Back to Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies

Print Options

 
 

Card Sizes

 
 
 
 Print
Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies Recipe

Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies Recipe

I'm a busy mother of two young children. I work in our school office and help my husband on our hog and cattle farm. When I find time to bake a treat, I like it to be special. The creamy filling gives traditional peanut butter cookies a new twist. -Debbie Kokes, Tabor, South Dakota
TOTAL TIME: Prep: 20 min. Bake: 10 min./batch + cooling YIELD:44 servings

Ingredients

  • 1 cup butter-flavored shortening
  • 1 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 cup packed brown sugar
  • 3 eggs
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 3 cups all-purpose flour
  • 2 teaspoons baking soda
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • FILLING:
  • 1/2 cup creamy peanut butter
  • 3 cups confectioners' sugar
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 5 to 6 tablespoons milk

Directions

  • 1. In a large bowl, cream the shortening, peanut butter and sugars until light and fluffy, about 4 minutes. Beat in eggs and vanilla. Combine the flour, baking soda and salt; add to creamed mixture and mix well.
  • 2. Shape into 1-in. balls and place 2 in. apart on ungreased baking sheets. Flatten to 3/8-in. thickness with fork. Bake at 375° for 7-8 minutes or until golden. Remove to wire racks to cool.
  • 3. For filling, in a large bowl, beat the peanut butter, confectioners' sugar, vanilla and enough milk to achieve spreading consistency. Spread on half of the cookies and top each with another cookie. Yield: 44 sandwich cookies.

Reviews for Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies

Sort By :
MY REVIEW
Reviewed Nov. 10, 2015

"Oh my soul these are awesome. Use chunky pb for a bit of a bite."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jun. 20, 2015

"I found this a little too sweet also. I cut the quantities of each sugar in half and the results were great! I may try swirling Nutella in with filling, had a lot of requests to have chocolate in there somewhere."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jun. 18, 2015

"Two of my sons have chosen this as their new favorite cookie. I use half butter, half shortening for flavor."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Dec. 29, 2014

"These were really good!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Oct. 31, 2014

"These cookies are yummy! The peanut butter cookie by itself is good, very moist. I used half margarine & half shortening for my dough. Adding the peanut butter flavored filling between two cookies just makes them even better."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Apr. 3, 2014

"Love, Love, LOVE these! I found this one in the TOH Cookbook that hubby bought for me and made them on a whim late one morning. The only adjustments I made were that I used butter instead of the shortening, and did not make them into sandwiches.

My family raved! The cookie alone isn't too sweet. I can't comment on the filling, though, as I didn't make it. I will definitely be making these again.
HIGHLY Recommended!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Mar. 27, 2014

"Nobody liked them in my family. Similar opinion as mom-in-michigan, too sweet."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed May. 15, 2013

"I made two batches of these cookies -- one with butter and one with butter-flavored shortening. Shortening gives the cookies a softer, chewier texture and allows them to hold a nice shape. But as far as flavor, butter wins all the way. If you chill the dough before baking them, you can keep butter-based cookies from spreading or becoming too crunchy (providing you don't overbake!)."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jan. 11, 2013

"obscenely sweet - my kids didn't even finish ONE. I guess if you like super sweet stuff, they would be good - but I actually had to make scrambled eggs with salt just to get the sugar taste out of my mouth. Even after brushing."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jan. 1, 2013

"Only peanut butter cookie recipe I've ever like. They are so good!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Dec. 5, 2012

"My mom made these for us and they were incredible! Now we have them all the time!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Sep. 3, 2012

"I am going to try this recipe! These cookies look delicious!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Apr. 4, 2012

"What a great recipe. I had to fend off my husband and kids while the cookies cooled on the baker's rack. My husband did mention after I sandwiched them together that they tasted great plain, all on their own. This is definately my new plain peanut butter cookie recipe."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Feb. 7, 2012

"Kids loved them!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jan. 29, 2012

"just made these cookies for my husband to welcome him home from hunting camp and they are awesome. i did not have butter-flavored shortening so i just used 1/2 shorting and 1/2 butter. there were a little lighter than the picture. but still great.."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Aug. 14, 2011

"I was in the mood for peanut butter cookies and wanted to try something different and I believe I have discovered my favorite peanut butter cookie recipe. These are SOOO good! The only complaint I have is for some reason mine didn't come out the size they show in the picture they turned out HUGE and flat. I didn't make huge cookie dough balls either. They are a little hard, but still taste GREAT with the frosting and as others said they are perfect by themselves. I debated whether not to make the frosting, but I wanted to see how good the recipe is when you do it up all the way. The frosting REALLY adds a lot lot too them. I may use the frosting to make some regular chocolate chip cookie sandwhiches with a hint of peanut butter flavor! There are so many ways you can alter this recipe. I look forward to playing with it. Next time I want to make them fancier and drizzle some chocolate on top. Thank you for the GREAT recipe I know it will be one I go to again and again!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jul. 28, 2011

"Amazing cookies, simply one of my favorites! I saw someone ask if you can use butter instead of shortening: YES!! It turns out even better, in my opinion, as I am not one to like the smell or flavor of shortening. Butter worked perfect and made the cookies all the more incredible!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jul. 15, 2011

"AWSOME!!!! AWSOME!!!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed May. 4, 2011

"These are my one of my husband's absolute favorite cookie. He asks for them all the time!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Apr. 14, 2011

"These cookies are my go-to for Peanut Butter cookies. The recipe makes a lot! So sometimes I make just half. Great Recipe!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Feb. 21, 2011

"This is a very good recipe and as another writer said, the cookies are good enough without the icing!

I did make the icing and it is delicious but I found 5 tablespoons of milk to be a little much and made the icing a little thinner than desired so I added a touch more sugar and thickened it to the consistency I wanted.
Someone else asked if regular shortening would work...that is what I used and the cookies are yummy!
My absolute favorite thing about this recipe is if you exclude the icing, it is dairy free which means my dairy allergy daughter can enjoy it as well. I considered making the icing with soy but since this was my first run I went with the milk.
Happy baking!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Feb. 19, 2011

"Very good!!! Did them just as the recipe called for. My only complaint is I ran out of frosting! :) (Must have put too much on some of them.) Also did some with grape jelly as some suggested and my husband loved them! I'm sure it would be just as good if you used regular shortning. I have done that in some recipes before and it turned out just as well."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Nov. 12, 2010

"OMG This is the best peanut butter cookie I've ever had! I made it without the frosting, it didn't need it! This is the perfect cookie!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Oct. 19, 2010

"Can you use regular shortening? Thats all I have in the pantry"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Oct. 9, 2010

"Just made these for my boyfriend and he loves them. Very good recipe. I will definitely make these again!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Sep. 23, 2010

"Ok, I'm personally not a big peanut butter fan, but these are delicious! The cookie alone is very tasty, but you add the filling and shazam! I made this w/ crunchy peanut butter and added extra chopped peanuts because we like the consistency much better. Trust me, these are GREAT!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jun. 13, 2010

"I just made the cookies without the filling and they are excellent! Everytime I go put the next batch in, the one I just took out is gone!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed May. 24, 2010

"I make these a lot! Everyone just LOVES them!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed May. 22, 2010

"This is an excellent peanut butter cookie...if you love peanut butter, you will love these! I added peanutbutter extract to the dough and the frosting...Yum!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Apr. 20, 2010

"I skipped the filling and these were still amazing. This is going to be my go-to peanut butter cookie recipe from now on. They'd be delicious with some strawberry jam!"

MY REVIEW
pwa
Reviewed Mar. 5, 2010

"These are the best! They, also, travel well and are good for mailing to loved ones far away."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jan. 20, 2010

"Husband has to have his cookies! He loved them & say's to make them so we don't run out!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jan. 20, 2010

"This recipe is in my "keeper" section and I make them not only at Christmas, but for our small group, and friends who specifically request this cookie. It is PERFECT as written and doesn't need alterations. Thanks for submitting it!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jan. 19, 2010

"First, these are exellent. Can't go wrong with peanut butter in my book.

Second, in reference to the person from Austrailia, it is vegetable shortening, such as Crisco, that is butter flavored."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jan. 19, 2010

"Very good! Everybody loved them. I added a thin layer of grape jam (you could use your favorite) along with the peanut butter filling and that was excellent also."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Dec. 12, 2009

"I just made the peanut butter cookies without sandwiching them with frosting and added a 12 oz bag of white chocolate chips! They were excellent!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Dec. 7, 2009

"can butter be used instead of butter-flavoured shorting"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Oct. 17, 2009

"These are by far the best peanut butter cookies they taste like home made nutter butter Cookies .You cant eat just one."

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Sep. 17, 2009

"I haven't tried these yet.I am from Australia,what is butter flavored shortening please?"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Jul. 18, 2009

"its so good!!! this is my favorite peanut butter cookie things!!!! you will love it!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed May. 19, 2009

"This ookie is my fav of them all! Try drizzling a small amount of chocolate on top of each cookie .....oh, so yummy!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Mar. 8, 2009

"These cookies are AMAZING! If you taste the filling alone it's too sweet but in the cookie it's perfect!"

MY REVIEW
Reviewed Aug. 13, 2008

"Very good. The icing makes these cookies an extra special treat."

Loading Image