Grandma’s Sugar Cookies

Reviews

• Christine
  
  Jun 17, 2017

  Would use flour on your rolling surface a little at a time- you don't want tough cookies. Chilling the cookies for about 10 minutes after you cut them out helps them retain their shape too,

• rebelene57
  
  Mar 29, 2013

  Good flavor, easy to make, BUT didn't hold their shape at ALL. All the cookies ran together; useless to decorate as the shapes I cut. Waste of time, now I have to make a different recipe this AM. Only make if you don't care how they look.

• CarlyCooker
  
  Mar 29, 2013

  To print without the ad on the side, copy and paste to a word document. Then delete the ad and print.

• sullivantx
  
  Mar 28, 2013

  The flour at 3 c. is correct. When you roll out the dough, you use a liberal amount of flour on the board and sprinkle on top so it doesn't stick. The dough works this flour in. If you put more flour in, then roll out on the flour, it will be too much and make a tough cookie. Please remember, in Grandma's day, that was how you made cut-out cookies. I made these and they turned out perfect, using probably 1/4 c. flour on the dough board. They don't last long enough to decorate! Unfortunately I do not have my grandmother's recipe, but this is close -- regardless, they are great!

• terriv17
  
  Mar 28, 2013

  Could anyone tell me how to print this recipe without the "only 3 ingredients" on the side of the page? It is for the full page size. If you delete the photos it takes it off but it also takes off the picture of the cookies.

• angelnurse2
  
  Mar 26, 2013

  Sugar cookies are my favorite so I am always comparing recipes. I just made a similar recipe and it was awesome. If you cut down the sugar to 1 cup and use one egg I think it will turn out for you.

• darlene_Mart
  
  Aug 28, 2012

  I used the recipe with the 3 cups of flour and the cookies did not hold their shape. The dough was chilled the night before. Cookies taste great but do not hold their shape? Is there a mistake in recipe?

• KScales
  
  Jan 25, 2012

  We have reviewed this recipe again and increased the flour to 3 cups. It has been corrected on the recipe. That will help the cookies keep their shape better. We apologize for the error.Taste of Home Test Kitchen

• diananimagoo
  
  Dec 23, 2010

  this cookie spreads way to much and it make for an ugly cookie I don't know how it made it to this sight!!

• Carolyn_Joyce
  
  Dec 2, 2009

  These cookies have a great taste but they do not hold their shape while baking. It was disappointing. Have you tried these in your test kitchen. Would like to know if they worked for you.