Part cake, part pie, all-around delicious. Jennifer Switzer of Beyond the Butter shares the recipe for this silly-sounding dessert with a sweet backstory.
How to Make Chocolate Funny Cake
Updated on Oct. 04, 2024
We all have that one recipe that whisks us back to childhood at a mere mention. The one you can taste—even smell—just by thinking of it, and suddenly your mind is flooded with the memories that come with that very special food. For Jennifer Switzer, it’s her grammy’s Pennsylvania Dutch Funny Cake.
When her grandma passed away in 2010, Jennifer was overcome with sadness. Holding the handwritten cards with the recipes for the beloved sweets she adored growing up, she knew she couldn’t let these family traditions be forgotten. That’s how her blog was born. “For years I had an idea to create a baking blog centered around the recipes Grammy made for everyone in the family—recipes that have given me truly great memories of childhood and beyond.”
By 2018, Jennifer had become comfortable enough with her baking skills that she decided it was time to share her treasured recipes with the rest of the world. Her blog, Beyond the Butter, is a place for desserts that are uncomplicated but delicious, whether they’re straight from Grammy’s recipe box or Jennifer’s original ideas. “If it has a kazillion steps, that’s not something I’m going to make,” said Jennifer. “And Grammy was the same way. She liked things that were simple, but that tasted wonderful.” Even the three-layered Pennsylvania Dutch Funny Cake is made with fewer than a dozen ingredients. What makes it so “funny?” Well, it’s kind of a difficult dessert to categorize.
What Is a Funny Cake?
A light vanilla cake is baked in a pie crust, with a fudgy chocolate layer that sinks from the top to settle below the cake as it bakes. It’s a curious kind of dessert, for sure, but with charming simplicity. And though Grammy liked to keep things straightforward, she was still a stickler. The first time Jennifer made funny cake for her, she said it was “good, but the crust wasn’t quite right.” Since then, Jennifer has perfected the technique for baking up a golden, flaky crust.
Her best tip for worry-free pie crust sticks to Grammy’s theme of undemanding but delectable: use store-bought! “Homemade pie crust is awesome, but I understand that people don’t always like to make it—or have the time.” Sure, the funny cake seems like a dessert, but Jennifer grants permission to eat it whenever you want. “My pop-pop always ate it for breakfast, so I would eat it at breakfast, too.”
Whether you eat it for breakfast, dessert, or sometime in between, we won’t judge. Now roll up those sleeves and get started on your own!
How to Make Pennsylvania Dutch Funny Cake
Here’s what you need to make Jennifer’s favorite funny cake:
For the crust:
- 3 cups all-purpose flour
- 1 tsp. salt
- 1/2 cup cold shortening, cubed
- 1/2 cup cold unsalted butter, cubed
- 6 to 8 Tbsp. ice water
For the cake layer:
- 1/2 cup shortening
- 2 cups sugar
- 2 large eggs, room temperature
- 1 tsp. vanilla extract
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 2 tsp. baking powder
- 1 cup whole milk
For the chocolate layer:
- 1 cup sugar
- 1/3 cup baking cocoa
- 1 cup boiling water
- 1/2 tsp. vanilla extract
This recipe makes two pies, so enjoy one and give one to a friend (along with the recipe).
Step 1: Make Your Pastry Dough
In a large bowl, mix flour and salt; cut in shortening and butter until crumbly. Gradually add ice water, tossing with a fork until dough holds together when pressed. Divide dough in half. Shape each into a disk. Wrap; refrigerate for at least an hour or up to overnight.
If you like, you can use a premade pie crust to cut down on prep time.
Step 2: Roll It Out
On a lightly floured surface, roll half of the dough to an eighth-inch-thick circle; transfer to a nine-inch deep-dish pie plate. Trim crust to a half-inch beyond rim of plate; flute edge. Repeat with remaining dough. Refrigerate 30 minutes.
Jennifer’s tip: Chill the dough all the way through. If the dough is as cool as possible, the pie crust won’t slide down the pan or shrink.
Step 3: Make Your Cake Batter
Meanwhile, preheat oven to 375°F. In a large bowl, beat shortening and sugar until crumbly. Add eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition. Beat in vanilla. In another bowl, whisk flour and baking powder; add to creamed mixture alternately with milk, beating well after each addition. Divide batter between pie plates.
Jennifer’s tip: Place both funny cakes on a baking sheet or jelly roll pan before adding the cake batter and chocolate. It will help keep spillage down when moving them from the counter to the oven.
Step 4: Pour on the Chocolate
For the chocolate layer, in a small bowl, combine sugar and cocoa. Whisk in boiling water and vanilla until sugar is dissolved. Pour over cake layers.
Step 5: Bake It Up!
Bake until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean, 40-45 minutes. Cool completely on wire racks.
When you pull it from the oven, you’ll see the chocolate layer has “flipped” to the bottom! How fun is that? The result is a fluffy cake with just a hint of sweetness sitting atop a rich, chocolatey layer and a flaky, golden crust. Slice it up and share your own sweet memories.
Looking for more cake recipes? Learn how to make this 4-ingredient magic cake at home.
Try More Cozy Pennsylvania Dutch-Inspired Recipes
Pennsylvania Dutch Cucumbers
My mom's side of the family was German and Irish. Settling in Pennsylvania, they adopted some of the cooking and customs of the Pennsylvania Dutch. This is a dish Mom loved, and today it's my favorite garden salad. It tastes delicious alongside a plate of homegrown tomatoes. —Shirley Joan Helfenbein, Lapeer, Michigan
Amish Breakfast CasseroleWe've enjoyed a few hearty breakfast casseroles while visiting an Amish inn. When I asked for a recipe, one of the ladies told me the ingredients right off the top of her head. I modified it to create this quick and easy breakfast casserole my family loves. —Beth Notaro, Kokomo, Indiana
Pennsylvania Dutch Potato DoughnutsMy relatives have been making these tasty doughnuts for years. The potatoes keep them moist, and the glaze provides just the right amount of sweetness. —Marlene Reichart, Leesport, Pennsylvania
German PancakesWhip up a show-stopping centerpiece for your breakfast spread with our recipe for German pancakes.
Easy Pennsylvania Dutch Apple CobblerThis is a common dish from where I was born and raised in Pennsylvania. It's a classic Dutch-style apple cobbler recipe—easy, quick and delicious. Who wouldn't love this golden brown delight? —Andrea Robson, York, Pennsylvania
Potato SoupThis easy homemade potato soup recipe is a staple side for steak dinners at home or an amazing comfort meal on a chilly day.
Pennsylvania Dutch Pork ChopsRecipes of Pennsylvania Dutch heritage, like this one, are popular in our area. We like to serve these sweet-and-sour pork chops with dumplings or spaetzle, red cabbage coleslaw and applesauce, with Dutch apple pie for dessert. —Joyce E. Brotzman, McVeytown, Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania Pot RoastThis heartwarming one-dish meal is adapted from a Pennsylvania Dutch recipe. I start the pot roast cooking before I leave for church, add vegetables when I get home, and then just sit back and relax until it's done. —Donna Wilkinson, Monrovia, Maryland
Blueberry JamHomemade blueberry jam adds an instant flavor boost to your favorite foods. Dollop a spoonful onto oatmeal or fluffy pancakes and waffles for a sweet, tart, purple-colored upgrade.
Pennsylvania Dutch Corn PieThis Pennsylvania Dutch corn pie is full of old-fashioned goodness, with tender diced potatoes and a fresh, sweet corn flavor. Once you've tasted this delicious pie, you'll never want to serve corn any other way! —Kathy Spang, Manheim, Pennsylvania
Pickled Green BeansMake your summer produce go the extra mile with this easy pickled green beans recipe. We'll walk you through every step of making this tasty snack.
Turkey White ChiliGrowing up in a Pennsylvania Dutch area, I was surrounded by excellent cooks and wonderful foods. I enjoy experimenting with new recipes like this change-of-pace chili. —Kaye Whiteman, Charleston, West Virginia
Maple Baked BeansSince my husband raises hogs and my parents produce maple syrup, this recipe is a natural for me! I usually prepare maple baked beans just for us during the winter. In summer, I'll often make it for family picnics and get-togethers. —Cindy Huitema, Dunnville, Ontario
Amish Sugar CookiesThe Amish seem to be master bakers, and they did not skimp on Amish sugar cookies.
Buttermilk DressingThis restaurant-style buttermilk dressing is similar to a classic ranch and dresses up basic green salads, pasta salads and potato salads.
Grandma’s Rosemary Dinner RollsMy grandma (I called her Baba) made these in her coal oven. How she regulated the temperature is beyond me! She always made extra rolls for the neighbors to bake in their own ovens. My mom and aunts would deliver the formed rolls at lunchtime. —Charlotte Hendershot, Hudson, Pennsylvania
Apple Slab PieApple slab pie is a terrific contribution to a covered-dish supper, picnic or potluck. It’s baked in a large 15x10 baking pan so it’s easy to make and tote, too. But be prepared—people always ask for a copy of the recipe! —Dolores Skrout, Summerhill, Pennsylvania
Amish NoodlesThese are the best buttered noodles ever! They are easy to make and kid-friendly, and they pair nicely with lots of main dishes. —Angela Lively, Conroe, Texas
Dill Garden SaladI love to cut up whatever fresh vegetables I have on hand and toss them with this delicious dressing and fresh dill. This salad shows up on our table regularly during the summer. —Bethany Martin, Lewisburg, Pennsylvania
Amish Onion CakeThis rich, moist bread with an onion-poppy seed topping is a wonderful break from your everyday bread routine. You can serve it with any meat, and it's a nice accompaniment to soup or salad. I've made it many times and have often been asked to share the recipe. —Mitzi Sentiff, Annapolis, Maryland
Potato Stuffing CasseroleI adapted this recipe from a Pennsylvania Dutch cookbook, and it's indicative of the fine German cooking found in this area. If you're looking for an alternative to mashed potatoes, try this dish. —Elsa Kerschner, Kunkletown, Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania Dutch Funny CakeI can still remember my grandma serving this delicious cake on the big wooden table in her farm kitchen. Every time I bake this unusual cake, it takes me back to those special days at Grandma's. —Diane Ganssle, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
Sweet Pickled OnionsSavory, sweet and all-around tasty, sweet pickled onions are easy to make and will last for a year and then some.
Oatmeal Molasses CrispsWhen I found this recipe in an Amish cookbook, I had to try it. It’s traditional in regions with Amish populations—Pennsylvania, Ohio and the Upper Midwest. Now it’s a staple for our family and the folks at our church fellowship, too. —Jori Schellenberger, Everett, Washington
Green Beans with BaconOne bite of green beans with bacon makes us wonder why we'd ever eat this veggie any other way!
Apple-Walnut Maple ConserveVersatile and delicious, this conserve reminds me of a warm cozy kitchen; you'll love every bite. I warm the conserve and pour it over vanilla ice cream as a dessert, and it's great as a topping over French toast, biscuits or even pork roast. Be sure to make more than one batch so you can give it as gifts during the holidays.—Paula Marchesi, Lenhartsville, Pennsylvania
Pretty Pumpkin Cinnamon BunsIndulge in these pumpkin cinnamon rolls for a cozy and delightful twist on the classic treat. Perfect for autumn mornings, these rolls are filled with pumpkin, cinnamon and a sweet glaze that will make your breakfast extra special.
Chocolate Zucchini BreadOur chocolate zucchini bread surpasses any regular zucchini bread by miles. Save up your zucchini bounty so you can later enjoy this bread bounty.
Make-Ahead Cabbage RollsI've relied on this recipe for years, and my cabbage rolls never fail to impress. As the host of a number of holiday parties, my guests have come to expect this main entree. —Nancy Foust, Stoneboro, Missouri
Amish Baked OatmealNot familiar with Amish baked oatmeal? Think of it as a warm-from-the-oven oatmeal cookie that you can serve topped with milk, fresh fruit and brown sugar.
Pork Chops with ApplesFor this version of pork chops and apples, you can serve the apple on the side or smother the chops with sauce. Either way, you’ve got a classic pairing of sweet pork, tart apple and aromatic spices.
Broccoli CasseroleThis classic cheesy broccoli casserole recipe is a timeless family favorite. It requires only five ingredients and 15 minutes of prep time for a quick and easy dinner.
Golden Honey Pan RollsA cousin in North Carolina gave me the recipe for these delicious honey-glazed rolls. Using my bread machine to make the dough saves me about 2 hours compared to the traditional method. The rich buttery taste of these rolls is so popular with family and friends that I usually make two batches so I have enough! —Sara Wing, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Spicy Potato SoupMy sister-in-law, who is from Mexico, passed along this wonderful recipe. Since she prefers her foods much spicier than we do, I reduced the amount of pepper sauce, but you can add more if you prefer a bigger kick. —Audrey Wall, Industry, Pennsylvania
Apple MuffinsThese apple muffins have a rich, tender inside and a decadent, crunchy topping (complete with a vanilla glaze) that makes for a delicious breakfast treat. They're great any time of year, but especially on a chilly fall morning.
Cabbage and SausageCabbage and sausage has so many variations the world over, but it's a hearty dish wherever you're serving it. This cabbage and sausage recipe comes together in a single pot in less than an hour.
Mom’s Roast BeefEveryone loves slices of this fork-tender roast beef with its savory gravy. The well-seasoned roast is Mom's specialty. People always ask about the secret ingredients. Now you have the delicious recipe for our favorite meat dish! —Linda Gaido, New Brighton, Pennsylvania
Chicken Corn SoupThis chicken corn soup stands up no matter the weather. It's cozy enough for cold winter nights and light enough for cool spring evenings.
Pumpkin-Apple Muffins with Streusel ToppingMy mother always made these tasty muffins whenever our family got together at her house. Now they’re a family favorite at my house, and my in-laws love them, too! —Carolyn Riley, Carlisle, Pennsylvania
Walnut Horn CookiesAt our house, it wouldn't be Christmas without these Pennsylvania Dutch cookies, which are known locally as kiffels. —Sharon Allen, Allentown, Pennsylvania
Chicken Potpie SoupRich and creamy chicken potpie soup is a fun variation of the old-fashioned favorite, plus it cooks up in about half the time as the baked version.
Amish Raisin CookiesI found this recipe for a chewy raisin cookie in one of the many Amish cookbooks I own. I haven't seen it duplicated anywhere else. —Marcia Wagner, Berrien Springs, Michigan
Amish Macaroni SaladThis Amish macaroni salad is a crowd favorite. It's supposed to be sweet, but you can lessen the sugar to suit your taste. Garnish with sliced hard-boiled eggs and paprika, if desired. —Mishelle Johnson, Wyoming, Michigan
Maple-Walnut Sticky BunsMmm! These ooey-gooey goodies will have everyone licking maple syrup from their fingers—and reaching for seconds. The yeast dough chills overnight. —Nancy Foust, Stoneboro, Pennsylvania
