Cherry Spice Cake
At least four generations of women in my family have been baking this Cherry Spice Cake. It's always my mom's pick for her birthday. I like to use cream cheese frosting, but when my mother was growing up, my grandma frosted the cake with butter cream.—Laurie Sanders, Manchester, Michigan
Reviews
Seems I'm frequently shaking my head at folks who down-rate and are disappointed in a recipe while admitting they made changes and didn't follow the directions. To the person who couldn't find tart cherries in the baking aisle, try looking in the aisle that has canned fruit and vegetables. That's where I usually find mine. For some reason it's often on the top shelf in every store.
Love the flavors here, though I tweaked the icing by adding margarine and vanilla. Not having a tart cherry tree, I need to buy the cherries. The only pitted tart cherries I have found in stores so far is a can of cherry pie filling, which is mostly glaze. If you put the glaze in the batter, it makes a wet goo instead of a cake. Is there another product I can look for besides the pie filling I found in the baking goods aisle?
I enjoyed it but HB didn't It seemed to get moister on day two. It is more bread like. But as I said I enjoyed it very much.
Everyone in my family loved this cake. I've been asked a couple times since to make it again. I loved it.
I made this cake n2 a loaffer (bread) and needs some work done to it... the frosting was way too sweet and heavy - I will make this again - as bread or cupcakes and add a thin layer of glaze to the top(s)!
My family moved to a farm in 1952 that had tart cherry trees along with many other fruit trees. My mother had no recipes for tart cherries at the time so a neighbor lady gave her a recipe for Cherry Cake. It is very similar to this recipe with just a few minor changes, for instance allspice instead of cloves, and plain milk instead of buttermilk. A few ingredients amounts differed somewhat also, but basically the same. I have made my mother's recipe for this cake on many special occasions over the years and my family and relatives have always loved it. I am going to make it using your recipe and see if there is any difference in the taste. But on the whole, it is a very delicious cake.
I've been making this for years, but with only 1/2 C. of sugar. I bake it in a 9 x 13 pan and use brown sugar frosting. It's my husbands favorite. His mother gave me the recipe 58 years ago.
I was not at all happy with this recipe. The cake was very dense and heavy and had no taste. I did not feel that the cherries added enough moistness. The frosting was too sweet .will not make again
A perfect cake for special occasions and not fussy to make either. The cherries keep it nice and moist.
Everyone really enjoyed this cake. I was surprised that the cherries and spices went together so well.