with cheesecloth. You can use this butter right away for dunking or you can store it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to three months or in the freezer for up to six.
Served side-by-side, this lobster tail and drawn butter is the perfect treat for celebrations and special occasions. If you want to go classic, serve them with warm cheddar biscuits.
Inspired by: Parrot Isle Jumbo Coconut Shrimp
Panko crumbs give this spicy baked coconut shrimp its crunch. It’s great for an appetizer or for your main meal. — Debi Mitchell, Flower Mound, Texas
Inspired by: Garlic Shrimp Scampi
This shrimp scampi recipe looks elegant enough to serve to company, but it’s easy to prepare. The bright flavors of lemon and herbs enhance the shrimp. Serve it over pasta and wait for the compliments. —Lori Packer, Omaha, Nebraska
Inspired by: Hand-Battered Fish and Chips
Dine as though you're in a traditional British pub. These moist fish fillets from the oven have a fuss-free coating that's healthy but just as crunchy and golden as the deep-fried kind. Simply seasoned and baked, the crispy fries are perfect on the side. —Janice Mitchell, Aurora, Colorado
Inspired by: Roasted Maine Lobster Bake
I’ve cooked lobster alla diavola (devil’s style) since I was first married. We serve lobster at family celebrations, usually with linguine or capellini. —Marcia Whitney, Gainesville, Florida
Inspired by: Cheddar Bay Biscuits
My biscuits won the prize for best quick bread at my county fair. One of the judges liked them so much, she asked for the recipe! These buttery, savory biscuits go with just about anything. —Gloria Jarrett, Loveland, Ohio Here's more on how to make Red Lobster cheddar bay biscuits at home.
Inspired by: Walt's Favorite Shrimp
Talk about fuss-free! These skewers are simple to assemble, and they grill to perfection in minutes. My guests enjoy them with a spicy seafood sauce. —Dianna Knight, Clayton, North Carolina
Inspired by: Soy-Ginger Salmon
Ginger, garlic powder and green onion blend nicely in an easy marinade that gives pleasant flavor to salmon. We also like to use this versatile mixture when grilling chicken, but we've found it tastes even better when marinated in the fridge overnight. —Dan Strumberger, Farmington, Minnesota
Inspired by: New England Clam Chowder
I ran across this recipe in one of my antique cookbooks. It's a timeless classic I like to prepare for friends and family throughout the year, but especially during the holidays. —Betty Ann Morgan, Upper Marlboro, Maryland
Inspired by: Crab Linguine Alfredo
When I was pregnant with my first daughter I had to limit my fat intake due to health problems. I still wanted delicious meals that were great for entertaining so I started making this Alfredo for special occasions. —Jackie Price, Trenton, Missouri
Inspired by: Parmesan-Crusted Fresh Tilapia
I love that simple Parmesan cheese brings such richness to an otherwise mild-tasting fish. It's one dish where leftovers are never a problem! —Tracy Locken, Gillette, Wyoming
Inspired by: Mediterranean Shrimp
Any recipe that is special enough for company but easy enough for a weeknight meal is a favorite in my book. All you need to finish off the meal is a side salad and crusty French bread to sop up the delicious tomato and wine juices. —Susan Seymour, Valatie, New York
Inspired by: Lobster Bisque
We live on the Gulf Coast, where fresh seafood is plentiful. I adapted several recipes to come up with this rich bisque. It's great as a first course or an entree, and it can be made with just shrimp or crabmeat. —Pat Edwards, Dauphin Island, Alabama
Inspired by: Farm-Raised Catfish
The Cajun flavor is great in this skillet-grilled catfish recipe. You can use this recipe with any thick fish fillet, but I suggest catfish or haddock. —Traci Wynne, Denver, Pennsylvania
Inspired by: Crispy Shrimp Lettuce Wraps
Lettuce forms a crispy shell that's full of possibilities, depending on what's in your fridge. Swap shrimp for cooked chicken, pork or tofu. Mix in any veggies you want: carrots, broccoli, snow peas and chopped zucchini are all fantastic add-ins. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen
Inspired by: Seafood-Stuffed Flounder
The delicious shrimp-herb stuffing makes this fish recipe special enough for company. But it really isn’t hard to make, and since our family enjoys fish, we eat it often. —Marie Forte, Raritan, New Jersey
Inspired by: Crunch-Fried Fish Sandwich
Fishing for a burger alternative? Consider it caught. A hint of cayenne is cooled by a creamy yogurt and mayo sauce in this fish sandwich that will put your local drive-thru to shame. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen
Inspired by: Key Lime Pie
For a taste of paradise, try this no-bake Key lime pie recipe. It's low in fat, sugar and fuss. It truly is the best Key lime pie recipe ever! —Frances VanFossan, Warren, Michigan
Inspired by: Cajun Chicken Linguine Alfredo
My family loves pasta, so I decided to get in the kitchen and come up with my own chicken pasta bake. This recipe is quick and simple to make, and it tastes so good, they all go back for seconds. I serve it with a tossed salad and garlic bread. —Kim Weishuhn, Pensacola, Florida
Inspired by: Seafood Gumbo
Gumbo is one dish that makes Louisiana cuisine so famous. We live across the state line in Texas and can’t seem to get enough of this traditional gumbo recipe that features okra, shrimp, spicy seasonings and what is called the holy trinity—onions, green peppers and celery. This recipe calls for seafood, but you could also use chicken, duck or sausage. —Ruth Aubey, San Antonio, Texas
Inspired by: NY Strip and Rock Lobster Tail
For an intimate dinner with close friends, serve this stunning dinner of tenderloin steaks and lobster tail. Your guests will think they are dining at a fine restaurant when you serve them this surf and turf dish. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen
Inspired by: Sweet Chili Shrimp
These finger-lickin' shrimp practically fly off the platter at my get-togethers. Play with the amount of sriracha to get the spice level just the way you like it. —Susan Harrison, Laurel, Maryland
Inspired by: Wood-Grilled Tilapia Tacos
Fish tacos are my new favorite thing—lighter and healthier than beef tacos smothered in cheese. Try adding tomatoes, green onions and chopped jalapeno on top. —Deb Perry, Traverse City, Michigan
Inspired by: Creamy Potato Bacon Soup
My husband and I enjoyed a delicious baked potato soup at a restaurant while on vacation and I came home determined to duplicate the flavor. It took me five years to get the taste right! —Joann Goetz, Genoa, Ohio
Inspired by: Maple-Glazed Chicken
When I became a new mother, my mom helped me find comforting and simple recipes to have on hand. This terrific roast chicken is a happy discovery. —Sara Eilers, Surprise, Arizona
Inspired by: Shrimp Linguini Alfredo
After tasting fettuccine Alfredo at a restaurant, I came up with this shrimp Alfredo with broccoli version at home. Not only does my family love the creamy dish, but my husband prefers it to the one at the restaurant. —Rae Natoli, Kingston, New York
Inspired by: Salmon New Orleans
We eat this salmon a lot, along with couscous and fresh veggies. Even my 2-year-old devours it. —Lyndsay Rensing, Katy, Texas
Inspired by: Rock Lobster Tail
I had never tried grilling lobster tails at home until I tried this convenient and deliciously different recipe. It turned out amazing, and has left me with little reason to ever order grilled lobster tail at a restaurant again. Here's how to cook lobster tails on the grill. —Katie Rush, Kansas City, Missouri
