Reese’s Cupcakes Are Jam-Packed with Creamy Peanut Butter, and We Need Some ASAP

Every editorial product is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links. Ratings and prices are accurate and items are in stock as of time of publication.

Fans of the iconic Reese's peanut butter cup will love Reese's cupcakes.

The best-known brand of peanut butter cup in America—and quite possibly the world—is back at it again.

Reese’s has a knack for offering inventive ways to satisfy peanut butter-and-chocolate cravings. They’ve sold one-pound versions of their peanut butter cups, a Take 5 bar that incorporates the brand’s classic peanut butter and an ice cream cake filled with peanut butter, among other things.

Now they’ve teamed up with Mrs. Freshley’s to bring us our newest obsession: Reese’s cupcakes.

What’s in Each Cupcake?

Creamy and dreamy, these cupcakes will satisfy even the brand’s biggest fan. They’re filled with that classic Reese’s peanut butter we all know and love, while the cake itself is chocolate-flavored (get it? It’s like a Reese’s cup!). The whole thing is frosted with peanut butter icing, and brown, orange and yellow sprinkles add Reese’s pieces-inspired pop of color. There are 480 calories in a two-cupcake pack, meaning one cake clocks in at 240 calories.

If you’re having trouble finding a way to pick up this latest delicious offering from Reese’s, try making your own desserts inspired by those beloved peanut butter cups. Bake a Reese’s snack cake, make your own homemade peanut butter cups or even indulge in a peanut butter cup cheesecake.

If you’re a peanut butter cup fan looking for more varieties of your favorite candy, check out our taste test. Spoiler alert: Reese’s wasn’t number one!

Where Can I Find Them?

The news of these delightful desserts broke last year at the National Association of Convenience Stores, so we’ve had to wait a little while to pluck them off of store shelves. Thankfully, 2020 brought them to Mrs. Freshley’s retailers, which include Walmart, Sam’s Club and Amazon.

The cupcakes are usually sold in packs of two, although Sam’s Club offers them in a 12-pack combination with another offering from Mrs. Freshley’s: Hershey’s Triple Chocolate Cakes. Whichever retailer you choose, we know you’re in for a peanut-buttery treat.

For Chocolate-PB Lovers Only
1 / 45

Popular Videos

Emily Hannemann
Emily adores both food and writing, so combining those passions as a writer for Taste of Home makes perfect sense. Her work has also appeared in Birds & Blooms and on TV Insider. When she’s not eating peanut butter straight from the jar, you'll find her running or birdwatching. Emily is currently a journalism graduate student at the University of Missouri.