Chocolate-Dipped Spumoni Cookies
I combined my favorite cookie and ice cream into one dessert. With so many delicious flavors going on, it's hard to eat just one. — Erica Ingram, Lakewood, Ohio
Ingredients
- 1 cup butter, softened
- 3/4 cup sugar
- 3/4 cup packed brown sugar
- 2 large eggs
- 1 tablespoon vanilla extract
- 2-1/2 cups all-purpose flour
- 1/2 cup Dutch-processed cocoa
- 3/4 teaspoon baking soda
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 1-1/3 cups finely chopped pistachios, divided
- 1-1/3 cups finely chopped dried cherries, divided
- 1-3/4 cups semisweet chocolate chips
- 1 tablespoon shortening
Reviews
I'm glad I read the reviews first! YES!!?? Baking soda is NOT to be used with Dutched Processed Cocoa, Baking Powder ONLY! This is a definite error in the recipe. When using Dutch Processed Cocoa, it is imperative you would to have to double the amount of baking powder (from baking soda) to 2 teaspoons instead of one for leavening and lightness (unless you want a heavy cookie.) I suggest to the chef to edit the recipe, per comments made. Thanks for a great cookie, though. Petite Chef Ann.
I am not a pastry chef and do not know the "culinary" rules behind Dutch process cocoa and have used it in many different applications, because of it's superior chocolate flavor, with no issues. But thank you for the advise, maybe all of the recipes I have used it in could be even better!
I'd like to address the baking soda vs baking powder comments. You can use baking soda with Dutch process cocoa but you need to have another acid somewhere in the recipe. In this case, i believe the brown sugar would act as your acid so this would be just fine. I like to use the Dutch process as I like the flavor better so I've incorpoarted acids in other recipes and they work just fine.
marybee66, you are correct, you should use baking powder with dutch process cocoa powder not the baking soda called for in the recipe. I only have regular cocoa so I am going to try the recipe with that as written ( with one teaspoon baking soda) .I will let you know how they turn out! ~- Marmalady***** Ok, I just baked a batch with regular cocoa, I also used craisins instead of the dried cherries and added a little cinnamon and grated orange zest. The cookies were fine with regular cocoa and baking soda (as in recipe). Nice and soft. They aren't fantastic though, definitely lacking in buttery quality and flavor even with the additions. For the price of shelled pistachios not worth it at all, there is no pistachio flavor. I was going to gift these but I don't think I will now.
I'm anxious to try this recipe because it sounds so good, but have read that Dutch processed cocoa should NOT be used with baking soda. According to the "experts" it should only be used with baking powder and regular cocoa should NOT be substituted. So, is this recipe in error? I don't want to waste my time/ingredients if this is wrong. Help, please!