11 Pie Plates We Want to Get Our Hands On
It's always time for tasty homemade pies to be popping out of ovens! Let us help find the best pie plate for your signature bake.
Every product is independently selected by our editors. If you buy something through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission.
Emile Henry Ceramic Pie Dish
Any pie will shine in a classic Emile Henry stoneware pie dish ($40), especially in this brilliant shade of cherry red. Plus, crusts bake up crisp and flaky, and the dish can withstand high temperatures for broiling meringues or browning savory dishes.
Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Pie Plate
The author of the Pie and Pastry Bible knows a thing or two about perfect pies! Her pie plate ($25) features an extra-wide fluted edge—which makes it easy to put a dramatic, decorative edge on your pie crusts. This lip also makes the dish easy to pull from the oven and gives extra support to mile-high pies.
Taste of Home Stoneware Pie Plate
Make one of our top 10 pie recipes in a Taste of Home stoneware pie plate. On the edges, you’ll find a pretty embossed design as well as serving markers, taking the guesswork out of serving sizes every time.
Camp Cast-Iron Pie Pan
Cast iron conducts heat nicely. For your pie, this means a beautifully browned crust with no soggy bottom! (See what Mary Berry means by “soggy bottom.”) This cast-iron pie pan ($21) comes preseasoned and ready to use in your home or outdoor oven.
Pyrex Easy Grab Glass Plate
Over 400 5-star reviews tell us that this ubiquitous glass pie plate is the go-to for home pie bakers. These economical Pyrex dishes ($17 for two) can go anywhere—fridge, freezer, oven, microwave, dishwasher. They have a cute, scalloped edge, allow you to bake up a lovely pie and they last forever. Sold!
Speckled Enameled Tin Plate
I love the homey look of this speckly dish. And because it’s lightweight, this enamelware plate ($18) makes it easy to transport your best pie to a picnic, the neighborhood BBQ or the potluck.
Portmeirion Rectangular Pie Dish
Your pies are works of art, and this unique dish brings a touch of artistic flair. This rectangular pie dish ($15) has a beautiful, pastel mint finish and a hand-thrown look. The shape and depth are perfect for your favorite slab pie recipes.
Pi Day Pie Plate
It’s the perfect dish for the pie baker/mathematician in your life. Celebrate Pi Day on March 14th with this fun pie plate ($25) that has the first 100 numerals of pi running around the rim. The symbol for pi is revealed as each slice is eaten.
Here’s another nice number: 100. As in 100 Pies to Eat on Pi Day!
Calphalon Nonstick Mini Pie Pans
These are perfect for mini chicken pot pies or individual apple pies. These mini pans from Calphalon ($20 for four) are built to last and better yet—they’re nonstick. The baked pies will release easily for a beautiful presentation. And… they’re also very cute!