Custard Pie Recipes

Looking for recipes for custard pie? Taste of Home has the best custard pie recipes from real cooks like you, featuring reviews, ratings, how-to videos and tips.

Add Filter

Taste of Home Logo

Bread Pudding Pie

4 reviews

This unique dessert is a bread pudding-pie combo. It was created by my paternal grandmother's family. They had a farm and made their own bread, which made this a low-cost dessert. — Kelly Barnes, Lexington, Indiana

Banana Meringue Pie

3 reviews

This pie is the perfect way to end a meal on a cozy, comforting note.—Edna Hoffman, Hebron, Indiana


Creamy Chocolate-Banana Pie

2 reviews

You can make almost any dessert more awesome with chocolate. In this cream pie, fresh banana and chocolate make a...


Caramel Custard Pie

4 reviews

Here’s a traditional custard pie that’s been in our family for over 100 years. A fun layer of caramel jazzes...


Squash Custard Pie

6 reviews

Acorn squash has been a favorite of mine since I was little and my mother baked it with sugar and...

Buttermilk Pie

10 reviews

This buttermilk pie is an absolute must on your dessert table! I love serving it to my family after Sunday...


Vinegar Pie

9 reviews

For an adventure in taste, this pie is the way to go. It is very inexpensive and will surprise you...

Old-Fashioned Custard Pie

15 reviews

This recipe came from the best cook in West Virginia—my mother! I just added a little to her ingredients. I'm...


Maple Sugar Pumpkin Pie

10 reviews

We make our own maple syrup, and that's what gives this pie its special taste. You might want to bake...


Dar’s Coconut Cream Pie

16 reviews

When I whip up a toasted coconut cream pie, my family goes wild and the pie vanishes. —Darlene Bartos, Shoreview,...


Mom’s Lemon Custard Pie

46 reviews

My mother often made this lemon pie back when we were growing up. You might say it's stood the test...

Easy Rhubarb Pie

Rhubarb adds a slightly tart flavor and a fruity touch of spring to this homemade custard pie. Our Test Kitchen...


Pear Custard Pie

2 reviews

Marie Rizzio of Interlochen, Michigan shares the secret of this mouthwatering pie. "When cooked, the pears become incredibly sweet, soft...


Easy Sweet Potato Pie

5 reviews

"I've been preparing this glazed pecan-topped pie for so long that I can't recall when I came across the combination...


Key Lime Pie

4 reviews

We created this refreshing mini pie with a homemade crumb crust and a pudding-like lime filling. If you can’t find...


Apple Custard Pie

2 reviews

There's no need to pull out your rolling pin to make this sweet apple custard pie. It has an easy...

Can’t-Miss Coconut Custard Pie

8 reviews

This soft custard pie has a mild coconut flavor. Who wouldn't love a hearty slice topped with a dollop of...


Frosted Orange Pie

3 reviews

I discovered the recipe for this distinctive pie in a very old church cookbook. With its fresh-tasting filling and fluffy...


Tout icon

Sugar Cream Pie

45 reviews

I absolutely love Indiana sugar cream pie; especially the one that my grandma made for me. Here, we serve it...


Buttermilk Lemon Pie

6 reviews

Our family tradition is to have a variety of cream pies for Easter dinner dessert. This old-fashioned recipe is always...