Save on Pinterest

9 Homemade Coffee Creamers

There's no better way to start the day than with a cup of coffee. Spice up your morning routine with some of these homemade coffee creamers—some of them are even dairy-free!

1 / 9
Honey Spiced Coffee CreamerTaste of Home

Honey Spiced Coffee Creamer

Give your coffee a boost of sweetness with this Honey Spiced Coffee Creamer. It’s light (thanks to the use of regular milk instead of heavy cream), but it’s also rich and comforting. You’ll love the flavors of rich molasses, golden honey, and warming spices.

2 / 9
Confessions of an Overworked Mom

Bailey’s Irish Cream Non-Alcoholic Irish Coffee Creamer


There’s nothing better than enjoying a leisurely Sunday brunch with a boozy coffee, but that doesn’t work so well the rest of the week. Thanks to this recipe from Confessions of an Overworked Mom, you can enjoy the flavors of Bailey’s Irish Cream coffee without adding any of the alcohol! Weekday mornings just got a whole lot better.

Get the recipe here.

3 / 9
A Latte Food

Peppermint Mocha Creamer


This inexpensive creamer from A Latte Food is one of our favorites. We don’t know which component we love more: the rich, chocolatey flavor from the cocoa powder or the refreshing finish of peppermint extract. Luckily, we don’t have to choose!

Get the recipe here.

4 / 9
Saltnpepperhere

Hazelnut Dairy-Free Coffee Creamer


There’s so much to love about this dairy-free, Paleo-friendly coffee creamer from Saltnpepperhere. You basically make a rich and creamy almond milk before sweetening it up with maple syrup and hazelnut extract. It takes a few extra steps, but it’s totally worth it!

Get the recipe here.

5 / 9
Don't Waste the Crumbs

Vanilla Bean


Don’t Waste the Crumbs’ Vanilla Bean Coffee Creamer does not mess around. It’s packed full of sweet and aromatic vanilla flavor because you use both vanilla extract and add extra vanilla powder. You won’t be sorry you chose this liquid celebration to start your day!

Get the recipe here.

6 / 9
fooduzzi

Dairy-Free Gingerbread Coffee Creamer


Pumpkin Spice gets all the attention in the fall, but I think gingerbread deserves its time in the limelight! This coffee creamer from Fooduzzi is like a hug-in-a-mug, filled with rich molasses and warming ginger. All in a tasty, dairy-free package!

Get the recipe here.

7 / 9
French Vanilla Coffee CreamerTaste of Home

French Vanilla Coffee Creamer

We love the simplicity of this four-ingredient coffee creamer recipe from blogger Shauna Sever. The sweetened condensed milk takes the place of multiple ingredients, giving the mixture a rich and decadent texture. It’s simple but delicious.

8 / 9
Foxes Love Lemons

Brûlée Caramel Coffee


Have you ever had the Caramel Brulée Latte from Starbucks? Foxes Loves Lemons took all of those flavors and boiled them down into an easy-to-make homemade coffee creamer! The recipe only makes two servings, but it’s so good we think you’ll want to double it up!

Get the recipe here.

9 / 9
Pumpkin Pie Coffee CreamerTaste of Home

Pumpkin Pie Coffee Creamer

It doesn’t get easier than this stir-in coffee creamer. It’s shelf stable and you can store it in the pantry for up to a year! Unlike other pumpkin spiced lattes, this creamer doesn’t actually have any squash in it: just the warming spices of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, cloves, and allspice.

Popular Videos