Chocolate-Covered Cherry Cookies

Reviews

• mskitty7499
  
  Mar 7, 2018

  This is one of my favorite cookies. Always a hit, wherever they are served.

• Grmmieof15
  
  Mar 6, 2018

  I have never heard of these cookies, and I am a Michiganier born and raised in Michigan these 76 years. But I love chocolate covered cherries !!! So I HAVE to try this recipe !! They sound so tasty!!

• Pokeymom56
  
  Feb 27, 2018

  In 1987, I found this exact recipe in a magazine given to me by a neighbor before I went to the hospital to have our fourth son. I have made this recipe every Christmas since, just as written. Perfection! Once, I found our 3 year old (that fourth child) eating a piece of burnt firewood from the fireplace, thinking it was a Chocolate Cherry Cookie. Today he is a pilot in the USAF and I send him these cookies wherever he happens to be.

• dcscake_OH
  
  Feb 1, 2018

  I make these on the holidays and on Valentines Day. They are always a hit. I make the frosting more like a glaze, so the cookie stands out. I also, if the dough comes out a little dry, add some milk or cherry juice. These are a great treat.

• Sherry
  
  Dec 25, 2017

  5 stars beautiful and delicious, adding to my Christmas repertoire. A chocolate covered cherry cookie.

• homemadewithlove
  
  Dec 24, 2017

  My family may have liked better if A chocolate drizzle over the cherry instead of covering with the frosting.

• Dee
  
  Dec 23, 2017

  Help, Help. I made this recipe exactly as printed. The cookies spread out to one big thin mess. The icing melted over the cherry and the cherry was left bare. An absolute MESS. Sorry, just reviewed by recipe and found that I messed up. Will try again

• Sharon
  
  Dec 13, 2017

  We have been making this cookie recipe for years. It is a family favorite! It wouldn't be Christmas without these! We make these the same way the recipe is written and they come out perfect every time!

• Robin
  
  Dec 4, 2017

  I have been making this cookie recipe for 4-5 years and I get specifically asked to make it at work every year for our Cookie exchange. Also my dad has had me handwrite it into one of his cook books, he loves it so much. The cookie base tastes like a brownie, and the frosting cherry make it a total piece of candy.The recipe works exactly as written, with putting the icing on before baking. I typically use a double-boiler to melt the chocolate to be safe and ensure I don't burn anything. To do that, just take a wide pan with a rim, put 2-3 inches of water in, put a folded washcloth on the bottom, and use metal bowl or small sauce pan ontop of the washcloth with the chocolate & milk inside. Putting a washcloth between the pans with the water works to break the heat transfer between vessels and is a tip I picked up from working at a bakery years ago. You don't need a special pan to do a double boiler.Second tip: make the cookie balls small in order to ensure you make 48. Slightly bigger than a quarter? That way they are bite size and it spreads the recipe out.Third tip: double the recipe. You will want more.

• Sue Zappa
  
  Nov 28, 2017

  First, Leslie, don't comment on a recipe you haven't tried. That's bad manners & misleading to others. Thank you. Second, these cookies have always been a huge hit with my family! We've raised six children, four of whom are now married. As our family grows in size with the addition of in-laws & grandchildren, these cookies grow in popularity, too. They're a bit messy to make, but well worth the effort! I made them during the year when we need a special chocolate treat too. I don't change a thing in the recipe!