How to Make an Oatmeal Cookie Drink Like a Bartender
Updated: Nov. 27, 2019
It's the perfect season to discover the deliciousness of an oatmeal cookie drink. Read on to see how you can perfect your recipe.
Loved Grandma’s oatmeal cookies? Well, there’s now a way you can enjoy it in cocktail form. By combining liquor that’s flavored with cinnamon, cream and butterscotch, the drink ends up tasting like the classic dessert you enjoyed growing up.
There are quite a few ways you can make an oatmeal cookie drink. We’ll share our basic recipe first, then offer up a few fun adjustments to make it your own.
How to Make Our Oatmeal Cookie Drink
Ingredients
Equal parts:
- Irish cream, like Baileys
- Goldschlager, or other cinnamon schnapps
- Butterscotch schnapps
Don’t forget to take a peek at our list of everything you need for a home bar setup.
Instructions
Step 1: Mix the ingredients
Pour 1 or 1-1/2 ounces of each of the three liqueurs above into a chilled and/or ice-filled cocktail shaker. Then, shake well.
Don’t have a shaker? Check out our recommendations for the best cocktail shakers for your home bar. You can also stir in a large glass, until evenly mixed.
Step 2: Serve with a flourish
Pour into a rocks glass over ice (or if shaken with ice, strain into a lovely coupe glass).
Be sure to garnish. Top your drink off with an oatmeal cookie, brown sugar the rim, throw in a cinnamon stick or add a dollop of whipped cream. Just make sure to have fun with it!
Oatmeal Cookie Drink Variations
1. Extra Merry Oatmeal Cookie Drink
For a punchier version (read: more potent), try mixing the following five liqueurs in equal measure:
- Baileys
- Goldschlager
- Kahlua
- RumChata
- Jagermeister
Editor’s Tip: You can use rum in place of the RumChata for a less sweet and creamy version.
2. RumChata’s Quick Oatmeal Cookie Drink
If you like to keep things simple, try this variation—it’s RumChata’s own oatmeal cookie recipe. It skips the butterscotch schnapps, which many of us don’t keep stocked in our liquor cabinet.
- 1 part RumChata
- 1 part Goldschlager
- A splash of Jagermeister
3. Fireball Oatmeal Cookie Drink
Last but not least, try this recipe which includes the ever-popular Fireball.
- 1 part Fireball whisky
- 1 part Irish cream
- 2 parts coffee liqueur
- 3 parts butterscotch schnapps
This recipe works well, as it has lots of creaminess and sweetness from the Irish cream plus coffee liqueur to temper the bite of Fireball. Find more drink ideas for Fireball.
Whichever version becomes your personal go-to, make sure to share your oatmeal cookie drink with those you love. It’s a delicious welcome that will make your guests feel right at home!
Brandy Old-Fashioned Sweet
Dating back all the way to 1806, the Old-Fashioned has a well deserved moniker. But the perfect balance of brandy, bitters, citrus, fruit and a splash of soda (a favorite addition via Wisconsin), make this cocktail an enduring classic. Check out these other easy mixed drinks you should know.
Martini
Shaken or stirred, the Martini is the quintessential classic cocktail. Made with gin or vodka, this drink harkens back to bygone eras, though it's a perpetual favorite. Have you ever tried a lychee martini? Here's how to make one.
Bloody Mary
In the early part of the 20th century, vodka and tomato juice was a popular pairing. Soon, though, bartenders began adding a little spice to the drink transforming it into the Bloody Mary that we love today – spicy, savory and served with plenty of garnishes. Learn how to make the best ever Bloody Mary.
Mai Tai
Though it's origins are subject to debate, the Mai Tai ushered in a new wave of mixology in the United States. This tropical, rum drink is synonymous with mid-century tiki culture (and it's darn good to boot). Mai tais are one of our favorite birthday cocktails!
Gimlet
Simple yet refreshing, it's no wonder the Gimlet has stood the test of time. This combination of lime juice and gin (or vodka if you prefer) is the perfect elixir on balmy days. These vintage drinks deserve a comeback.
Moscow Mule
In recent years, the Moscow Mule has surged in popularity. However, its history can be traced all the way back to the early '40s right here in the USA. With strong ginger flavors paired with lime and vodka, we're not surprised this cocktail had a major comeback. Love mules? Try one of these fun variations.
Refreshing Mojito
This drink first swelled in popularity during the 1920s in Cuba. The combination of fresh mint, a squeeze of lime and white rum was so irresistible that tourists and servicemen demanded the drink upon coming back to the US. And we're happy they did!
Fresh Lime Margaritas
Coming from south of the border is the ever-popular Margarita. This tequila and lime combo made it's debut in Mexico in the early part of the 1900s, and it's been a regular on bar menus ever since. Here's how to take your marg to the next level.
Mint Julep
While it's claim to fame is being the traditional Derby Day drink, the Mint Julep has a long history predating the race. Americans have been enjoying juleps since the 1700s. Packed with fresh mint and bourbon, we're happy this classic hasn't gone out of style. For more flavorful drinks, check out our guide to lychee cocktail recipes.
White Chocolate Brandy Alexander
On the sweeter side of classic cocktails, you'll find the Brandy Alexander. Part brandy, part creme de cacao and part cream, this libation makes a smooth, tasty after dinner drink.
