Back to Easy Coconut Cream Pie

Print Options

 
 
 
 

Card Sizes

 
 
 
 Print
Easy Coconut Cream Pie Recipe

Easy Coconut Cream Pie Recipe

This is my own recipe for a pie that I make often. It's been a family-favorite dessert since the '40s, when I made several of these pies to serve a threshing crew of 21 men! —Vera Moffitt, Oskaloosa, Kansas
TOTAL TIME: Prep: 20 min. + chilling YIELD:8 servings

Ingredients

  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 3 tablespoons all-purpose flour
  • 1/8 teaspoon salt
  • 3 cups whole milk
  • 3 large eggs, beaten
  • 1-1/2 cups sweetened shredded coconut, toasted, divided
  • 1 tablespoon butter
  • 1-1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 pastry shell (9 inches), baked

Directions

  • 1. In a medium saucepan, combine sugar, flour and salt. Stir in milk; cook and stir over medium-high heat until thickened and bubbly. Reduce heat; cook and stir 2 minutes longer. Remove from the heat; gradually stir about 1 cup of hot mixture into beaten eggs. Return all to saucepan; cook and stir over medium heat until nearly boiling. Reduce heat; cook and stir about 2 minutes more (do not boil). Remove from the heat; stir in 1 cup coconut, butter and vanilla. Pour into pie shell; sprinkle with remaining coconut. Chill for several hours before serving. Yield: 8 servings.

Recipe Note


Test Kitchen Tips

  • Put the lime in the coconut by stirring in 1 teaspoon grated lime peel after removing sugar mixture from the heat.
  • This filling is super easy and delicious in a graham cracker crust.
  • Nutritional Facts

    1 piece: 389 calories, 20g fat (12g saturated fat), 101mg cholesterol, 266mg sodium, 47g carbohydrate (30g sugars, 1g fiber), 7g protein.

    Reviews for Easy Coconut Cream Pie

    Sort By :

    Average Rating
    MY REVIEW
    Naomie User ID: 9114200 263674
    Reviewed Mar. 20, 2017

    "Awesome recipe! Then again I love coconut! Thanks for sharing!"

    MY REVIEW
    res1046 User ID: 8390460 263173
    Reviewed Mar. 7, 2017

    "We enjoyed this pie. I prepared it as written except for substituting 1 Tablespoon cornstarch for 1 Tablespoon of the flour as suggested by chefkatkat in her review. I'd intended to top the pie with freshly whipped cream but found it didn't need any. I served it with a few fresh strawberries to add a bit of color."

    MY REVIEW
    Bubbasmom40 User ID: 8807053 245509
    Reviewed Mar. 16, 2016

    "Recipe did not work. Custard did not set in the refrigerator. Not sure what I did wrong. Any ideas about how I might fix it?"

    MY REVIEW
    cdtl User ID: 8678127 240417
    Reviewed Dec. 28, 2015

    "This pie was delicious. i made it as given except substituted heavy whipping cream for the milk. (Took much less time to thicken using the heavy whipping cream) it stands on its own--you don't need to top with any meringue or whip cream"

    MY REVIEW
    chefkatkat User ID: 8676715 240325
    Reviewed Dec. 27, 2015

    "This is pretty much the recipe I use for all of my cream pies (adjusting different flavors, of course) with only a couple of changes. Reduce the flour to 2 tablespoons and add 1 tablespoon of cornstarch. Gives a smoother texture to the pudding. I also separate the eggs and only add the yolks to the pudding. I use the whites for meringue. I sprinkle 1/4 c coconut on the filling, top with meringue and sprinkle remaining coconut on top. Place under broiler until golden brown. (Watch closely! It can burn in a heartbeat! Ask me how I know.) Even if you follow the recipe as written, you will have a delicious pie! The changes I made are due to the methods I learned while earning my Masters in Pastry Arts."

    MY REVIEW
    veridical_angel User ID: 4535862 240186
    Reviewed Dec. 25, 2015

    "This recipe did not work for me at all. The flour milk ratio is not right. It should not take a half hour to thicken. Burnt my favorite pan after all that. Lost a half an hour scrubbing."

    MY REVIEW
    onetoomany User ID: 7556943 238828
    Reviewed Dec. 6, 2015

    "Delicious and easy even for a first time"

    MY REVIEW
    mjh1944 User ID: 8087698 224903
    Reviewed Apr. 15, 2015

    "I liked it but like to make the creamier filling."

    MY REVIEW
    Sweetaroma65 User ID: 8206803 224485
    Reviewed Apr. 8, 2015

    "This recipe looks beautiful in the picture!"

    MY REVIEW
    sprolessissy User ID: 7205796 224480
    Reviewed Apr. 8, 2015

    "You can make this pie filling in the microwave in 7 minutes! Very same results!"

    MY REVIEW
    rusticcooking User ID: 1448674 224461
    Reviewed Apr. 8, 2015

    "This is a very good pie, and keeps well, however it is a very old recipe that

    I have used for years as far back as the 70s......"

    MY REVIEW
    cultura User ID: 3011187 224457
    Reviewed Apr. 8, 2015

    "It is a great pie, which the poster has been making since the 40's. Maybe the cookbooks came after, because of HER recipe!"

    MY REVIEW
    newgrandma User ID: 1077052 224454
    Reviewed Apr. 8, 2015

    "yes you can add bananas instead of coconut. I have been making this recipe for years, both with coconut and bananas. You would slice up 2-3 in the bottom of your pie shell and pour the pudding over it. It can also be made into a delicious chocolate pie."

    MY REVIEW
    spiritvamp User ID: 7628909 224451
    Reviewed Apr. 8, 2015

    "I have more of a question than a comment and if someone would be so kind to give me a holler back I'd be grateful. My husband cannot eat coconut, so could I add bananas to this recipe instead? And if so how much? Thanks"

    MY REVIEW
    ctquilter User ID: 43819 224450
    Reviewed Apr. 8, 2015

    "As another reviewer said, this same recipe has been around for years in the cookbooks. I made it for Easter last week. It's a goodie, but not original to the poster. My mother also made her pudding for pies in this fashion. It is REAL pudding which can't compare to that out of a box."

    MY REVIEW
    lfknisley User ID: 7284778 224441
    Reviewed Apr. 8, 2015

    "This recipe has been around for years in several cookbooks. The only difference is you add meringue and coconut to the top of it and brown it slightly and you don't have to chill it. You can serve it warm or cold. Its delicious warm!"

    MY REVIEW
    btgocag User ID: 8128302 72260
    Reviewed Nov. 27, 2014

    "quick and easy to make added a little bit of home made whip topping and it was perfect!!!"

    MY REVIEW
    melody61 User ID: 8121085 36423
    Reviewed Nov. 25, 2014

    "A great pie."

    MY REVIEW
    bluefrog62 User ID: 1755462 40704
    Reviewed Dec. 12, 2013

    "LOVED LOVED LOVED THIS pie.....I am a HUGH fan of that one spot that is no longer around BS....and I added whipped cream to the top of this and OH MY this is one GREAT COCONUT CREAM pie!!! I did put this in a Keebler Shortbread pie shell and that was awesome but his pie was good no matter what! quick and Great pie what could be better!"

    MY REVIEW
    Eubie User ID: 1416604 45100
    Reviewed Dec. 2, 2013

    "Creamy and delicious. Loved it."

    MY REVIEW
    last_woodsman User ID: 2676942 12951
    Reviewed Nov. 27, 2013

    "great retro pie I remember from my days on the farm. simple and wonderful!!!

    When threshing there was always this pie with the others under a tree in the hot August shade for the crews."

    MY REVIEW
    Aquarelle User ID: 985301 18743
    Reviewed Jan. 20, 2013

    "After reading the previous reviews I realized that it would be very easy to reduce the recipe by a third. (I always sucked at math but I'm very good at re-sizing recipes - go figure!) A 2/3 filling recipe is perfect for a 9" pie. It tastes really good, too."

    MY REVIEW
    Pittypat5458 User ID: 6685932 18741
    Reviewed Jun. 1, 2012

    "This was a great pie! Will definitely make again. Everyone loved it."

    MY REVIEW
    bgbmartin1958 User ID: 3282340 40702
    Reviewed Nov. 25, 2011

    "I made this for Thanksgiving. Got lots of compliments. easy to make. I used this and made 2 pies out of this recipe. I put whipped cream on top and then the toasted coconut. It was the right amount of pie filling for 2 pies and they were deep dish. So it would be plenty without whipped cream on top for 2 regular pie shells."

    MY REVIEW
    ChevalDeLis User ID: 4388194 41807
    Reviewed May. 22, 2010

    "Just a fabulous, easy recipe! The best coconut cream pie I've ever had. It does make a lot of filling, so be sure to use a deep dish pie plate. Wow! Made me look like a superstar - thanks!"

    Loading Image