Save on Pinterest

Top 10 Amish Baking Secrets—Revealed

If you're a fan of Amish sugar cookies, you'll love this cooking advice, passed down from generation to generation.

1 / 12
Professional female baker cooking dough with eggs, butter and milk for Christmas cookies. ; Shutterstock ID 340582067; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeShutterstock/Stasique

When it comes to scratch-made foods, it doesn’t get much more authentic than the Amish kitchen. Characterized by communities that eschew materialism and avoid modern conveniences and technology, many Amish bake bread in wood-burning stoves, preserve pies in iceboxes and beat their eggs without the aid of electricity. While you may not want to adopt the complete Amish lifestyle (taking a buggy to the grocery store could be a tad inconvenient), you can still take some tips from their time-tested vault of secrets. Here are 10 takeaways for any clever baker.

2 / 12
Detox drink made of water, apple cider vinegar, lemon juice and baking soda; Shutterstock ID 580918609NoirChocolate/Shutterstock

1. Use Vinegar in Cherry Desserts

From homemade salad dressings to unorthodox pie fillings, vinegar lends a pleasant bite to all kinds of foods. According to The Amish Cook columnist Elizabeth Coblentz, the acidity plays up the tart taste in cherries, so she made vinegar a staple in her cherry baked goods.

3 / 12
Desserts choice. Cookies and biscuits in glass jars on counter bar for sale. Chocolate drops and chips, oatmeal cookies stacks.; Shutterstock ID 490086187Shutterstock/Prostock-studio

2. Keep Your Cookies Fresh

Without refrigerators, the Amish have to be careful when storing food. They’ve learned, for example, that cookies stay fresh longer when stored in an airtight container with a little piece of bread. And it doesn’t have to come from a loaf of Amish potato bread; plain sandwich bread will do the trick.

4 / 12
Anzac biscuits close up in baking dish on the table. horizontal view from aboveShutterstock/AS Food studio

3. Always Make More than You Think You’ll Need

Amish community dinners have to feed as many as 600 people, so people are accustomed to making food in large quantities. But even when they’re just cooking for immediate family, Amish bakers typically double the recipe. Pies or cakes are such delicious delicacies that they get eaten quickly—and, like many of us, the Amish enjoy snacking on cookies after church service on Sundays—so they make extra batches to eat throughout the week.

Inspired to cook like the Amish? Here are some recipes from the Pennsylvania Dutch to get you started.

5 / 12
Bread,Japanese butter roll,bread roll; Shutterstock ID 677550253Shutterstock/gontabunta

4. Brush the Top of Your Bread with Butter

Making friendship bread, a treat synonymous with Amish baking, can be tedious. Noted for its incredibly moist texture, it takes an entire week to make, with specific instructions detailed for each day. If you can’t imagine devoting this kind of time to bread, there’s a trick to giving other homemade breads an Amish flavor: Brush melted butter across the top before baking. This will make the bread softer and give it a golden appearance and crispy crunch.

Terrified to make bread at home? These non-scary bread recipes are easy enough for anyone to bake!

6 / 12
Macro still-life of serving spoon overflowing with brown sugar onto color coordinated porcelain tile. Glass canister of brown sugar and homespun cloth out of focus in the background. Shallow dof; Shutterstock ID 6792511; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeShutterstock/Marie C Fields

5. Break up the Brown Sugar

While rock solid brown sugar might seem inevitable, the Amish found an easy way to make it soft again. Place a small piece of bread or apple in the bag with the sugar and leave alone for a little while. When you come back, the sugar will be soft again.

(A slice of bread is more utilitarian than you’d think! Here are some other tools you’ll need before you start rolling dough.)

7 / 12
hot pepper; Shutterstock ID 592560635; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of HomeShutterstock/Ilzira

6. Add a Little Spice

While you might like to add a dash of cinnamon to bread or a sprinkle of cocoa to cookies, the Amish are known to use hot peppers to add spice to their foods. Adding a bit of hot pepper can make any boring dish exciting. A common example is hot pepper butter, which adds a thrill to even the most basic bread loaves.

Here’s our guide to peppers, from sweet to flamin’ hot.

8 / 12
Beef meat stew. Overhead view braised beef meat stew with vegetables in pot.; Shutterstock ID 496497469; Job (TFH, TOH, RD, BNB, CWM, CM): Taste of Homecasanisa/Shutterstock

7. Pay Attention to Color

When preparing your food, don’t live and die by the recommended cooking time. Instead, closely monitor the color of soups, casseroles and baked goods to tell when they’re done. Crisp edges or a boiling surface can indicate when food is ready. The Amish know to remove things from the heat when they reach the appropriate color or texture, and this leads to more satisfying results than simply setting a timer and walking away.

For more old-fashioned cooking know-how, see 12 timeless tips we learned from Grandma.

9 / 12
Herb butter on bread.Shutterstock/HandmadePictures

8. Never Serve Plain Butter

The Amish don’t often indulge, but they rarely serve butter plain when there are so many varieties to enjoy. Common types include apple, grape, red pepper and various herb butters. Take a page from the Amish book and add flair to your dinner table by trying these scrumptious compound butters.

10 / 12
Preparing the shopping list before going to buy the groceries. ; Shutterstock ID 221603185conejota/Shutterstock

9. When It Comes to Celebrations, Start Early

The Amish start meal planning for large occasions weeks in advance. They make plans for shopping, and they prep ingredients and dishes that freeze well, such as casseroles, broths and simple cookies. And they begin gathering gifts, putting decorations together and doing other small tasks as early as possible.

Eliminate holiday stress by making a shopping list, making sure you have the necessary recipes on hand and getting ready to bake before it’s actually time to begin. Check out these list-making tips from the pros.

11 / 12
Old recipe box, with sections for cakes, meats, etc. ; Shutterstock ID 159058811Shutterstock/Robyn Mackenzie

10. Save Every Great Recipe

Amish or not, passing down recipes from one generation to the next is a tradition that holds people together. Whenever you make something that your family loves—whether it is an original recipe or adaptation of someone else’s—be sure to copy the ingredients and steps, and save them somewhere safe.

When your children grow up and start their own families, there is nothing more special than passing down treasured family recipes. Begin teaching them how to prepare the dishes when they’re little. Cooking with your kids is a great way to bring the family together.

12 / 12
Taste of Home

Your Turn!

Now that you know the secrets to baking like an Amish cook, try your hand at this famous Amish Sugar Cookie recipe. It’s one of the most popular desserts on our website, and it’s no surprise why: The time-tested, melt-in-your-mouth taste is simply unparalleled.

Popular Videos