Save on Pinterest

19 Personalized Baby Gifts They’ll Cherish

Make shopping for a newborn even more special with these personalized baby gifts. We found practical items, sentimental keepsakes and cute, custom presents.

Every editorial product is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links. Ratings and prices are accurate and items are in stock as of time of publication.

1 / 19

Giraffe Heirloom Baby Blanket Ecomm Via Potterybarnkidsvia merchant

Monogrammed Giraffe Baby Blanket

When it comes to personalized baby gifts, you can’t go wrong with a baby blanket. We love this adorable giraffe-patterned option from Pottery Barn. Add the little one’s name in one of three fonts and four colors. It makes for a great baby shower gift, as well!

Shop Now

2 / 19

Baby Gift Box Baby Gift Set Ecomm Via Etsy.comvia merchant

Baby Gift Box

You can customize several aspects of this sweet baby gift box from Etsy. Choose from baby boy, girl or gender-neutral themes, then opt for one of several stuffed animal selections. A personalized card completes this darling care package.

Shop Now

3 / 19

Personalized Moon And Stars Nightlight Ecomm Via Uncommongoodsvia merchant

Name Nightlight

Sweet dreams await when this personalized moon and stars nightlight is in the nursery. Available at Uncommon Goods, this unique gift is powered by a USB cord and casts a soft, cozy glow. It’s perfect for nighttime feedings and, as the child gets older, fending off monsters under the bed.

Shop Now

4 / 19

Custom Name Hand Embroidery Baby Bow Ecomm Via Etsy.comvia merchant

Embroidered Baby Bow

Big bows are all the rage. And this hand-embroidered option from Etsy is extra-special. Pick from several fabrics and thread color options for the perfect fit. Plus, it’s one of the more budget-friendly personalized baby gifts you can buy.

Shop Now

5 / 19

Musical Horse Nursery Rocker Ecomm Via Potterybarnkidsvia merchant

Personalized Nursery Rocker

While baby won’t be able to play on this nursery rocker from Pottery Barn for a few years, it’s still a darling addition to their nursery. We love this classic horse option with a customizable base. Choose from eight fonts and 10 colors to add their name or other short text.

Shop Now

6 / 19

6 Models Custom Baby Busy Board Ecomm Via Etsy.comvia merchant

Personalized Busy Board

Little hands will stay occupied for hours thanks to this personalized busy board. Available on Etsy, this simply toy encourages motor skills development, touching and problem-solving. Each puzzle includes your child’s name, as well as a variety of themed shapes. Plus, you can engrave a personalized message on the back!

Shop Now

7 / 19

Personalized Name Pillow Ecomm Via Oliveandcocoa.comvia merchant

Name Pillow

Add some color to their nursery with this personalized name pillow from Olive & Cocoa. Available in two designsbranches and critters or flowers and butterfliesthis pillow is a sweet addition to a rocking chair or recliner.

Shop Now

8 / 19

Monogrammed Christmas Sotcking Ecomm Via Llbean.comvia merchant

Monogrammed Christmas Stocking

It’s never too early to think of the holidays. And the mom-to-be will appreciate your forethought when you show up with this monogrammed Christmas stocking from L.L. Bean. We love the retro needlepoint style and bountiful designs to choose from. This is a sweet baptism gift, too.

Shop Now

9 / 19

Crochet Baby Rattle With Grip Ecomm Via Etsy.comvia merchant

Custom Baby Rattle

There’s only one word for this personalized baby gift: precious. Made of cotton and beech wood, these sweet Etsy crocheted rattles come in several animal styles and colors. Add an engraving to one (or both!) sides of the holder, too.

Shop Now

10 / 19

Personalized Piggy Bank Ecomm Via Uncommongoodsvia merchant

Alphabet Piggy Bank

It’s never too early to start saving for your little one’s goals! And this alphabet piggy bank from Uncommon Goods is a practical, personalized baby gift. Not only does it look cool in the nursery (and later in their big-kid bedroom), but it gives mom and dad a purposeful spot to stash loose coins.

Shop Now

11 / 19

Personalized Book For Baby Ecomm Via Etsy..comvia merchant

Custom Nursery Rhyme Book

What child wouldn’t want to be the subject of their bedtime stories? This personalized nursery book from Etsy includes songs, poems and lullabies with your little one’s name. Not only will it be a nighttime staple for years, but it’s beautifully illustrated, too.

Shop Now

12 / 19

Supersoft Animal Baby Hooded Towel And Washcloth Set Ecomm Via Potterybarnkidsvia merchant

Monogrammed Hooded Towel

Bath time for older babies just got more fun! This hooded animal towel and washcloth set—available in bunny, lion and lamb styles—can be monogrammed with the child’s name. Pick it up at Pottery Barn.

Shop Now

13 / 19

Name Cutouts For Nursery Wooden Letters Ecom Via Etsy.comvia merchant

Nursery Name Sign

Another nursery trend? Large name signs above the crib. We’re fans of this cutout option from Etsy that’s customizable with several widths, two wood types and a dozen middle name fonts.

Shop Now

14 / 19

Custom Hand Embroidered Baby Crewneck Ecomm Via Etsy.comvia merchant

Embroidered Crewneck Sweatshirt

Chilly days call for comfy sweatshirts. And this tiny option from Etsy is perfect for baby. Hand-embroidered in the thread color of your choice, this name crewneck is a comfy addition to baby’s wardrobe.

Shop Now

15 / 19

Personalized Baby Photo Album Ecomm Via Uncommongoodsvia merchant

Personalized Baby Photo Album

New parents take a ton of pictures. Preserve all of the important memories in this Uncommon Goods photo album. Available in pink, blue or mint, this keepsake is personalized with baby’s name and birth date.

Shop Now

16 / 19

Personalized Watercolor Whale Ecomm Via Etsy.comvia merchant

Personalized Lovey

This adorable lovey will become their all-time favorite. An oh-so-comfy faux fur backing, cute watercolor whale print and personalized name detail make this Etsy gift a keeper.

Shop Now

17 / 19

Dalmatian Childrens Art Ecomm Via Mintedvia merchant

Nursery Name Art

This gender-neutral art print from Minted will look great on any nursery wall. We love the playful Dalmatian, six colorways, array of sizes and plentiful framing options. Plus, you can add baby’s name to the balloon.

Shop Now

18 / 19

Personalized Constellation Growth Chart Ecomm Via Uncommongoodsvia merchant

Personalized Growth Chart

Little ones don’t stay little for long! Soak up every moment with this personalized growth chart from Uncommon Goods. Include their name and an optional quote, then watch as they reach for the stars.

Shop Now

19 / 19

Customized Rainbow Abacus Toy Ecomm Via Etsy.comvia merchant

Custom Abacus Toy

Another toy that helps with baby’s development, this custom abacus from Etsy is both pretty and practical. Opt for one of 11 color themes, then personalize the middle ring’s beads with your little one’s name. Bonus: This is one of those personalized baby gifts that doubles as nursery decor.

Shop Now

Katie Bandurski
As Senior Shopping Editor, Katie connects Taste of Home readers with the best gifts, deals and home products on the market. An avid foodie and a holiday enthusiast, Katie is an expert at cultivating meaningful moments. When she’s out of the office, you’ll find her exploring Wisconsin, trying out new vegetarian recipes and watching Christmas movies.