These Easter egg stuffers for kids and adults alike prove that good things really do come in small packages!
Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.Learn more.
14 Best Easter Egg Stuffers That Are Small and Sweet
Updated on May 13, 2024
1
/
14
On Sale
Custom Beaded Bracelet
These nostalgic bracelets à la the early aughts bring serious Easter cheer. The customizable accessory comes in more than 40 colors and various sizes for children and adults. The wearer can’t help but think of you every time they slip it on! Discover more non-candy Easter basket fillers.
2
/
14
Wildflower Hearts
This Easter egg stuffer is sweet simplicity. The handmade paper hearts contain wildflower seeds, so they can be planted in their entirety for a gift that keeps on giving. The resulting blooms will make the recipient think of you for springs to come. (Psst! For a stress-free Easter, turn to these premade baskets.)
3
/
14
Caramels
Anyone would be sweet on these salty caramels! Individually wrapped, the rich, melt-in-your mouth morsels are made with locally sourced ingredients at a confectionary in Wisconsin. Sneak these in their baskets, and they’ll never settle for another Easter basket stuffer.
4
/
14
Corner Bookmarks
If you have a good read on your bookworm of a friend, then you know this corner bookmark is the gift for them. The patterned paper triangle slips over the corner of the page they’re reading so they can find their place again with ease.
5
/
14
Satin Ponytail Holder Set
Scrunchies are here to stay! This ponytail holder set comes in a number of color variations and is made of satin to reduce crimping of the hair. No braid, bun or pony is complete without this cute pop on top.
6
/
14
Tiny Hands Finger Puppets
An Easter basket addition for teens, these hilarious hand finger puppets will actually have them giggling. They even come in different signs, including the peace sign, thumbs up sign and rock ‘n’ roll sign.
7
/
14
Novelty Erasers
The plain white and pink varieties pale in comparison to these colorful cookie erasers. The adorable macarons look just like the real deal—and smell like them, too! These erasers for the little artists in your life are even scented with vanilla.
8
/
14
Moodibars
Give them all the feels—literally!—with these mood-themed Belgian chocolate bars that contain different flavors for when they’re happy, excited, cool, flirty, silly and beyond. We have a good guess as to how they’ll be feeling when they unwrap one of these!
9
/
14
Positivity Stickers
Bring some extra sunshine this Easter Sunday with uplifting stickers that look stylish placed on water bottles, laptops and notepads. The pack of 10 promotes positivity, kindness and self-assurance. What better gift is there than that?
10
/
14
Glitter Bouncy Balls
The quintessential Easter egg stuffer gets a bit of glitz with this 24-pack of eye-catching bouncy balls. They’ll love burning off all their Easter candy energy playing with this childhood classic (and you’ll love the easy entertainment). Check out these themed basket ideas for kids, too!
11
/
14
Mini Marshmallow Roasting Kit
It doesn’t get more creative—or cuter—than this miniature marshmallow roasting kit! The all-in-one matchbox comes with mini marshmallows, toothpicks, candles and instructions. Just use your own lighter for brûléed ‘mallows in the blink of an eye.
12
/
14
Nail Polish
The best Easter egg stuffer is right at your fingertips! These dainty bottles of nail polish pop with spring colors and complement every Easter outfit. Mani-pedi, anyone?
13
/
14
Crystal Paperweights
And for the crown jewel of their Easter basket: these gorgeous paperweights. A little princess could add the purple, yellow, blue, green or red crystals to her treasure trove, whereas a grown one could add them to her office space. Find more Easter basket picks from Amazon.
14
/
14
Tea Sachets
These elegant, individually-packaged triangular tea sachets ensure they’re as bright-eyed and bushy-tailed as the Easter Bunny! In tantalizing flavors, such as Mojito Marmalade, Cherry Cosmo and Apricot Amaretto, they’re a worthy Easter treat.
