Personalized Crayons
Creative kiddos will love waking up to a new set of crayons—especially when they spell out their name! Choose between bright pastels or primary colors, then pair with a Christmas coloring book.
Candy-Filled Ornaments
Gift this set to one lucky recipient. Or, split it between all of your kids’ stockings. Either way, the whole family will be impressed with this gorgeous holiday ornament collection. Each of the six whimsical baubles is stuffed with a sweet, tasty treat. (The milk chocolate cookies are an editor favorite!)
Mini Creatures 3-D Kits
Who wouldn’t want to build their own animal friend? Made of recycled cardboard, these petite puzzles are equal parts fun and challenging for kids ages 6 and up. Get creative in the kitchen with these kid-friendly Christmas recipes.
Family Christmas Pajamas
OK, these won’t fit in a stocking. But St. Nick’s Day is the perfect excuse to gift matching family Christmas pajamas. Plus, your little ones will get a lot more wear out of their festive ‘fits than if you wait until Christmas Eve. Want more? Browse these family Christmas pajamas to find your perfect fit.
Personalized Book
Celebrate the 12 Days of Christmas with this personalized children’s book. The sweet story and eye-catching illustrations include tons of hidden details and family names. Reading through this sentimental gift will become a treasured holiday tradition.
Holiday Hair Ties
With a price tag well under $5, you can’t go wrong with these cheerful holiday hair ties. They’re perfect for the girl who’s already rocking her holiday best.
Harry Potter Hot Cocoa Bomb
Don’t worry, this Golden Snitch hot cocoa bomb won’t fly away. Add it to a warm mug of milk and watch the magic happen! Check out these homemade St. Nick treats, too.
Nutcracker Puzzle
Gift your aspiring sugar plum fairy this dazzling holiday puzzle. It’s inspired by The Nutcracker ballet and, when finished, takes the shape of a holiday tree. Keep in mind that this 500-piecer is pretty complex, though, and should be reserved for older kids.
Chocolate Orange
We love St. Nick gifts rooted in tradition, and an orange is said to symbolize the gold St. Nicholas presented to needy families. This Terry’s Chocolate Orange is a sweet upgrade!
Hot Chocolate Mug
Whether it’s during a holiday movie marathon or after a cold day of sledding, this custom hot chocolate mug will get a lot of use. Choose between a ceramic mug, campfire mug or lidded travel mug, then add your little one’s name.
Cuddly Friend
How cute will this plush moose toy look peeking out of your child’s stocking? And, more importantly, how many hugs will he receive between now and Christmas? His super-soft fur and kid-friendly size will make “Marty the Moose” an instant favorite. This makes for a great gift for 1-year-olds, too.
Cindy Lou Who Apron
If your little one loves to help out in the kitchen, this kid-sized Cindy Lou Who apron is a practical addition to their stocking. She can wear it while decorating a gingerbread house or helping bake Christmas cookies. Kids who love food will enjoy these child-friendly cooking kits, too.
Seasonal Fidget Toys
For kids who need an outlet for anxiety, energy or stress, these pop fidget toys are great St. Nick gifts. We love the trio of cute, seasonal shapes.
Peppermint Pretzels
The whole family will enjoy digging into these tree-shaped peppermint pretzels. It’s a great option for when you need a snack trifecta: sweet, salty and festive!