Colby Cheese Recipes

Colby is one of our top cheeses for cooking. Take a look at all of our most satisfying recipes with colby cheese or colby jack cheese today!

Add Filter

Sloppy Joe Tater Tot Casserole

7 reviews

This sloppy joe Tater Tot casserole is an easy dinner for both you and the kids. Serve with carrot and celery sticks for a fuss-free feast. You can also stir in some spicy brown mustard if the adults want more zing. —Laura Wilhelm, West Hollywood, California

Cranberry Chipotle Chicken Enchiladas

2 reviews

Whether canned or homemade, cranberry sauce delivers a healthy dose of vitamins to this dish. A little bit sweet and...


Contest-Winning Grilled Roast Beef Sandwiches

3 reviews

This fast favorite hits the spot when we're short on time. Roast beef, cheese, and sauteed onion, green pepper and...


Southwest Creamy Pasta Bake

10 reviews

“I like to cook a package of boneless chicken breasts in the microwave, then dice it up and store in...


Zucchini Egg and Cheese Casserole

1 review

Whether I'm preparing a sit-down dinner at home or attending a potluck buffet, family and friends have come to expect...

Mashed Potatoes with Corn and Cheese

1 review

The cheese and corn add a boost of flavor to mashed potatoes. For more convenience, purchase refrigerated mashed potatoes. Heat...


Special Sandwich Loaves

These satisfying sub sandwiches are a study in simplicity. Try serving the seasoned mayonnaise on the side so guests can...

Tout icon

Mexican Chicken Bake

8 reviews

I've had this Mexican chicken bake recipe for 30 years. Since my kids, grandkids and guests of all ages request...


Cheesy Crab Enchiladas

3 reviews

While I was in college, my roommates and I loved the taste of ranch dressing - it was our condiment...


Ham ‘n’ Cheese Bow Ties

12 reviews

Everyone who tries this yummy casserole lists it as a favorite from then on. Bow tie pasta makes it fun,...


Antipasto Bake

13 reviews

Stuffed with savory meats and cheeses, these hearty antipasto squares would satisfy an entire offensive line! The dish comes together...

Ranch Mac & Cheese

58 reviews

I came up with the recipe for this creamy and satisfying macaroni and cheese, which has a special twist. My...


Zucchini and Cheese Casserole

23 reviews

My daughter and I love zucchini, and this casserole uses plenty for a hearty fall side dish. For extra color,...


Mashed Cauliflower au Gratin

20 reviews

Unless someone tells you, you might not know you're eating cauliflower. Even my grandchildren love this buttery, cheesy, creamy dish...


Chicken Nachos

4 reviews

Everyone needs a go-to nacho recipe. Change this chicken version by using leftover shredded pork or brisket, and barbecue sauce...


Cheesy Onion Chicken Skillet

6 reviews

My zesty chicken with peppers and onions is so versatile, it works when you serve it over rice, potatoes, noodles,...

Chicken Cheese Strata

13 reviews

The spices in this simple strata with chicken, broccoli and cheese offer an extra special taste. —Taste of Home Test...


Tout icon

One-Skillet Lasagna

65 reviews

This is hands-down one of the best skillet lasagna recipes our testing panel has ever tasted. And with classic flavors...


Crab Crescent Triangles

1 review

When friends who love crab were planning a party, I created this recipe just for them. These comforting baked bundles...


Buffalo Chicken Sandwiches with Bacon

1 review

I love grilling chicken because it's a healthier choice. I put my "Joe-style" twist on this sandwich with a spicy-sweet...


Green Chile Grilled Cheese Melt

6 reviews

My daughter created a masterpiece with her ultimate grilled cheese and chiles sandwich. Want more heat? Use a 4-ounce can...


Homemade Crisp Crackers

1 review

Store-bought crackers have nothing on these cheesy crisps. Make them in advance and keep them handy in an airtight container...


Bacon-Colby Lasagna

14 reviews

My grandmother added bacon to her cheesy lasagna—something she borrowed from carbonara-style pasta. I learned so much by her side....


Fruit ‘n’ Cheese Kabobs

1 review

The home economist in our test kitchen came up with this colorful combination. It's a simple, nutritious snack that's a...


Onion Cheese Soup

16 reviews

I made a few adjustments to this savory soup recipe I came across in a community cookbook. It's rich, buttery...

Magazine Cover

Subscribe & SAVE

Save Up To 80%!

Creamy Green Chile Chicken Cobbler

5 reviews

Biscuity crumbs take this family-friendly combo of rotisserie chicken and cheesy, creamy green enchilada sauce over the top. —Johnna Johnson,...


Stovetop Cheeseburger Pasta

22 reviews

Cheeseburgers are delicious in any form, but I'm partial to this creamy pasta dish that seriously tastes just like the...


Bacon Mac & Cheese

20 reviews

Jalapeno pepper adds an extra kick to this bacon mac and cheese, giving it great grown-up taste. I serve this...


Baked Ham and Colby Sandwiches

8 reviews

This yummy ham sliders recipe is a winner with friends and family. Not only are the warm sandwiches a snap...


Ham & Cheese Casseroles

9 reviews

I got this recipe from my mother, and I love it because it’s easy and I usually have the ingredients...


Duo Tater Bake

21 reviews

I made this creamy and comforting potato dish for Thanksgiving and it was a winner with my family. They said...