Capture the flavor of juicy, fresh strawberries with this old-fashioned strawberry cake recipe. Here's how to make it.
How to Make an Old-Fashioned Strawberry Cake from Scratch
Updated Feb. 14, 2022
If you’re a fan of fresh strawberries, chances are you love them baked into a dessert as well. The only problem? Fresh strawberries can lose their flavor and color during the process. But not with this old-fashioned strawberry cake recipe.
A homemade strawberry puree used in both the cake batter and the frosting is the perfect solution. It’s fresh, moist and wonderfully flavored. It’s made entirely from scratch, too—no need for Jell-O or a boxed mix with this cake. (Use your mix in these strawberry cake mix cookies instead.)
Old-Fashioned Strawberry Cake Recipe
Ingredients
- 2 sticks unsalted butter, softened
- 1-1/2 cups sugar
- 2 whole eggs, room temperature
- 1 egg white, room temperature
- 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
- 2 cups all-purpose flour
- 2-1/2 teaspoons baking powder
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- 1 cup milk
- 2-1/2 pounds fresh strawberries
Frosting:
- 2 sticks unsalted butter, softened
- 1 (8-ounce) brick cream cheese, softened
- 9 cups confectioners’ sugar
- 2 tablespoons milk
- 4 tablespoons strawberry puree
Editor’s Tip: There are many types of food coloring but we prefer gel food coloring if you’d like an extra pop of color.
Tools You’ll Need
- Food Processor: Puree the strawberries until completely smooth with ease using a food processor. This model is the best food processor of the bunch, according to our Test Kitchen.
- Stand Mixer: A KitchenAid stand mixer will make the process of mixing the batter and frosting quick and easy. It looks gorgeous on the countertop, too!
- 8-in. Cake Pans: Bake your strawberry cakes in round 8-inch cake pans for the best results.
Directions
Step 1: Make the strawberry puree
Rinse the strawberries, remove the stems and roughly chop them. Puree the strawberries in a food processor until smooth. Once pureed, there should be about 2-1/2 cups of liquid. Transfer the strawberry puree into a small saucepan. Turn the heat on the stovetop to low and allow the puree to simmer, stirring occasionally, for 30 minutes until reduced. Transfer the reduction to a bowl and chill it in the fridge until completely cool.
Step 2: Prep the cake pans
Preheat the oven to 350°F. Grease two 8-inch round cake pans with cooking spray or butter. Cut out a circular piece of parchment paper to place in the bottom of each pan to prevent sticking.
Step 3: Make the strawberry cake batter
In a mixing bowl, combine the flour, baking powder, baking soda and salt. Whisk until smooth and set aside.
Cream the softened butter and sugar until light and fluffy. (This is how to cream butter and sugar.) Mix in the two whole eggs and one egg white, along with the vanilla extract.
Mix in 1/3 of the flour mixture, then add half of the milk. Add in another 1/3 of the flour mixture, the remaining milk and then the remaining flour mixture. Stir in 1 cup of strawberry puree, leaving the remaining puree for the frosting.
Mix in red gel food coloring, if a stronger pink color is desired.
Step 4: Bake the cakes
Divide the batter between the two prepared cake pans. Bake the cakes for 25 minutes, until a toothpick inserted in the middle comes out clean. Once baked, remove the cakes from the oven. Allow the cakes to cool for 20 minutes before removing them from the cake pans. Set aside on a cooling rack to cool completely.
Step 5: Make the strawberry frosting
Cream the softened butter and cream cheese until well combined and fluffy. Mix in 2 cups of confectioners’ sugar, along with 2 tablespoons of milk. Continue to mix in the powdered sugar, alternating with the strawberry puree. Scrape the sides of the bowl with a spatula as needed. With all of the powdered sugar added and the frosting coming together, turn the speed up on the mixture to whip until fluffy.
Step 6: Assemble your strawberry cake
Place one cooled cake round on a cake stand or plate. Spread frosting over the cake round and then place the second cake round on top. Frost the rest of the cake with the strawberry frosting, covering the sides and top. Garnish with fresh strawberries, if desired.
Editor’s Tip: Read up on how to frost a cake like a pro for a smooth-looking finish.
Tips for Making an Old-Fashioned Strawberry Cake
When should I wash the strawberries?
For this cake, be sure you’re using fresh, ripe strawberries. For best results, wash your strawberries right before you’re going to use them. Washing strawberries when you get home from the store will cause the fruit to begin breaking down.
What’s the best frosting to use?
A simple vanilla buttercream frosting or even a punchy lemon frosting would be a lovely addition to this cake. However, to really amp up the strawberry flavor, fresh strawberry frosting is best. This recipe uses cream cheese frosting as a base to add stability, while including fresh strawberry puree for great flavor. The end result? It tastes like strawberry ice cream!
The frosting will be a light pink hue, but you can certainly enhance that with red gel food coloring.
Can I skip reducing the strawberries?
Because strawberries are an incredibly porous fruit, they can be tricky to work with. A juicy strawberry is great for eating, but it’s not necessarily great for baking! If you were to add chunks of fresh strawberries or a fresh strawberry puree without reducing it, the color of your cake would be lost along the way. Often, strawberries can turn an unappealing grayish purple color while baking.
The first step to avoid this color mishap is to reduce the fresh strawberries. By simmering the strawberries, a lot of the water content is released. This leaves you with a concentration of strawberry flavor and a ruby red hue.
After mixing in the strawberry puree, you’ll end up with a light pink batter. This is certainly pretty on its own, but you can make it bolder. Just a few drops of red gel food coloring will make the color much more vibrant.
How do I store leftover slices of strawberry cake?
If you don’t devour all of this old-fashioned strawberry cake in one day, you can save it for later. Place a dome on your cake stand, or use a large bowl in a pinch. This will allow you to keep your cake fresh for another day or two.
If you want to keep your cake even longer, cut it into slices and wrap them individually in plastic wrap. Be sure they’re airtight! Freeze the cake slices for up to a month. When you want a slice, simply pull one out of the freezer and wait patiently for it to come up to room temperature. Once the cake slice is thawed, grab a fork and dig in!
Vintage Cakes We Can't Resist
Pecan Pound CakeThis pecan pound cake always turns out great. It's wonderful with a steaming cup of coffee on a chilly winter day. —Fleta West, Hayes, Virginia
Icebox CakeYou don't have to bake to serve a wonderful dessert! This icebox cake is made from chocolate wafers and whipping cream. It is so delicious.—Cindy Hawkins, New York, New York. If you're looking for more recipes, then you must try these vintage chocolate desserts.
Glazed Lemon Chiffon CakeThis fluffy cake is a real treat drizzled with the sweet-tart lemon glaze. —Rebecca Baird, Salt Lake City, Utah
Italian Cream Cheese CakeButtermilk makes every bite of this awesome Italian cream cheese cake recipe moist and flavorful. I rely on this recipe year-round. —Joyce Lutz, Centerview, Missouri
Classic Pineapple Upside-Down CakeThis pineapple upside-down cake is a classic recipe that never goes out of style! It’s delicious with the traditional pineapple, but try it with peaches or a combination of cranberries and orange. —Bernardine Melton, Paola, Kansas. Love upside-down cakes? Be sure to check our favorite cranberry duff.
Hummingbird CakeThis impressive hummingbird cake is my dad’s favorite, so I always make it for his birthday. It makes a memorable dessert for any celebration and is lovely with a summer meal. —Nancy Zimmerman, Cape May Court House, New Jersey
Spiced Devil's Food CakeOne of my mom's friends gave her this recipe when I was a child, and it has been a family favorite ever since. When your chocolate sweet tooth acts up, this really hits the spot! —Linda Yeamans, Ashland, Oregon
7UP Pound CakeThis classic 7UP cake recipe uses the carbonated beverage to bake a tall pound cake with hints of lemon and lime. We also use the soda in the glaze to really drive home its iconic flavor.
Southern Lane CakeWhat’s the most sumptuous, indulgent cake you can bake for your guests? The answer is probably Lane Cake, a Southern classic with a rich history and even richer filling. This Lane Cake recipe takes some planning and patience, but it’s all worth it in the end.Â
Gran's Apple CakeMy grandmother occasionally brought over this wonderful cake warm from the oven. The spicy apple flavor combined with the sweet cream cheese frosting made this recipe one that we treasured. Even though I've lightened it up, it's still a family favorite. —Lauris Conrad, Turlock, California
Red Velvet CakeOur red velvet cake recipe is traditionally southern with light, tender, ruby-red cakes held together with a rich vanilla frosting.
Traditional Sponge CakeThis light sponge cake makes a fitting finale to any meal.—Arlene Murphy, Beverly Hills, Florida
Walnut Blitz TorteThis pretty torte is very popular at family gatherings. The cake layers are baked with the frosting—crunchy, sweet meringue—already in place, and then assembled with a layer of luscious custard in the center. Whenever I make it, everyone always asks me for the recipe. —Suzan Stacey, Parsonsfield, ME
Banana CakeLeftover ripe bananas aren't just for banana bread! Try our banana cake recipe covered with cream cheese frosting to make a sheet cake that you'll want to eat right out of the pan.
German Apple CakeWith the long, cold winters we have here, this German apple cake recipe has warmed many a kitchen. The cake is perfect for breakfast, dessert or an evening snack. I've often made it for parties, and I've always received compliments on it. —Grace Reynolds, Bethlehem, Pennsylvania
Tres Leches CakeExperience the ultimate in creamy, dreamy desserts with this easy-to-make tres leches cake, soaked in a trio of milks and finished with a cloud of whipped cream.
Layered Yellow Cake with Chocolate ButtercreamThis yellow cake will become your go-to recipe for birthdays, but the tender cake with flavorful chocolate buttercream is truly perfect for any occasion. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Apple Brandy Pecan CakeMy favorite apple cake is made with a shot of brandy and drizzled with caramel to set off the wonderful flavors. If alcohol is a no-go, use orange juice instead of apple brandy. If you'd rather follow a chocolate route, add mini chocolate chips to the cake and use chocolate ice cream topping for the drizzle. —Nancy Heishman, Las Vegas, Nevada
Angel Food CakeThis top-rated angel food cake recipe is a light and airy dessert everyone loves. It's heavenly served with berries or other fresh fruit and a dollop of homemade whipped cream.
Coconut Chiffon CakeToasted coconut adds visual appeal to this tall and impressive cake. With an airy texture and heavenly coconut-ginger flavor,it's a lovely end to meals throughout the year.
Chocolate CakeWe can confidently say that this is the best chocolate cake recipe and, at Taste of Home, we make (and eat!) a lot of cakes. With three moist, fluffy cake layers and a rich, decadent chocolate frosting, we think this will become your go-to chocolate dessert as well.
Next: Learn about the king cake!
Originally Published: February 14, 2022
