Yes, the amount is correct—you add 2 tablespoons of vanilla to the batter. A friend who shared this recipe years ago loved the taste of vanilla and wanted this cake to taste just as good. I like to use Mexican vanilla in this recipe.—Joan Hallford, North Richland Hills, Texas


Test Kitchen tips For a stacked look, make two cakes and a double batch of icing.
  • Gently spoon flour into dry measuring cups and level off with a spatula. Remember to always measure liquid ingredients in liquid measuring cups placed at eye level on the counter top.
  • Oven temperature varies, it's a good idea to check the cake a few minutes before the time range stated in the recipe.
  • For success and ease, grease tube or fluted cake pans with shortening.
  • For best flavor, use Pure or Mexican vanilla extract.