Save on Pinterest

25 Magical Harry Potter-Inspired Recipes

Pay tribute to the beloved series with these delightful Harry Potter-themed recipes. Wizards and muggles alike will feel the magic!

1 / 25
Witches Brew Exps Thso18 138269 D04 25 5b 8

Witches' Brew

Feel like you’re in potions class with this bewitching beverage. For a nonalcoholic version, just omit the vodka.
2 / 25
Exps23866 Ff163882b01 13 8b 1

Hogwarts Acceptance Letters

You might not have gotten one when you turned eleven, but these savory puff pastry envelopes are magical enough to have come from Hogwarts.
3 / 25

Wingless Snitches

These eggnog-flavored snitches are so good, you’ll feel like you’ve won a Quidditch game with each bite.
4 / 25
Mother Lode Pretzels Exps34208 Th1193306d57b Rms 2


Fly away from hunger with this salty-sweet snack.
5 / 25

Owl Post Pops

While this friendly owl resembles poor Errol, use white sprinkles to make a snowy Hedwig.
6 / 25

Hogwarts Hats

Feel like a true Hogwarts student by decorating the hats with your house colors!
7 / 25
Chewy Good Oatmeal Cookies Exps159556 Th2379807a11 01 8bc Rms 5

Hagrid's Rock Cookies

As much as we love Hagrid, he wasn’t the best baker. Lucky, these cookies have all of flavor of Hargrid’s but won’t break your teeth!
8 / 25

'Cockroach' Clusters

This badly named candy is a favorite at Honeydukes. Our version of these delightfully crunchy treats is made with pecans and rice cereal.
9 / 25
Jelly Bean Bark Exps22470 Th143191d11  13 8bc Rms 5

Bertie Bott's Every Flavor Jelly Bean Bark

Get multiple flavors in each bite with this new twist on the famous “Every Flavor” jelly beans. Watch out for bogey-flavored ones.
10 / 25
Butterscotch Mulled Cider Exps Scbz20 50401 E07 15 4b 8

Warm Butterbeer

Grab a cozy mug inspired by one of Harry’s favorite drinks. To make this drink for kids, swap the shnapps for butterscotch ice cream topping.
11 / 25
Exps 34638 Uh153291b05 01 8b 3

Polyjuice Potion

While the real polyjuice potion takes a month (and a few human hairs) to brew, this deliciously sweet version takes moments to make.
12 / 25
Neapolitan Fudge Exps62236 Hc2379809b12 16 5b Rms 3

Weasley Skiving Snacks

Tricky Hogwarts students use these treats to get out of class (they make you ill, and then well in the next bite). This version won’t get you out of class (or work), but they’re just as sweet.
13 / 25
Chocolate Caramel Cupcakes Exps17377 Cc2919384b09 21 7b Rms 1

Cauldron Cakes

Transport yourself to the Hogwarts Express with these chocolate and caramel cupcakes, a classic in Harry’s world.
14 / 25

Dumbledore's Sherbet Lemon

Dumbledore loved this sweet-tart treat so much, “sherbet lemon” was the password to his office!
15 / 25
Exps Hbz16 178192 C05 05 2b 1

Slytherin Snake

This serpentine sandwich isn’t nearly as scary as the Basilisk. No Godric Gyffindor’s Sword required to slice this one up.
16 / 25
Pumpkin Pie Smoothies Exps Sdon16 145412 A06 07 6b 5

Pumpkin Pie Smoothies

A sweeter, frostier version of good ol’ pumpkin juice, which pairs with almost every meal at Hogwarts.
17 / 25

Aragog's Followers

Aragog’s minions threaten to devour Harry and Ron, until the intervention of Mr. Weasley’s feral car. Turn the tables and devour a plateful of tiny spiders at your next party.
18 / 25
Quick Easy Gumdrops Exps176760 Th143190b10 09 5bc Rms

Honeydukes Gumdrops

A trip to Hogsmede wouldn’t be complete without a trip to Honeydukes, and a Harry Potter celebration wouldn’t be complete without these gumdrops!
19 / 25

Canary Cremes

Inspired by another invention of the Weasley twins, but our version won’t turn you into a canary.
20 / 25
Mamaw Emily S Strawberry Cake Exps Frbz19 82745 C01 31 4b 9

Harry's Birthday Cake

All you need to add is Hargrid’s “HAPPEE BIRTHDAE HARRY” in green frosting to recreate Harry’s 11th birthday cake.
21 / 25
Coconut Creme Chocolates Exps37301 Th143190b10 10 3bc Rms

Exploding Bonbons

Exploding with coconut, that is!
22 / 25

Mini Treacle Tarts

Feel like you’re at a feast in the Great Hall with these delicious tarts.
23 / 25

Never-Ending Ice Cream

Harry eats countless bowls of ice cream at Florean Fortescue’s Ice-Cream Parlour. You can try to do the same with this easy ice cream recipe.
24 / 25

Acid Pops

While the Honeydukes version of lollipops can burn a hole in your tongue, ours are certified Muggle safe.
25 / 25
Cherry Chocolate Layer Cake Exps49124 Thca2916394c11 12 6bc Rms 4

Aunt Petunia's Pudding

In Britain, a “pudding” is any dessert. The one Aunt Petunia makes to impress Uncle Vernon’s boss is a tall, frosted, fussy confection, something like this pink cake. Top with piped flowers and cherries for the full effect.

Make sure you don’t miss our Harry Potter gifts for the kitchen that’ll make you say “Accio”! and learn how to brew the best butterbeer recipe outside of Universal Studio.

Caroline Stanko
As Editor, Caroline writes and edits all things food-related and helps produce videos for Taste of Home. When she’s not at her desk, you can probably find Caroline cooking up a feast, planning her next trip abroad or daydreaming about her golden retriever, Mac.

Newsletter Unit

CMU Unit

Subscribe & SAVE Save Up To 80%!