Lemon Lover’s Cookies
Total TimePrep: 20 min. + chilling Bake: 10 min./batch + cooling
MakesAbout 3-1/2 dozen
After reading the reviews I made a couple of changes to this recipe. I added extra lemon zest to the cookies and frosting. I also waited till the second day to frost them. We didn't detect any chalky taste. The cookies are very tender and melt in your mouth.
These cookies were just weird with all that cornstarch, but hubby actually liked them, even without the frosting.
Great recipe, quick and easy to make. Be generous with the lemon rind, they came out milder than I expected. And as other reviewers noted, they taste better the second day.
A very fragile cookie. I tasted one of them when it broke apart. It left a very chalky taste in my mouth (definitely the cornstarch). I waited 24 hours before I frosted them. What a difference. No chalky taste!!
A word of warning: These cookies are awesome, but not as written. The ORIGINAL recipe is the same except it calls for 3 Tbsp of sugar not, 1/3 cup powdered sugar. That will probably alleviate the crumbling problem others are having. Make that change and try these, they are really good.
I have this recipe from a a Taste of Home cookies and bars magazine. It calls for 3 Tablespoons of regular sugar not one third cup confectioners sugar. I think that Amight be why some peopleTT are having problems with this cookie. Also after i mix the batter with the electric mixer then i mix it with my hands. The warmth of your hands melts the butter and it becomes more like regular cookie dough, not crumbs. The cookies get great every time i make them and i always get a lot of compliments from everyone that tries them. This is my most treasured cookie recipe! Also make sure you use real lemons to get your lemon juice and lemon peel. The only difference in the recipe i use and this recipe posted online is the sugar to make the dough. The frosting ingredients are the same.
Wow...What a huge disappointment. I should have come here first to read the reviews. Is the 1/2 cup cornstarch correct?? They taste like cornstarch and crumbled to dust when touched. I can't imagine that they could hold frosting on them! They went in the trash before it got that far.
We will not make these again. They fell apart into powder. Very disappointing! We keep re-reading the recipe thinking surely we left something out.
just like some others said, these cookies fell apart, some while removing from pan, others while I was trying to ice them. Taste good. Might try to reduce the cornstarch and increase the flour next time to see if this helps.
Here's my update...According to the magazine recipe (which I follow, but double) use 3 Tbsp sugar and 1-1/4c flour. Follow the rest of the recipe but cool the cookies completely on pans on wire racks (I personally use parchment paper and slide the whole sheet off onto a rack after cooling for about 5 minutes so I can start another batch right away).A tip for forming the cookies...have a long piece of plastic wrap on the counter that you pour the dough on to. The dough will be very dry and powdery (enough so that once I thought I had done something wrong, pitched it and started over). Wrap the plastic wrap around the dough and use your hands to form the roll. The heat from your hands will soften the butter in the dough, helping it to pack together to form a log. I hope this helps all of you who are having problems with this recipe. They are fragile cookies, but that is part of the appeal, as they seem to melt in your mouth. They are so worth the effort. I am by no means an expert cook/baker, just a lemon lover who gave these a try and wish I could share them with the whole world!