Save on Pinterest

Sugar-Free Easter Candy to Add to Your Easter Basket

Not doing sugar? No problem! Get your chocolate and jelly bean fix with our fave picks for sugar-free Easter candy.

Every editorial product is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links. Ratings and prices are accurate and items are in stock as of time of publication.

1 / 10
Russell Stover Sugar-Free Pecan Delightsvia

Russell Stover Sugar-Free Pecan Delights

If your Easter morning memories involve waking up to rich chocolate treats in your pretty Easter basket, grab these sugar-free pecan clusters before they sell out. Crunchy pecans covered in chewy caramel and chocolate…yum!

Shop Now

2 / 10
Jelly Belly Sugar-Free Assorted Flavor Jelly Beansvia

Jelly Belly Sugar-Free Assorted Flavor Jelly Beans

It wouldn’t be Easter without a bag of colorful jelly beans; yes, even those buttered popcorn ones. Jelly Belly packs all of their favorite flavors without the sugar into this variety pack. Fill your basket with this treat plus these genius Easter basket stuffers that aren’t candy.

Shop Now

3 / 10
Reese's Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Cups Miniaturesvia

Reese’s Sugar-Free Peanut Butter Cups Miniatures

Miniature Reese’s cups are the perfect size for stuffing plastic Easter eggs. They also pack all that chocolate peanut butter deliciousness with no sugar and fewer calories than the original. (Psst! Find other healthy candy options to throw into your basket this year.)

Shop Now

4 / 10
Russell Stover Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Orange Bitesvia

Russell Stover Sugar-Free Dark Chocolate Orange Bites

Get a taste of springy sunshine with Russell Stover sugar-free orange bites. Sweetened with stevia, these chocolate bites are the perfect size for snacking before Easter brunch.

Shop Now

5 / 10
YORK Sugar-Free Peppermint Pattiesvia

YORK Sugar-Free Peppermint Patties

Easter morning calls for chocolate and lots of it. Satisfy your craving with sugar-free peppermint patties. That crisp, minty bite is the perfect complement to the pounds of jelly beans you’ll be grabbing next.

Shop Now

6 / 10
Russell Stover Sugar-Free Jelly Beansvia

Russell Stover Sugar-Free Jelly Beans

You can’t go wrong with a bag of colorful jelly beans in spring. Russell Stover sugar-free jelly beans make a cute Easter basket addition or thoughtful hostess gift.

Shop Now

7 / 10
JOLLY RANCHER Sugar-Free Hard Candyvia

JOLLY RANCHER Sugar-Free Hard Candy

Get all the tart sweetness you know and love from Jolly Rancher without the sugar. Their sugar-free hard candies are individually wrapped and perfect for stuffing Easter eggs or jazzing up platters of diabetic-friendly Easter desserts.

Shop Now

8 / 10
HERSHEY'S Sugar-Free Chocolate Barsvia

HERSHEY’S Sugar-Free Chocolate Bars

Sure, sure, Easter is a time to celebrate with family, but the chocolate definitely doesn’t hurt. If you’re steering clear of sugar this year, stock up on Hershey’s sugar-free chocolate bars for festive snacking.

Shop Now

9 / 10
Russell Stover Sugar-Free Chocolate-Covered Peanutsvia

Russell Stover Sugar-Free Chocolate-Covered Peanuts

Perfect for snacking on-the-go, Russell Stover sugar-free chocolate-covered peanuts are an easy and tasty Easter treat. They’re sweetened with stevia to keep all the flavor without extra calories.

Shop Now

10 / 10
Murray Sugar-Free Vanilla Creme Wafersvia

Murray Sugar-Free Vanilla Creme Wafers

There’s just something classic about biting into a light and crispy vanilla wafer cookie. Get a taste of your childhood—without the added sugar—with sugar-free wafers this year. And if you’re in a baking mood, whip up these sugar-free cupcakes.

Shop Now

Carrie Madormo, RN
Now a freelance health and food writer, Carrie worked as a nurse for over a decade. When she isn't hunched over her laptop with a baby in hand, you will find her cooking her grandmother’s recipes, lacing up her running shoes or sipping coffee in the bathroom to hide from her three young children.
Subscribe & SAVE Save Up To 80%!