Save on Pinterest

Your Guide to the Best Healthy Nut Butters

Not sure where to start? Use our guide to learn how and when to use the best healthy nut butters—including almond butter, PB and sunflower seed butter.

1 / 12
Homemade almond butter in jar on cutting board.Cegli/Shutterstock

Almond Butter

Compared to peanut butter, almond butter has about the same amount of protein per two tablespoons—right around 7 grams—while also packing seven times more calcium, as well as 50% more magnesium. Another one of the health benefits of almonds is the a higher level of monounsaturated fats, which can lower your LDL cholesterol levels.

Taste: Mild and creamy, and very easy to spread.

Uses: This butter works great as a schmear, or as a substitute for butter or oil in baked goods. You can also use it as one of your smoothie ingredients or to make soups a thicker consistency.

2 / 12
Creamy peanut butter with nuts on wooden textureVolosina/Shutterstock

Peanut Butter

Of course, no roundup of the best healthy nut butters would be complete without a nod to peanut butter. PB is a favorite among athletes and nutritionists, and for good reason—it’s got plenty of protein, and is high in poly- and monounsaturated fats for regulating your cholesterol.

Taste: Creamy, rich, classic.

Uses: Use peanut butter as a spread or a dip for fruits and vegetables. It’s also a great substitute for tahini in a hummus recipe, and will add a delicious boost to oatmeal, smoothies and baked goods.

Tired of having to stir your natural peanut butter? This trick will keep your peanut butter in perfectly balanced condition.

3 / 12
Healthy brand Creamy SoyNut Butter.Sheila Fitzgerald/Shutterstock

Soy Nut Butter

With peanut allergies on the rise, it’s important to have some good peanut and tree nut substitutes on hand. Soy nut butter is made from roasted soybeans, and it doesn’t contain gluten or dairy. Sitting only a little lower on the protein scale—6.6 grams of protein per two tablespoons compared to 7 grams in peanut butter—soy nut butter also has all essential amino acids, and a good serving of those healthy unsaturated fats.

Taste: Creamy and savory, with less of a strong nutty flavor than other nut butters.

Uses: Swap for peanut butter to make recipes peanut-free.

4 / 12
Sliced black bean bread with spread and toppingAmallia Eka/Shutterstock

Pumpkin Seed Butter

Pumpkin seed butter is actually made from pepitas, not the large white seeds from your Halloween pumpkin. The butter is higher in protein per 200 calorie serving than most other nut butters. Plus, pumpkin seed butter naturally contains lots of zinc, which is great for your immune system.

Taste: Very nutty and earthy. It’s super-easy to spread, and it doesn’t need stirring unlike many nut butters.

Uses: Mix with honey to balance out the flavor, and use as a spread or substitute for peanut butter in recipes.

If you’re trying to eat healthier, make sure you’re avoiding these six common mistakes.

5 / 12
toasted pistachio lemon butter on a dark wood background.Nataliya Arzamasova/Shutterstock

Pistachio Butter

Pistachio butter is much lower in fat than other nut butters—only 13 grams per two tablespoons compared to almost 18 grams in almond butter—but still has 6 grams of protein. It’s also totally cholesterol-free and has lots of potassium and fiber, as well as copper for building strong bones and connective tissue.

Taste: Herbal, earthy and bitter.

Uses: Blend with cheeses and creams for a dip or spread, use as a base for your favorite pesto recipe or incorporate into desserts.

6 / 12
Organic brown rice cakes with healty organic sunflower seed butter.MSPhotographic/Shutterstock

Sunflower Seed Butter

Another great alternative for those with peanut or tree nut allergies, sunflower seed butter has more fiber, magnesium, vitamin E, zinc and copper than most other nut butters. It also has a good dose of selenium, which can help reduce cholesterol.

Taste: Sunflower seed butter is definitely an acquired taste—its flavor profile is, well, very much like a mouthful of sunflower seeds. It’s earthy, with a big, bold flavor.

Uses: Use sunflower seed butter in your favorite salad dressings and vegetable sauces.

7 / 12
homemade toasted cinnamon hazelnut butter.Nataliya Arzamasova/Shutterstock

Hazelnut Butter

Hazelnuts have lots of protein, fiber, vitamin E, manganese and copper. While Nutella popularized this nut butter, you’re better off saving that chocolatey spread for a sweet treat and opting for the pure hazelnut butter for daily eating.

Taste: Rich and nutty.

Uses: Hazelnut butter is delicious in baked goods, or just as a plain ol’ spread.

8 / 12
Raw organic walnut butter and fresh nuts.Chamille White/Shutterstock

Walnut Butter

While not the highest in protein, walnuts do have super-high levels of omega-3 fatty acids, and they also have anti-inflammatory properties which is great for people suffering from arthritis and autoimmune diseases.

Taste: Earthy and buttery, with a strong tannic, bitter flavor. Walnut butter is thick and a little drier, so it can be difficult to use as a spread by itself.

Uses: Pair with sweet flavors, like chocolate or cinnamon, to balance out the strong taste. It’s a great binding agent, so use it to firm up your veggie burgers and add a nice, nutty texture.

9 / 12
Homemade Cashew Peanut Butter Ready to EatBrent Hofacker/Shutterstock

Cashew Butter

Cashew butter is full of monounsaturated fat to keep your bad cholesterol levels down, and it also has over 80% of the daily recommended dose of copper. While cashew butter is lower in calcium than other nut butters, it does contain lots of magnesium and oleic acid for a healthy heart, as well as biotin for strong hair, skin and nails.

Taste: Rich cashew taste and smell, but overall it’s pretty light and sweet. It also has a thin consistency that makes it easy to spread.

Uses: Cashew butter is a great ingredient for sauces and curries, as well as a vegan alternative for cream cheese and sour cream.

10 / 12
Organic Freshly Made Almond Butter in Small Serving Bowl; Shutterstock ID 278857178; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): TOHAnna Hoychuk/Shutterstock

Brazil Nut Butter

People rave about Brazil nuts because of their high selenium content.  Make sure you’re adding nuts to your diet the healthy way.

Taste: Rich and creamy, very similar flavor to coconut.

Uses: This works great as a vegetable dip or a spread. It’s also very easy to make at home because its high fat content requires less processing to get it into butter form.

11 / 12
Homemade organic peanut butter, only crushed peanuts inside. Top view.; Shutterstock ID 754716562Geshas/Shutterstock

Macadamia Butter

This luxurious butter is very high in unsaturated fats, but lower in protein than other nut butters—only 4 grams per two tablespoons.

Taste: Floral, buttery and tropical.

Uses: Use instead of butter for a delicious spread, or pair with sweeter cheeses and fruit. It can also be used in desserts as a creamy, rich topping.

12 / 12
Delicious toasts with coconut oil in plate on tableAfrica Studio/Shutterstock

Coconut Butter

Unlike coconut oil, coconut butter is made from the flesh of the coconut. It has tons of lauric acid, which is great for energy production and for keeping your cholesterol levels in check. However, its high fat content is mostly composed of saturated fats, and its calorie count is the highest of the nut butters.

Taste: Creamy and tropical, with a mild flavor.

Uses: Swap coconut butter for butter in any recipe for a more healthful, vegan alternative.

Maggie Ward
Maggie’s background in the arts gave her a penchant for collaborative communication and the pursuit of conveying ideas in a clear, striking way. Outside of writing for Taste of Home, Maggie loves playing the piano and writing music, as well as performing with various bands and theatre productions around the city of Chicago.

Popular Videos