Sort By :

Average Rating
AfterAgnesDowner User ID: 7584816 269931
Reviewed Jul. 25, 2017

"Topped with mini marshmallows, salted peanuts & chocolate chips & under the broiler a couple minutes then swirled the topping. Very rich."

homemadewithlove User ID: 4311884 260783
Reviewed Feb. 4, 2017

"Best Fudge recipe! Very fluffy and creamy. We only make at Christmas and my husband helps with the stirring. Yields great results."

Wenwen36 User ID: 8677191 240359
Reviewed Dec. 27, 2015

"I have made this many times! It is the best and easiest recipe I've found for peanut butter fudge. I went to get the ingredients today to make more and both stores in my little town were sold out of marshmallow creme. I am wondering if I can make this with whole marshmallows, what adjustments I need to make if so... I'd appreciate any help please! Thanks for the best fudge recipe EVER!"

kerryboots User ID: 8537232 232841
Reviewed Sep. 13, 2015

"I'd never made fudge before and was scared. This is the best fudge I've ever eaten. Made it many times last fall/winter and getting ready to make it again for the 2nd time in two weeks. Thank you so much."

joshc5919 User ID: 8526335 232305
Reviewed Sep. 4, 2015

"Made this recipe many times. Went to make it tonight, and didnt have milk. So I used half and half instead. Came out really creamy, and really delicious. Recommend trying it."

pajamaangel User ID: 1603339 215772
Reviewed Dec. 24, 2014

"The best peanut butter fudge ever! We never use another recipe. It's like a fluff sandwich on sugar steroids!"

melsmorsels User ID: 5529597 215758
Reviewed Dec. 24, 2014

"I just whipped up a batch and it turned out's chilling now so I don't really know how it's going to cut & taste but the fudge looks smooth, tastes wonderful, super easy...I can't wait to try a piece!!"

chikalulu User ID: 6320395 214857
Reviewed Dec. 14, 2014

"This turned out perfectly. I read previous reviews before trying this one. The problem with a lot of recipes is lack of details. Have your marshmallow creme jar open, and your peanut butter - I used Jif No Stir Natural Creamy Peanut Butter. already measured out. Prep your pan before you start. I line a 7"x10" glass pan lined with parchment. You must first bring the milk (I used evaporated milk) and sugar to a full boil - one that does not go away when stirred. I usually start with medium-high to get the boil going, then back off to medium once it's boiling. You must stir constantly. Begin your 3 minute timing once the mixture comes to a full boil. Take the pan off the heat! I immediately stirred in a tsp of vanilla. Now you've got to work quickly. Add your peanut butter and marshmallow creme. Stir with a wooden spoon until thoroughly combined. Pour into your prepared pan. Let it cool completely at room temperature. To cut it, just lift it our with the parchment paper and place it on your cutting surface. Cut into 1" squares because it's quite rich. LOVE this recipe! Plenty of peanut butter flavor for me."

Sheikadrsw48 User ID: 8155375 214741
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2014

"This is the best recipe I have tried. My kids love it too! 5 stars ! I used 1/2 marshmallow cream and 1/2 regular marshmallows. My fudge set just fine."

einnaj User ID: 2641027 213811
Reviewed Dec. 2, 2014

"Mine turned out great. If it burns, that means your heat is too high. Try medium heat."

Loading Image