#NationalPeanutButterDay doesn’t usually cause much of a stir (pun intended), though we’re all for celebrating America’s favorite spread. This year, however, the one brand that definitely knows its peanut butter decided to cash in on the hype.
Yep, we’re talking about Butterfinger, makers of the “crispety, crunchety, peanut-buttery” candy bar. They dropped a major hint on Instagram about making Butterfinger peanut butter.
Is It Really Happening?
On January 24th, the brand posted a picture of a jar of the Butterfinger-inspired peanut butter, captioning it, “We just had the best idea for #NationalPeanutButterDay. Just kidding…Unless?”
Safe to say, our taste buds are ready, but it doesn’t look like the brand is planning to commit right now. It’s a pity, because we’d love some crispety, crunchety action in our peanut butter jar, with some chocolate pieces to add to the fun!
Of course, the comments were predictably enthusiastic, with fans begging them to actually release it and not just tempt them. Honestly, we’re joining in the call for Butterfinger to make this peanut butter a real thing!
We’ve Still Got Hope
The idea may not be shelved for good: the photo also features an asterisk followed by the line, “Maybe in the future.” We’re keeping our fingers crossed that they stick to their promise in 2021! Until then, we’ll have to make do with do with our own crispy, crunchy concoctions, like these Butterfinger cookie bars or this Butterfinger cheesecake.
And hey, you could always make your own peanut butter at home and mix in some Butterfingers to add your own sweet crunch!
Our Best Recipes for Butterfinger Desserts
Butterfinger CookiesThese terrific cookies featuring a favorite candy don't last long—make a double batch! —Carol Kitchens, Ridgeland, Mississippi
Butterfinger Cookie BarsMy boys went through a phase where they loved Butterfingers. We made Butterfinger shakes, muffins, cookies and experimented with different bars; this one was voted the best of the bunch. Make sure you have an extra candy bar on hand because it’s hard to resist a nibble or two while you’re chopping. —Barbara Leighty, Simi Valley, California
Homemade Butterfinger BitesBent on using up a stash of leftover candy corn, I decided to experiment. Turns out, if you melt it, mix it with peanut butter and coat the balls with chocolate, you get a softer, denser version of a Butterfinger bite. Who knew? They’re delicious! —Melissa Hansen, Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Candy Bar Cheesecake BrowniesI came up with these brownies as a way to use up my son's leftover Halloween candy. You can tint the cream cheese orange for a spooky touch. —Elisabeth Larsen, Pleasant Grv, Utah
Quicker Blue-Ribbon Peanut Butter TorteNo one will guess that this tall, tiered cake isn't completely homemade. Chunky peanut butter is stirred into both the cake batter and the decadent chocolate ganache, giving each layer a rich, from-scratch taste. —Taste of Home Test Kitchen
Butterfinger Ice CreamAdd Butterfingers to this icy, creamy combination, and you get a no-fail sweet everyone will love. —Tammy Drost, Cheyenne, Wyoming
Ultimate Candy Bar CookiesI created these after Halloween, when I had way too much candy left over. You can make them with any mini chocolate candy, but if you use peanut butter cups, throw them in the freezer just before unwrapping so the chocolate won’t stick to the paper. —Tara John, Plymouth, Minnesota
Butterfinger CheesecakeI am a cheesecake fanatic! When I found this recipe featuring Butterfinger candy bars, I knew it was for me. Our pastor's wife asked me to share this recipe so she could make it to impress her family back home. She couldn't believe something so elegant-looking was so easy to prepare. —Melissa Pirtle, Fresno, California
Updated: Jan. 28, 2021
