10 Ways to Use Up a Jar of Tahini

That jar of sesame paste you bought to make hummus can do a lot more than that! These ideas for using tahini will make sure none of it goes to waste.

Many people buy tahini for dips like hummus or baba ganoush, then wonder what to do with the rest of the jar. Not me. The creamy sesame paste never lasts long in my fridge. It blends beautifully into sweet and savory recipes, so it feels like there are infinite ways to use tahini. Its smooth, silky texture and earthy, nutty flavor can elevate almost any dish.

Tahini is similar to other nut and seed butters in texture and preparation. It’s made by blending a neutral oil with sesame seeds (typically hulled white, but sometimes toasted or unhulled black sesame seeds) until smooth and thick. The best tahini balances richness with gentle bitterness, making it versatile. Combine it with white or brown sugar to add complexity to tahini chocolate chip cookies, or whisk it with garlic and lemon juice for an umami-rich sauce that’s perfect on sandwiches like arayes.

There are plenty of tahini recipes you can follow, but I often cook without a recipe. Instead, I find myself adding a dollop here and a drizzle there. Once you start experimenting, you’ll find it can stand in for peanut butter in baked goods or noodle dishes. It can be swirled into salad dressings and marinades, or thinned with a little water to be drizzled over roasted vegetables or grain bowls. With so many uses, it’s no wonder the jar never lasts long at my house.

1 / 10

Lebanese Street Sandwiches Tohcom26 259277 Dr 01 28 04b
DAN ROBERTS FOR TASTE OF HOME

Create an Easy Tahini Sauce

Tahini sauce is so good, I want to drizzle it on everything. It’s also one of the fastest and most flexible ways to use up the last bit of your tahini jar. You can make an easy sauce by blending equal parts tahini, warm water and lemon juice, plus a pinch of salt and a minced garlic clove to amp up the pungency. Adjust the consistency and flavor with more water or lemon juice to create a well-balanced, pourable sauce or dressing for salads.

The sauce is silky-smooth with a nutty, bright character that elevates everything from grain bowls to falafel. If I’m looking for a no-fuss dinner, I’ll toss the sauce with cooked noodles and top it off with a little chili crisp for a hint of spice. It doubles as a spread for sandwiches and a dip for crudites or sweet potato chips.

2 / 10

Fifteen chocolate oat bars are arranged on a white cutting board next to a knife with a wooden handle. The bars have a crumbly oat topping and are cut into neat squares.
Josh Rink for Taste of Home

Add Tahini to Desserts

Tahini is one of those ingredients that works just as well in desserts as it does in savory applications. In classic tahini desserts like halva or Dubai chocolate treats, it’s often paired with pistachios. It also works beautifully with dark chocolate, dates, citrus, honey, maple syrup and warm spices, like cardamom and ginger.

To start, try swapping it in dessert recipes that call for creamy peanut or almond butter. In recipes like peanut butter frosting, it should work as a 1:1 replacement. For baked goods like tahini brownies, cookies or cakes, you may need to add a little extra flour because tahini’s texture is generally thinner than other nut butters, which takes up more volume in a measuring cup. Increasing the dry ingredients will compensate for the extra moisture.

3 / 10

A baked sweet potato split open and filled with melted butter sits on a black plate with a lime wedge, next to a knife and a bowl of butter. The plate is on a wooden table with a burgundy napkin underneath.
Dan Roberts for Taste of Home

Use Tahini to Enhance Vegetables

Tahini tastes fantastic with vegetables, raw or roasted. Its creamy texture offers a nice contrast to crunchy crudite vegetables, and its nutty, roasty flavor adds depth to even the simplest veggie dishes. Tahini can be thick, so I usually thin it with a touch of water or oil—just enough to make it easier to drizzle. Then I’ll spoon it into the bottom of a bowl and top it with roasted veggies and grains. That way, every spoonful gets a little bit of tahini, seasoning the dish one bite at a time.

I also love mixing up a quick tahini butter for veggies. The butter mellows tahini’s bitterness, and then I add other punchy, savory ingredients like soy sauce, lemon or lime juice, garlic, smoked paprika, cumin, chili flakes or fresh herbs. Dollop the butter onto baked sweet potatoes, top with some crunchy roasted chickpeas and you have an easy, flavorful dinner. Tahini butter also tastes fantastic melted and drizzled over grilled eggplant or cauliflower.

4 / 10

Dubai Chocolate Latte is ready and served in a glass
SARAH TRAMONTE FOR TASTE OF HOME

Add Tahini to Coffee, Shakes and Smoothies

Stirring tahini into coffee is an unexpected delight. It adds a richness that balances out coffee’s bitterness, and its savory edge brings a delightful earthiness to your morning drink. To make tahini coffee, simply add a tablespoon or so of tahini to your coffee mug, along with some maple syrup or honey (if you like your coffee sweetened). Add coffee or espresso, and stir to combine. You can also add other mix-ins to create decadent drinks, like a Dubai chocolate latte.

Tahini is also great for plant-based shakes and smoothies. The first time I heard of a tahini shake was from Goldie, a Philadelphia-based falafel shop. Their shakes are known for being super thick and creamy, and I just had to try making one at home. To avoid watering down the shake with ice, I blended 1/2 cup tahini, 1/2 cup sugar and 3 cups of nondairy milk (I used coconut milk), and froze it overnight in ice cube trays. The next day, I blended it into one of the thickest and most delicious shakes I’ve ever had. 

5 / 10

close shot of tahini dressing in a jar
Taste of Home

Whisk Tahini into Salad Dressings and Marinades

Adding tahini to salad dressings is a great way to add body without dairy or mayonnaise. My go-to tahini dressing is pretty simple: tahini, water, lemon juice, garlic and salt. It tastes great on leafy green salads or grain salads with quinoa, couscous or pasta. Sometimes, I’ll add miso paste for a salty, savory boost or maple syrup for a touch of sweetness. Fresh herbs, chili flakes or grated ginger can add complexity, too.

You can also whisk tahini into marinade recipes. It thickens the marinade slightly so the spices and aromatics cling to the protein, whether you’re working with tofu, chicken, beef or lamb. Try blending tahini with olive oil, garlic, cumin and smoked paprika for a simple yet bold marinade.

6 / 10

Grilled sandwiches filled with ground meat and herbs are stacked on parchment paper next to a bowl of creamy dipping sauce on a light blue cutting board.
Dan Roberts for Taste of Home

Use Tahini Instead of Mayonnaise

I often use hummus as a mayonnaise replacement on sandwiches, but tahini works just as well. Slather a tablespoon or two onto the bread, and you’ll get the same indulgent texture you’d expect from mayo plus a subtle sesame flavor.

Tahini is smooth enough that it doesn’t need thinning when used as a condiment for sandwiches or wraps. However, if I’m using it as a mayo replacement for creamy salads, like chicken or tuna salad, I like to whisk in a little water or lemon juice to achieve the perfect consistency. This hack works particularly well in plant-based recipes, like chickpea salad sandwiches.

7 / 10

Fresh Hammus with chickpeas in a small bowl
Taste of Home

Fold Tahini into Dips

Tahini is an essential ingredient in dips like hummus and baba ganoush, but you don’t have to stop there. When I need a last-minute dip for a party or potluck, I stir a generous spoonful of tahini into Greek yogurt, and add garlic, apple cider vinegar and fresh dill. It becomes a creamy dip for chips or veggies, and no one realizes how easy it was to make!

Tahini also quietly enhances mild dips. A dollop in a smashed zucchini dip adds subtle sesame flavor without overpowering the zucchini. Stirred into white bean spreads, tahini makes the dip silkier without a distinct taste. You may not detect it at first, but you’ll notice the extra depth it brings.

8 / 10

A spoon drizzles caramel sauce over three scoops of vanilla ice cream in a light gray bowl, set against a marble background.
Christine Ma for Taste of Home

Make Tahini Magic Shell

Magic Shell holds a special place in my heart because, as a kid, I thought it really was magical. The liquid hardened over ice cream almost as soon as it hit, and the resulting crunchy shell melted in my mouth as soon as I took a bite. So when Taste of Home editor Melissa Gaman told me about tahini magic shell, I think my mind exploded a bit. Of course, I had to try it!

To make homemade magic shell with tahini, stir 1/2 cup tahini and 1/4 cup warm, melted coconut oil until smooth. Add a pinch of salt if you want to bring out the savory sesame flavor. Dip frozen homemade popsicles into the shell, or drizzle it over ice cream. If you end up with leftovers, pop it in the fridge. Before using it, reheat it in the microwave, stirring occasionally until it’s just warm enough to become liquid again.

9 / 10

Shot of the peanut butter toast with banana slices and pomegranate on a plate.
Wirestock/Getty Images

Spread Tahini on Toast

Turn a humble slice of bread into a satisfying snack or meal, depending on how wild you go with toppings. I usually start simple with a smear of tahini, a drizzle of honey and a sprinkle of sesame seeds and flaky sea salt. When I’m feeling fancy, I’ll add even more sweet or savory toppings.

You can really customize this toast however you like. Try sliced apples or bananas and a dusting of cinnamon for breakfast. Or for something crunchy, try roasted chickpeas and za’atar seasoning. If you’re looking for a satisfying lunch, grab tomatoes and feta cheese. The possibilities are truly endless.

10 / 10

A blended mixture of oats, water, maple syrup, and salt
ELLIE CROWLEY FOR TASTE OF HOME

Blend Tahini for Dairy-Free Milk

This might be the easiest homemade dairy-free milk ever! Simply combine 1/2 cup of tahini and 3 cups of water in a blender. For a touch of sweetness, add a few pitted dates, a splash of maple syrup or a tablespoon or two of honey. Then, just blend until everything is well combined. Homemade tahini milk doesn’t need to be strained like other nut milks, since the tahini is already ground and smooth. You’ll have creamy, pourable milk in seconds.

Store it in a covered container in the fridge for up to five days. The milk may separate as it sits, but a firm shake before using will bring it back together. Use the sesame-flavored milk in smoothies, granola or coffee. I like adding it to chai, where the nuttiness blends with warming spices for a comforting treat.