We Tried Internet Famous Pan-Bang Chocolate Chip Cookies (and Loved Them!)
Updated: Jan. 12, 2022On our quest to find the *perfect* chocolate chip cookie, we couldn't help but wonder if the internet's favorite recipe was worth they hype. Find out what we loved about pan bang cookies.
When it comes to chocolate chip cookies, I’m all about trying every single iteration in efforts to find the best version of the classic cookie. In my day, I’ve come across some really good recipes (like these!), but these drop cookies all follow the same method: cream, mix and bake.
But recently I stumbled upon an an internet phenomenon that goes one step further than basic drop cookies: pan bang cookies. This cookie, created by Sarah Kieffer of the Vanilla Bean Blog, takes chocolate chip cookies to a new level by literally banging the cookie sheet in the oven to create ripply, crispy chocolate chippers. When I saw this fresh take, I knew that I had to try it for myself. After all, I’ve tried every other chocolate chip cookie recipe—maybe this one would be my new favorite.
The Internet Famous Recipe
Any baker knows that all chocolate chip cookie recipes have nearly identical ingredients—typically it’s just the proportions that differ. And looking at the famous pan bang cookie recipe, I noticed the normal cast of characters: butter, eggs, sugar, brown sugar, flour.
Here’s exactly what you need to mix up these pan banging cookies:
2 cups all-purpose flour
1 cup butter, softened
1 egg
1½ cups granulated sugar
¼ cup packed brown sugar
2 tablespoons water
1½ teaspoons pure vanilla extract
¾ teaspoon salt
½ teaspoon baking soda
6 ounces bittersweet chocolate, chopped into bite-size pieces
Yields 12 cookies
Now you may have noticed a few differences between this and your standard Tollhouse recipe. What stood out to me was the addition of water and also using chopped chocolate instead of chips. But there’s certainly a method to all this madness, so let’s get into it!
Prepping for Pan Banging
Mixing up these cookies is just like any other standard drop cookie. First, cream together sugars and butter. Once light and fluffy, add vanilla, egg and water. When those ingredients are incorporated, mix in your dry components: flour, salt and baking soda. Finish it all off by stirring in the chopped up chocolate.
Now, the standard protocol for these cookies is over! Rather than lining a baking tray with parchment, the recipe recommends lining your cookie sheet with aluminum foil—dull side up—for crispier cookies. That was easy enough for me. The recipe goes on: Instead of dropping dough by the tablespoon onto the sheet, it recommends a whopping 1/3 cup of dough per cookie. I love cookies, so the bigger the better. Knowing that these would spread after wiggling, jiggling and banging the pan, I played it safe and only scooped two per sheet. Spoiler alert: This was the right idea.
Now, these cookies weren’t ready for baking (or pan banging) quite yet. Before popping them into a 350ºF oven, they require a 15 minute stay in the freezer.
The Bake
After their time in the freezer, these cookies go into a 350ºF oven for 10 minutes. During this time, the cookies spread a lot—like a lot a lot. I’m glad that I stuck with my baking instincts and only put two on each sheet, otherwise I’d be dealing with a real mess (but I wasn’t too worried—we’ve got this great hack for cleaning up even the dirtiest pans).
Once those 10 minutes were up, the recipe told me do something so counterintuitive to me: bang the pan against the oven rack. I’d never heard of this method in any other chocolate chip recipe (or any other recipe, for that matter). But I went ahead and grabbed the cookie sheet with some hot pads and gave it a few good whacks on the wire rack. Right away I could see that the bit of puffiness and lift the cookies had, disappeared. I could also see a few ripples forming around the edge. I was on the right track.
Of course one ripple does not make perfectly crinkly cookies. So every two minutes for the next six to eight minutes (that’s a total baking time of 16-18 minutes—16 for chewier cookies, 18 for crispy), I repeated this pan banging method. Each time I could see a new ripple form.
Once out of the oven, let them cool five minutes on the cookie sheet before moving to a wire rack to cool completely.
The Instagram-worthy Results
Pulling these out of the oven, I was pretty impressed with how they looked. First and foremost, these cookies were giant—at least the size of a saucer. When it comes to cookies, I’m a firm believer that bigger is better. What I noticed next was how beautiful that ripply pattern looked and how tempting those bits of chopped chocolate were peeking through the dough. It turns out that taking that extra step to chop chocolate, rather than using chips, helped give the cookies their beautiful texture (chips would have interfered with the crinkling).
But enough about the look. How do these giant cookies taste? Well, I suppose it goes without saying that these cookies were tasty (aren’t they all?). The rippled edges were super crisp—perfect for crunchy cookie lovers. And the center was just a touch chewy, giving me (and my taste-testing friends) the best of both worlds. For those looking for a cookie that’s crisp through and through, I’d recommend baking them the full 18 minutes; if you like that bit of softness in the middle like me, don’t go over 16.
Overall, I’d say that these pan bang cookies were a successful addition to my chocolate chip cookie repertoire. Full of pretty ripples and hand-chopped chocolate, these look a lot like something you might find at nice bakery. Also, let’s not forget that size! The only drawback to these giant cookies is how much babysitting they require. The freezing, the banging, the getting up every two minutes to rattle the pan—it can be a lot if you’re just looking to whip up a quick recipe. So my recommendation is to save this one for a lazy Sunday afternoon so you can relax and enjoy the process (and the results!). In the end, though, I’d say these pan bang cookies are a must-keep recipe! Check out more of Sarah Kieffer’s work at, The Vanilla Bean Blog.
Craving comfort food in a hurry? Grab a box! We snagged seven to find the best boxed mac and cheese.
Big Soft Ginger Cookies
When you want a ginger cookie but nothing as crunchy as a gingersnap, these big softies are nicely spiced and taste fantastic with a cup of tea. When baking, don’t forget to use parchment paper for picture-perfect cookies.
Big & Buttery Chocolate Chip Cookies
An essential classic cookie recipe, this version results in thick and chewy cookies studded with lots of semisweet chips and crunchy walnuts. It's also super adaptable to other chocolate and nut combinations. 
Old-Fashioned Peanut Butter Cookies
An easy recipe made with pantry staples, this is the kind of cookie to whip out when you just feel like making cookies. Readers suggest using natural peanut butter for a more peanut-y taste, and try pressing with a glass that has a decorative bottom instead of criss-crossing with a fork. 
Cakes and Cookies Contest
Are your baked goods more than just good? We’ll gladly take a bite out of your best. Our recipe boxes are ready for your luscious tiramisu crepe cake, crispy gingerbread pizzelles, vibrant matcha cheesecake, dreamy Orangesicle-inspired macarons and so much more. So send us your favorite cakes and cookies, fresh from the oven (or icebox or stovetop), with fewer than 12 ingredients, and you could win big and be featured in Taste of Home.
Jumbo Brownie Cookies
Get your essential cookie supplies in order and make these deeply fudgy cookies for any party or potluck—or just for you. The trick is adding a little espresso powder to the dough to really bring out the chocolate flavor. 
Vanilla Meringue Cookies
Meringue cookies are delightfully sweet and light, and they can be made into so many different flavors (although vanilla is just perfect). If you haven’t worked with meringue too much, we have lots of tips—like make sure the egg whites are room temperature—to make these just right. 
First-Place Coconut Macaroons
When baking coconut macaroons, it’s important to control the moisture so they don’t spread too much on the cookie sheet. You’ll have nice and craggy, chewy cookies in no time. 
Peppermint Meltaways
These festive cookies are a great addition to any Christmas cookie platter or gift box. And it’s right there in the name: These little pepperminty treats simply melt in your mouth. 
Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies
You only need five ingredients and a short amount of time to make these classic peanut butter-and-chocolate treats. While milk chocolate kisses are the standard, you can experiment with other flavors, like white chocolate swirled kisses. 
Coffee Shortbread
A crisp, buttery coffee-flavored shortbread drizzled with white and semisweet chocolate is like a morning mocha in cookie form. To keep the dough from sticking on the counter or your rolling pin, tuck it between two sheets of parchment paper for easy smoothing. 
Pecan Meltaways
To ensure the proper melt-away texture of pecan meltaways, chill your cookie dough like you would for cutout cookies. It will help keep them from spreading too much on the baking sheet. 
Raspberry Ribbons
Like a buttery shortbread with a sweet jam, these “ribbon” cookies make a lovely addition to any dessert table. Because they’re filled with jam and cut after baking, they are more delicate. Shipping these for the holidays or special occasions is not advised. 
White Velvet Cutouts
This super soft and buttery cookie really tastes what white velvet feels like. With cream cheese in the dough, the texture and flavor can’t be beat. They shape easily and icing can be any color you want, so they’re good year-round! 
Contest-Winning Chocolate Truffle Cookies
The key to getting a puffy cookie with a rich, soft, chocolatey center is chilling the dough for at least three hours; it prevents the cookies from getting too flat while baking. You really want this to be almost truffle-like inside, and the slightly domed shape helps with that. 
Scottish Shortbread
A ribbon-winning family recipe, this classic Scottish shortbread is everything you want it to be: buttery, just crispy and wonderfully sweet. Instead of chilling the dough before rolling, you’ll chill it after rolling and cutting so it can go straight to the oven. Cherry Chocolate Nut Cookies
Like other great drop cookie recipes, these are studded with extra ingredients, like bright red maraschino cherries, chocolate chips and pecans. They’re pretty enough for a holiday cookie box yet simple for everyday snacking. 
Amish Sugar Cookies
These old-fashioned Amish sugar cookies are delightfully tender and easy to make. Make them your own by adding a touch of extract (almond is delicious!) or a sprinkle of coarse sugar on top. To get the best results, follow these tips for baking sugar cookies. 
Chippy Peanut Butter Cookies
This classic peanut butter cookie is made even better with the addition of chocolate and peanut butter chips. Use a small ice cream scooper to get consistently sized cookies on the baking sheet. Chewy Chocolate Cookies
Chocolate and chocolate, what can be better? This wonderful chocolate drop cookie gets extra lusciousness from semisweet chocolate chips inside. But you can use a darker chip for more chocolatey depth. 
White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Cookies
A ringer for the famous name brand cookie you’d buy in the grocery store, this buttery cookie is chock full of white chocolate chips and macadamia nuts. Tip: If you use unsalted nuts, you might want to add a pinch of salt to the cookie dough. 
Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies
Chocolate chips add some pizzazz to chewy oatmeal cookies. If you prefer a bolder flavor, use dark brown sugar instead of light (although both work perfectly well in this classic recipe). 
Snickerdoodles
The name alone brings a smile to your face. The beauty of a snickerdoodle is you probably already have all the ingredients on hand—no running to the grocery store when the craving strikes! Carefully watch them while baking; an extra second or two can make a crispier cookie. 
S’more Sandwich Cookies
Such a genius move: Pop half of these sandwich cookies in the microwave topped with a marshmallow for a few seconds, then smoosh with another cookie. The dough has graham cracker crumbs for real s’mores flavor.
Mimosa Butter Cookies
Spiked with sparkling wine and orange juice, this butter cookie recipe has a brunch-y twist. To help the uncooked dough hold its shape, use parchment paper and chill the piped cookies for about 10 minutes before hitting the oven. 
Thumbprint Butter Cookies
Filled with any fruit preserve you like, these buttery little cookies add beautiful color to any platter of treats. They’re super versatile for the holidays or any time of year. 
Toffee Almond Sandies
Studded with chocolate-covered toffee and almond bits, these delightful sandies hit all the high notes. They’re not too crumbly or dry, and they have a nice nutty flavor, which you can amp up with a little extra extract if desired. 
Iced Orange Cookies
This old-fashioned drop cookie gets topped with a sweet, citrus-scented icing. A little zest and a dab of orange food coloring really brightens things up. 
Chocolate Mexican Wedding Cakes
An alternative to the traditional favorite, these Mexican wedding cakes are packed with cocoa and a hint of cinnamon. Covered in powdered sugar, they make great holiday gifts. 
Crisp Sugar Cookie Mix
Put bags of this pre-made mix along with instructions on how to bake the cookies together for gifts. With butter, eggs and extra sugar for decorating, the crisp sugar cookies couldn’t be easier to make at home. Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Every cookie recipe box should have an oatmeal raisin contender. The secret to this recipe is to measure exactly and not over bake to ensure a chewy, fruit-filled treat. 
Lemon Tea Cookies
A deliciously delicate butter cookie filled with a lemon-scented filling is perfect for afternoon tea. Note that the dough needs to chill, preferably overnight; so plan your prep and bake time accordingly. Miniature Peanut Butter Treats
Slip a mini peanut butter cup in still-warm cookies for this fantastic treat. Think about using mini heart-shaped candies for a sweet hit of love on Valentine’s Day.
Frosted Red Velvet Cookies
Red velvet cake in bite-size cookie form? Sign us up! You’ll find chocolate chips in every bite, and sprinkles on the sweet icing (store bought is fine, or make your own with this quick cream cheese frosting recipe). 
Lemon Snowflakes
You only need four ingredients for this cookie recipe—and one is cake mix, so you know it's easy. It's super adaptable, too: Start with lemon and then try other flavors by using chocolate, vanilla, strawberry or spice cake mix. Cranberry Cookies with Browned Butter Glaze
Brown butter makes everything better, including the glaze that tops these chunky cookies. Use fresh cranberries instead of dried, which are usually sweetened. Fresh gives these a tart zingy bite that pairs well with white chocolate chips and nuts. 
White Chocolate Pistachio and Cranberry Biscotti
While not specifically a holiday treat, crunchy biscotti dappled with white chocolate, pistachios and sweet dried cranberries makes a fantastic gift around Christmastime. Make it easier on yourself and bake batches ahead and freeze the cookies until you’re ready to serve or pack up. 
Dipped Gingersnaps
Like the name implies, these spiced cookies should snap when you bite them, as opposed to being soft and chewy. Dip in or swirl melted white chocolate on top for a pretty decorative effect. 
Lemony Gingerbread Whoopie Pies
Never mind the debate over whether whoopie pies are cakes or cookies (they’re really cake-like cookies, so both sides win). These cookies are spiced just right. Roll the dough in sugar before baking for extra crunch. The lemony filling pairs nicely with the ginger. 
Chocolate Caramel Thumbprints
A soft chocolate cookie dough gets a coating in chopped pecans before hitting the oven. After, a pool of caramel gets added to the indentation and melted chocolate drizzled on top. Butter Cookies
Give that new cookie press a whirl with this simple and delicious butter cookie recipe. Use any shape, although hearts are most charming, and top with your favorite frosting. 
Lime & Gin Coconut Macaroons
A touch of aromatic gin and lime zest add a unique flavor to these wonderfully chewy coconut treats. Remember: Macaroons are different from macarons, the French meringue sandwich cookie, but both are totally delicious.
Fudgy Mint Cookies
When you don’t have a lot of time to fuss with a cookie recipe, this one has you covered. Made with chocolate cake mix and a thin chocolate-covered mint candy pressed into it, this decadent cookie practically makes itself. 
Cranberry Oatmeal Cookies
Instead of raisins, add sweet dried cranberries to this oatmeal cookie recipe. That little bit of tartness really elevates each chewy cookie. 
Gluten-Free Peanut Butter Kiss Cookies
Swap in gluten-free flour for regular to make this classic cookie recipe, and use crunchy peanut butter for even more peanut flavor. For a change of pace, press in a peanut butter cup in the center instead of a kiss. 
Banana Chocolate Chip Cookies
With a soft cake-like texture and lots of sweet banana flavor, this is one of the best ways to use up overripe fruit. Add a 1/2 cup toasted pecans or walnuts to the batter for some crunch. 
Almond Spritz Cookies
A little almond extract goes a long way with these buttery spritz cookies. Use colored sugar to match the holiday: pink and yellow for Easter, and red and green for Christmas. 
Giant Molasses Cookies
Could a cookie name be any more perfect? These are in fact giant cookies, sweetened with molasses and spice, and sugared for a little sparkle. They’re soft, chewy and even ship well, making them a great holiday gift.
Here's more on how to make molasses cookies. 
Coconut Clouds
These cakelike drop cookies have coconut inside and out. Brown butter, which serves as the base for the icing, pairs perfectly with shredded toasted coconut. Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies
While the peanut butter filling makes these sandwich cookies sweet and delicious, one commenter suggests filling them with dulce de leche spread. Now we can’t stop thinking of other fillings, like hazelnut spread, chocolate and more.
Tender Italian Sugar Cookies
Skirting the line between sugar cookie and shortbread, these little morsels are like a blank canvas for whatever extra flavors or colored icings you desire. Mini semisweet chocolate chips or a dash of almond extract in the dough? Sure! Red and green icing for Christmas? You bet! 
Chocolate Crinkle Cookies
Crinkles always look impressive, thanks to the powdered sugar the dough gets rolled in before baking. To make these your own, try adding dried cherries to the cookie dough, or peppermint extract and peppermint candy for a holiday twist.
