This Is The Secret For Making Perfect Grilled Cheese Every. Single. Time.

Say goodbye to messy, unevenly toasted grilled cheese sandwiches with this genius Amazon kitchen tool.

Our editors and experts handpick every product we feature. We may earn a commission from your purchases.

Mastering the art of the perfectly grilled cheese sandwich is a feat. More often that not, the bread toasts unevenly or faster than the cheese has time to get nice and melty. Or worse, the cheese melts too fast and spills out the edges and onto the frying pan, resulting in a burnt mess (though a little crispy cheese—AKA frico—is OK with us!.

Luckily for grilled cheese fanatics, we found a prep tool from Amazon that makes perfect grilled cheese sandwiches (and it beats the TikTok viral toaster grilled cheese method). The Nostalgia Grilled Cheese Toaster is a convenient, time-saving gadget that evenly toasts bread and melts cheese—minus the mess.

What Is A Grilled Cheese Toaster?

The Nostalgia Grilled Cheese Toaster is no ordinary toaster. It’s a vintage-looking, yellow gadget with reusable toasting baskets for carefully inserting grilled cheese sandwiches and holding them together while they toast. Unlike normal toasters, this appliance features a pre-heat setting, which makes sure grilled cheese sandwiches are cooked at the optimal temperature for achieving evenly toasted bread slices and melted cheese every. single. time.

It’s one of those kitchen gadgets you won’t believe is real thanks to how weirdly specific yet highly functional it is, and its retro-looking aesthetic makes it an Amazon kitchen find that’s too pretty to hide. Plus, it’s one of the best gifts for foodies of all ages.

How To Use A Grilled Cheese Toaster

Start by pre-heating the grilled cheese toaster. This is an important step as it makes sure sandwiches are cooked at just the right temperature. As it pre-heats, butter the outside pieces of bread (this step is KEY for achieving toasty slices) and assemble your grilled cheese. Amazon reviewers note that thinner slices of bread with two slices of cheese each is ideal.

When the toaster is done preheating, place the sandwiches in the toaster baskets and slide them in. Use the dial to select the level of toasty-ness you desire, wait a few minutes, and voila! A delectable, evenly toasted grilled cheese sandwich awaits.

Product Features

  • Cooks two grilled cheese sandwiches at a time
  • Includes toasting baskets with heat-resistant handles
  • Three functions: pre-heat, defrost and cancel
  • Toasting dial for selecting different browning levels
  • Removable drip tray for catching crumbs
  • Electric toaster with cord wrap for easy storage

The Best Amazon User Reviews

“This is a very easy way to quickly make a delicious grilled cheese,” shares one verified Amazon reviewer. “Once the toaster has preheated, all you do is drop the baskets in with your sandwich and select how long you want it to cook for. I am never using my stove again when my kids want a grilled cheese just because it’s easier and more efficient to use this grilled cheese toaster.”

“The single most used small appliance in my house!” shares verified Amazon reviewer, Christopher. “Makes perfect grilled cheese. Requires very thin bread, but the sandwiches come out perfectly toasted, and melty. Just wash the baskets to keep them clean.”

Verified Amazon purchaser, Michelle, attests to the gadget’s ease of use: “I love grilled cheese sandwiches, but sometimes, I just don’t want to make one. This is a fancy toaster with wide slots and a basket to hold the sandwich together, and it’s a quick and easy way to make grilled cheese. It’s not messy. It cleans up easily. I have never had cheese spill out the edge of my sandwich. It doesn’t get too hot. It’s easy to store, and it makes great grilled cheese sandwiches.”

Where to Buy

Nostalgia Grilled Cheese Sandwich Toaster Ecommm Via Walmartvia merchant

Find the Nostalgia Grilled Cheese Toaster on Amazon, Walmart, QVC, The Home Depot, and Wayfair where it retails for $35-$50. It’s a popular kitchen gadget, so you’ll want to act fast before it sells out.

Shop Now

Want more fun product picks and money-saving deals from our shopping experts and Test Kitchen? Sign up for the Stuff We Love newsletter.

Madi Koetting
As Product Reviews Home Editor, Madi covers the best cleaning gadgets, organizing gear and home buys. She’s constantly testing internet-made-me-buy-it splurges and home goods—if there’s a viral product taking the internet by storm, you can count on Madi to give her honest review. Her work has appeared in various home outlets including Better Homes & Gardens, Reader’s Digest, The Family Handyman and Birds and Blooms. When she’s not decorating her apartment, you can find her sharing her favorite finds on Taste of Home’s social media platforms and scouring Denver for the best espresso martini.