These Are the Best Ice Cream Scoop Options According to Fanatics

Every editorial product is independently selected, though we may be compensated or receive an affiliate commission if you buy something through our links. Ratings and prices are accurate and items are in stock as of time of publication.

Find out which ice cream scoop you need to make that super sundae.

Between the two of us ice cream aficionados, we’ve sent many, many spoons to an early grave trying to scoop hard ice cream. Their frail, spindly spines just couldn’t hold up to my carton of cookies ‘n’ cream. Sure, we could have waited 15 minutes before digging into a batch of homemade strawberry ice cream, but who wants to wait?

So finally, after years of ruining spoons, spatulas and scoopers, we consulted with the pros in the Taste of Home Test Kitchen. If anyone would know ice cream and kitchen gear, it would be this talented team.

The Search for the Best Ice Cream Scoop

Our Test Kitchen team has tried dozens of scoops over the years. These expert cooks and bakers use scoops to top desserts with ice cream and scoop up the frozen treats they whip up in the kitchen. Pint after pint, a few brands of ice cream scoops really impressed our team.

Best Overall: Zeroll Ice Cream Scoop

Zeroll Ice Cream Scoopvia williams-sonoma.com

The Zeroll Ice Cream Scoop is a classic. This traditional scoop has been used in ice cream parlors since 1935, and this brand has been a favorite in the Test Kitchen for years.

What makes this basic scoop so beloved? First and foremost: It scoops really, really well. The heat conductive fluid in the handle warms up the metal so you can scoop through ice cream, gelato and sherbet with ease. This might sound pretty simple with so many fancy-looking scoopers on the market, but the Test Kitchen can attest to how well this basic technology works.

And let’s not forget one more thing: This Zeroll scoop is super durable. As long as you wash this by hand, this aluminum scooper should last you for years (and plenty of sundaes) to come.

Shop Now

Cleanest Scoop: Tovolo Tilt-Up Ice Cream Scoop

Tovolo Ice Cream Scoopvia target.com

What do you do with your spoon when you’re taking a break from scooping portion after portion of ice cream? Chances are that it goes right on the counter creating a mess. But, if you’ve got the right scoop, you can avoid all that stickiness. That scoop is the Tovolo Tilt-Up Ice Cream Scoop. The handle of this gadget has bulit-in feet that keep the scoop off your countertops and funnels any melting ice cream away.

But this scoop is more than just its mess-free feature. Its almond-shaped scoop digs in with ease and creates perfectly round scoops of sorbet.

Shop Now

Best Splurgy Scooper: Midnight Scoop

Midnight Scoopvia wayfair.com

Say hello to the Midnight Scoop: a feat of design, science and ice cream fanaticism. This scoop was designed by an aerospace engineer with ergonimics in mind. The curved handle helps you push through even extra-frozen ice cream with ease, relying on your shoulder and arm muscles—not your wrist. As for the scoop itself, it’s shaped to dig in and create generously sized portions of ice cream.

This space-age gadget is a bit pricier at $35, but if you’re serious about you’re ice cream the way we are, it’s well worth it. With its sturdy stainless steel construction, it might just be the last scoop you ever buy.

Shop Now

Best Budget Buy: OXO Point Ice Cream Scoop

Oxo Ice Cream Scoopvia crateandbarrel.com

You don’t need to spend a lot to get a good scooper in our books. The Test Kitchen also recommends this $10 OXO Ice Cream Scoop. It has a comfortable rubberized grip and a scoop with a pointed tip. Talk about smart!

That spade-shaped scoop makes diving into mix-in-filled pints of ice cream a breeze. No more getting snagged on a big chunk of cookie dough in that container of Ben & Jerry’s.

Shop Now

Need Some Ice Cream Inspo?

Try some homemade ice cream recipes and learn how to make professional ice cream right at home.

1 / 36

Popular Videos

Katie Bandurski
Katie is an Associate Editor for Taste of Home, specializing in writing and email newsletters. When she’s out of the office, you’ll find her exploring Wisconsin, trying out new vegetarian recipes and combing through antique shops.
Lisa Kaminski
Lisa is an editor at Taste of Home where she gets to embrace her passion for baking. She pours this love of all things sweet (and sometimes savory) into Bakeable, Taste of Home's baking club. Lisa is also dedicated to finding and testing the best ingredients, kitchen gear and home products. At home, you'll find her working on embroidery and other crafts.