6 Stores That Sell the Best Everything Bagel Seasoning – Trader Joe’s & More

Updated: May 10, 2024

Obsessed with this versatile seasoning? Trader Joe’s isn’t the only spot that has it! Here’s where you should look.

Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.
Learn more.

1 / 8
Round Warm Everything Bagels Ready to Eat
Brent Hofacker/Shutterstock

Anyone else obsessed with Trader Joe’s Everything But the Bagel Seasoning? The versatile spice blend can be served numerous ways, giving every single bite that salty and crunchy goodness only an everything bagel can. Ree Drummond’s everything chicken recipe proves just that. However, if you don’t live near a Trader Joe’s, it obviously would be hard to get your hands on a jar of this magical seasoning.

But never fear! There are plenty of other places to get everything bagel seasoning.

2 / 8
 Olde Thompson Everything Seasoning For Bagels & More 11.5 OZ | 1 Pack Olde Thompson Everything Seasoning For Bagels & More 11.5 OZ | 1 Pack Tell us if something is incorrect Olde Thompson Everything Seasoning For Bagels & More
via walmart.com


Head to a Costco, membership card in hand, to hunt for a big container of Olde Thompson Everything Seasoning, which clocks in at 11.5 oz. for $4.49. (You can also get it at Walmart!)

Buy now.

Psst: Sprinkle this over a homemade bagel! Here’s our step-by-step guide to making bagels at home.

3 / 8
Gustus Vitae's Everything Brooklyn Bagel Seasoning
via walmart.com


Walmart also sells Everything Brooklyn Bagel Seasoning from Gustus Vitae, which comes in a magnetic shaker tin, for $8.99.

Buy now.

Psst: Get it for a song at our site, Shop Taste of Home. For just $9.99, you can buy a two-pack of this seasoning and French onion sprinkle!

4 / 8
Tone's Everything Bagel Seasoning (7.5 oz.)
via samsclub.com

Sam’s Club

Not surprisingly, other stores are also selling this heavenly blend of spices. Sam’s Club sells Tone’s Everything Bagel Seasoning in a 7.5 oz. container for $3.98.

Buy now.

We’re letting you in on the secrets Sam’s Club employees want you to know.

5 / 8
Everything Bagel Seasoning Trio
via uncommongoods.com

Uncommon Goods

Looking to add a little spice to this blend? Uncommon Goods has your back! This online store actually sells three different kinds of everything seasoning, which is called “Everything on Everything.” There’s the Classic Blend, the Spicy Blend, and the Dill Blend, all for $20.

Buy now.

6 / 8
Everything Bagel Seasoning Blend XL 9 Ounce Jar
via walmart.com


We’re not surprised! This “Not Just Bagel Seasoning” has a blend of sesame seeds, salt, garlic, onion, poppy seeds and spices. It comes in a 9-oz. container and you can snag it for $10.95.

Buy now.

7 / 8
Everything Bagel Topping - 8 oz.
via kingarthurflour.com

King Arthur Flour

Leave it to King Arthur Flour to have something like this! The popular baking company sells an “Everything Bagel Topping,” which, of course, is meant for when you’re making bagels. But that doesn’t mean you can’t use it for other purposes! You can grab an 8 oz. container for $9.95.

Buy now.

8 / 8
who needs the bagel seasoning stonemill
Courtesy Aldi


If you’re looking for a budget-friendly version of your favorite seasoning, Aldi has the best deal for you. On October 9, Who Needs the Bagel? seasoning will be available at Aldi for $1.95, at 2.3 oz. per container.

Buy now.

Here’s why Aldi brands are definitely worth buying.