Back to Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake

Print Options

 
 

Card Sizes

 
 
 
 Print
Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake Recipe

Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake Recipe

I said I'd bring dessert to a holiday party and tried this recipe. I'm sure you'll agree it tastes as luscious as it looks! —Dawn Lowenstein, Hatboro, Pennsylvania
TOTAL TIME: Prep: 20 min. Bake: 55 min. + chilling YIELD:12-14 servings

Ingredients

  • 1-1/4 cups graham cracker crumbs
  • 1/4 cup sugar
  • 1/4 cup crushed cream-filled chocolate sandwich cookies
  • 6 tablespoons butter, melted
  • 3/4 cup creamy peanut butter
  • FILLING:
  • 3 packages (8 ounces each) cream cheese, softened
  • 1 cup sugar
  • 1 cup (8 ounces) sour cream
  • 1-1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 3 large eggs, lightly beaten
  • 1 cup hot fudge ice cream topping, divided
  • 6 peanut butter cups, cut into small wedges

Directions

  • 1. In a large bowl, combine the cracker crumbs, sugar, cookie crumbs and butter. Press onto the bottom and 1 in. up the sides of a greased 9-in. springform pan. Place on a baking sheet.
  • 2. Bake at 350° for 7-9 minutes or until set. Cool on a wire rack. In a microwave-safe bowl, heat peanut butter on high for 30 seconds or until softened. Spread over crust to within 1 in. of edges.
  • 3. In a large bowl, beat cream cheese and sugar until smooth. Beat in sour cream and vanilla. Add eggs; beat on low speed just until combined. Pour 1 cup into a bowl; set aside. Pour remaining filling over peanut butter layer.
  • 4. In a microwave, heat 1/4 cup fudge topping on high for 30 seconds or until thin; fold into reserved cream cheese mixture. Carefully pour over filling; cut through with a knife to swirl.
  • 5. Return pan to baking sheet. Bake at 350° for 55-65 minutes or until center is almost set. Cool on a wire rack for 10 minutes. Carefully run a knife around edge of pan to loosen; cool 1 hour longer.
  • 6. Microwave remaining fudge topping for 30 seconds or until warmed; spread over cheesecake. Garnish with peanut butter cups. Refrigerate overnight. Refrigerate leftovers. Yield: 12-14 servings.
Editor's Note: Reduced-fat peanut butter is not recommended for this recipe.

Reviews for Peanut Butter Cup Cheesecake

Sort By :
MY REVIEW
GlamKaylyn
Reviewed Jul. 11, 2016

"This is amazing! I used Reese's Oreos. Hubby loves it."

MY REVIEW
Debbie5981
Reviewed Feb. 5, 2016

"I make this for many charity auctions it's a big ticket item. The most it has sold for is S295"

MY REVIEW
Chrissee14
Reviewed Dec. 12, 2015

"Yummy!!! I just made this for a Christmas party. I did add some creamy PB to the main batter, after removing the cup that is mixed with the fudge. I also replaced some of the graham cracker crumbs for more oreo crumbs, just to make it a little more chocolatey. I had no problem with too much batter as one review stated and I used a 9" springform. So delicious - one of my new favorites!!"

MY REVIEW
LTinNW
Reviewed Nov. 21, 2015

"I made a few substitutions which created a lovely taste sensation. First, I made a crushed pretzel thins and butter crust. Second, I substituted 1/4 C caramel ice cream topping and 1/4 C chocolate syrup for the reserved 1 C filling in place of the fudge topping. Finally, I chopped 4 Reese's cups and put them IN the vanilla batter. None on top. Did it turn out? You bet it did and it was fabulous."

MY REVIEW
debpenns
Reviewed Oct. 22, 2015

"wow! made this for my daughter n love:) birthday!! she loved it!"

MY REVIEW
missfrosty
Reviewed Jul. 25, 2015

"It's been awhile since I made this cheesecake but it's amazing. Just can't remember if you have to take creme out of Oreo cookies before crushing for the crust.??"

MY REVIEW
blajr
Reviewed Jan. 19, 2015

"I've made this cheesecake several times and I love it and have always gotten rave reviews. It is quite a bit of work, but I find it most worth it. I do use a larger 10 1/2" springform pan."

MY REVIEW
apoKylEpse
Reviewed Dec. 31, 2014

"Great cheesecake, but unfortunately, and I'm surprised no one else has mentioned it, this recipe yields enough cheesecake filling to easily do two 9" cakes. Wish I had known beforehand, as I just kept saying to myself "The recipe has to be right" as I kept noticing that there seemed to be way too much while I was mixing the ingredients, and I wound up washing 40% of the filling down the sink, and over filling the one pan & crust I did have, and the cheesecake ballooned up and split in several deep crevices because of this. Get your amounts correct next time please."

MY REVIEW
bbaker2
Reviewed Dec. 15, 2014

"Delicious...easy to make and it looks great. Everyone at the party loved it."

MY REVIEW
Mirandalynn21
Reviewed Dec. 11, 2014

"The recipe is delicious. The only complaint is that from all the chocolate on top is that it was very messy, but overall very tasty"

MY REVIEW
lisamaria
Reviewed Nov. 28, 2014

"I might be in the minority, but this cheesecake was not as good as I thought it would be. I am confused by the name because it tastes nothing like a peanut butter cup. The peanut butter flavor is hardly evident and the fudge poured on top doesn't add much to the flavor. Except for the pb cups for garnishes, where is the comparison to a pb cup? The crust came out hard, too and I didn't overbake it. I just was not thrilled with this cheesecake. It's not worth all the trouble, so I don't think I would bother making it again."

MY REVIEW
Sarah37
Reviewed Oct. 9, 2014

"Unreal amount of deliciousness."

MY REVIEW
Linda-Lee
Reviewed Mar. 28, 2014

"I made this for Christmas. IMPRESSIVE. But very rich, although we managed to eat it all! I did omit the peanut butter in the crust. Loved the crust and will use it in my next cheesecake."

MY REVIEW
LaurenShea
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2014

"dpauly123--I leave my cheese cake in the springform until I'm ready to serve it. So yes, cool it in the pan."

MY REVIEW
dpauly123
Reviewed Dec. 22, 2013

"Could someone answer if the cheesecake remains in the springform pan overnight while cooling? Ive experienced that my fall if taken out too soon. It is asking me to rate, but I haven't tried it yet!"

MY REVIEW
lisataber
Reviewed Dec. 21, 2013

"This cheesecake is a must for our parties. I substituted mini peanut butter cups for the chopped and it makes the finished product extra pretty!"

MY REVIEW
chrissellscandles
Reviewed Dec. 13, 2013

"I have made this cheese cake year after year for my son's birthday. It's sooo good!"

MY REVIEW
vickieg68
Reviewed Nov. 23, 2013

"Great recipe. I would not change anything!"

MY REVIEW
Jswisher2
Reviewed Aug. 24, 2013

"Five stars aren't enough. I'm always looking for new cheesecake recipes. This was delicious. Definitely will make again, and again. I wouldn't change a thing."

MY REVIEW
Ray Z
Reviewed Aug. 13, 2013

"Great recipe. To cut down (?) just a little on the calories I used peanut butter chips instead of the cups on the top. But still the best peanut butter cheesecake recipe EVER..."

MY REVIEW
c.houston
Reviewed Jul. 28, 2013

"Substitutions I made:

- Peak Freans Lifestyle cookies (dark chocolate/cherry) instead of graham cracker crumbs+sandwich cookies. I just used 1 cup and a half of the Lifestyles cookies and it was delish.
- Instead of hot fudge ice cream topping, I used nutella. ALSO DELICIOUS.
- I noticed that the peanut butter really did not make an appearance in the final product (maybe I did something wrong), but the peanut oil seeped out of the springform pan and onto the cookie sheet. Which I don't think was a problem, but maybe add more peanut butter? OR perhaps mix it into the batter?
- I misread the instructions, and melted butter for the crust, but then (Stupidly) measured out 6 tbsps of the melted stuff and only put that in. The crust was definitely drier than I would've liked, it, so don't make the same mistake as me. Always add a lot of butter.
-I also didn't have an electric mixer, which resulted in a pretty lumpy batter. Luckily I had some extra muscle on hand to stir it up, but I think an electric mixer would have made things easier :p
- I added cut up peanut butter cups into the batter (before I poured the chocolate part on) and it was SUCH a good idea. They melted into the cake, and it was impossible to see them, but they definitely made the cake richer and more velvety. They added a distinct "peanut butter cup" taste. Very good."

MY REVIEW
tatukween
Reviewed Jul. 26, 2013

"The crust - a mix of graham crackers and oreos - is what sets this cheesecake apart from the rest. It is delicious! My mother-in-law loves peanut butter and she can't get enough of this rich, creamy cheesecake."

MY REVIEW
ChefKat
Reviewed May. 26, 2013

"I'm not a great baker or dessert chef, but this recipe made me look like I am! It turned out beautifully, really rich and decadent. Next time I will try replacing one or two of the bars of cream cheese with the light cream cheese. My son and I had a great time making this together. It did take me much longer to prepare than the stated prep time, but other than that, no complaints!"

MY REVIEW
Angel182009
Reviewed May. 26, 2013

"My husband LOVE anything with peanut butter but he's not a big fan of cheesecake. This he loves. Great recipe!"

MY REVIEW
bje50
Reviewed Apr. 15, 2013

"Very good recipe.Unfortunately, the prep time is not realistic. Started it at 9:30 at night, and got it to the refrigerator after midnight."

MY REVIEW
TJKCW
Reviewed Mar. 20, 2013

"OK this is what i said when i saw how many views it has "holy fudge!!" it looks so good!!!!!!!!!!!

my mom loves PB cup!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:) :):) :)"

MY REVIEW
qpv
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2013

"I made this recipe for our Christmas Eve dessert and it was a huge hit. Everyone loved it and they have been asking me to make it again and again. I do not usually take the time to rate recipes but this one was so good I felt I had to."

MY REVIEW
franser
Reviewed Jan. 30, 2013

"This is a cheesecake that always gets requested over & over!!"

MY REVIEW
exj01
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2012

"Truly enjoyed this cheesecake. It was creamy and smooth and a great peanut butter taste -- one of the family's favorite."

MY REVIEW
tampster1
Reviewed Dec. 23, 2012

"I would make this again. It turned out Perfect"

MY REVIEW
momof29
Reviewed Nov. 5, 2012

"Mason makes this divine cheesecake for his mother! Thank you son;)"

MY REVIEW
mem381
Reviewed Aug. 1, 2012

"I feel kind of bad being the only one so far to really think this cheesecake wasn't that amazing. I think I was expecting more of the peanut butter cup taste all through out it and it wasn't really what I was looking for. I wouldn't mind trying it again, but instead of putting the peanutbutter on the bottom, fold it into the cream cheese filling, or both : ) I'm just not a big fan of plain cheesecake and this was more plain tasting than I would like."

MY REVIEW
leosnaarf
Reviewed Jul. 14, 2012

"This is one of the best cheesecakes I have ever made and it is definitely the one I make most often. I made this for an office party and now I am not allowed to bring anything else. It has been a hit wherever I take it. It is somewhat time-consuming so make sure you give yourself plenty of time to finish. Cooling completely before refrigeration is key. It really is as good as it looks."

MY REVIEW
Stephsupermom
Reviewed Jun. 26, 2012

"I have made this cheesecake over and over again. It is so delicious. One of my husbands favorites. It always gets rave reviews wherever I take it."

MY REVIEW
kpossible18
Reviewed May. 12, 2012

"amazing!!!"

MY REVIEW
Shelleybell1970
Reviewed Apr. 18, 2012

"I just finished this cheesecake for a co-worker's birthday. I can already tell it's going to be a HUGE hit. I can't wait to serve this tomorrow!"

MY REVIEW
MzKitty
Reviewed Mar. 12, 2012

"Totally decadent!! Made it for my in-laws and they proclaimed it to be "restaurant quality". I didn't change a thing and thought it was pretty easy. I may do a water bath next time to prevent cracks (or allow myself more time, it had to be put in the fridge overnight without fully cooling outside of the oven first). It was wonderful, thank you for sharing it."

MY REVIEW
deb49729
Reviewed Feb. 24, 2012

"I won a !desert tasting with this one"

MY REVIEW
DorothyC2012
Reviewed Feb. 14, 2012

"This is the best cheesecake, ever!!! I love making this, love eating it even more!!!!"

MY REVIEW
DanielleRie
Reviewed Nov. 30, 2011

"I made this for Thanksgiving and my whole family loved it and there were no left-overs!!!"

MY REVIEW
mam-a-5
Reviewed Nov. 30, 2011

"Absolutely Amazing!!! I made this the morning of Thanksgiving, we ate it that evening. Pardon the pun, but each bite could've given a heart attack, it is absolutely scrumptious. Also pretty easy to create as well."

MY REVIEW
HammockQueen
Reviewed Nov. 24, 2011

"This was an amazing Peanut Butter Cheesecake! Was easy to do also. Was devoured shortly after i cut into it for Thanksgving at my friends house!!!"

MY REVIEW
360fods
Reviewed Nov. 20, 2011

"Delicious! Worth the time put into it."

MY REVIEW
sheinemann
Reviewed Aug. 1, 2011

"This is one of the most decadent cheesecakes I have ever had!!! Everyone loved it and I've already had 3 requests to make this again! Delicious!!!!!"

MY REVIEW
donnal777
Reviewed Jul. 7, 2011

"I made this cheesecake for a birthday party and it was a big hit with all of the guests! I used miniature peanut butter cups cut in half. The birthday girl asked for the recipe!"

MY REVIEW
sassyblonde1953
Reviewed May. 3, 2011

"This recipe was a major hit! Have already made several of them!"

MY REVIEW
dlindenf
Reviewed Apr. 20, 2011

"OMG! This cheesecake was positively sinful! Everyone loved it!"

MY REVIEW
dschultz01
Reviewed Mar. 13, 2011

"This is one of those recipes that my family keeps requesting. Made it for a holiday gathering a few years ago, and everyone is still talking about it!"

MY REVIEW
bethjensen
Reviewed Mar. 13, 2011

"Have made this several times and always a hit. MY family likes it when I add peanut butter cups on top of the peanut butter layer."

MY REVIEW
Kar_ligirl
Reviewed Feb. 15, 2011

"Holy Cheesecake! This was amazingly good! I made it for my Valentine, and He LOVED IT! Keep in mind this is very rich, but full of peanut butter and chocolate flavor! Took some time to make, but I will definately make this again!"

MY REVIEW
rsweet3
Reviewed Feb. 9, 2011

"this turned out so good. I cant wait to make it again. Instead of using the fudge for the top I used the Reese's shell for ice cream. worked great"

MY REVIEW
Tishscook
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2011

"This is sooooo good. Everyone just loved it."

MY REVIEW
chirey
Reviewed Jan. 28, 2011

"DELICIOUS! This is one of the best cheesecakes I have ever tasted. You can't go wrong with peanut butter and chocolate! I made it according to the directions except I doubled the reese's cups on top. I took it to a Thanksgiving carryin and everyone raved about it. Just make sure everyone sees it when it is whole because cutting it ruins the pretty look! My slices looked nothing like the photo! But that's why magazines have food stylists! Most amazing flavor and I will definitely be making it again! The only thing I might change is the crust and make an all oreo crust!"

MY REVIEW
DeAnna2008
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2011

"I first made this recipe years ago when it was on the cover of TOH, and I made my husband take a picture of me with my finished product and my TOH cover. This cheesecake is a little time consuming, but worth every second. It looks so wonderful on a table atop a pedestal plate, and it tastes every bit as good as it looks."

MY REVIEW
missi2111
Reviewed Dec. 20, 2010

"This cheesecake is stunning and delicious. I've made it twice to use as gifts and the recipients raved. I use a few more Reeses than the recipe calls for to get that WOW appearance on top. Recommend this recipe highly."

MY REVIEW
mikensue
Reviewed Nov. 28, 2010

"I made this for a friend who has had lots of things I've baked and she always likes them a lot - but this she declared as her absolute favorite! She brought one small piece home to her family and they all fought over it. She's already requesting it for her birthday again next year. I have to agree it was amazing. I did not change one thing in the recipe. If you're a chocolate peanut butter fan who also likes cheesecake, you have to try this! One warning, though. I made homemade fudge sauce for the top, but the recipe I have gets hard when chilled. Luckily, I had time to go to the store and buy a jar because the other would have been too hard to cut through without tearing the cake apart. For once, a store-bought ingredient was better than homemade."

MY REVIEW
pm52233
Reviewed Nov. 25, 2010

"I made this cheesecake for Thanksgiving. It is DELICIOUS!! Everyone loved it...they couldn't believe I made it...they all thought it was from the Cheesecake Factory. I will definitely make it again."

MY REVIEW
btakpowers
Reviewed Sep. 5, 2010

"Everyone loved this and I've had requests to make it again."

MY REVIEW
threespeedfortunecookie
Reviewed Aug. 12, 2010

"Made for a party and it got AMAZING results. It's true what other say -- it needs to be served in small pieces. The host kept the remainder and wound up freezing it. Apparently this recipe is so good frozen, it makes the original obsolete. I will now use this as a frozen dessert. FREEZE IT!!!!!"

MY REVIEW
liliant
Reviewed Jun. 9, 2010

"I made this recipe for work and it was a big hit. Everybody loved it! It did take some time to make, but it was all worth it."

MY REVIEW
momofgideonandeli
Reviewed May. 11, 2010

"This is absolutely to die for!!! I am a huge fan of cheesecake and this is amazing. I have made it for friends and they just loved it also. It is one of my top favorite dessert recipes!!!! It is very easy to make too."

MY REVIEW
ljanks
Reviewed Dec. 24, 2009

"I always receive rave reviews when I make this, so it's worth the hassle. It's amazing in taste and visually stunning."

MY REVIEW
HisVictoriah
Reviewed Nov. 14, 2009

"I personally don't like cheesecake but I made it for a birthday party and everyone LOVED it. The only thing is...it came out pretty attractive but not nearly as neat looking as the photo."

MY REVIEW
ruthsgranddaughter
Reviewed Oct. 27, 2009

"I made this for my mothers birthday, and it was a big hit."

MY REVIEW
jackie3307
Reviewed Jul. 14, 2009

"i used the smaller cups"

MY REVIEW
jackie3307
Reviewed Jul. 14, 2009

"Just made it, very easy just alot of steps, looking forward to trying it. Yummy! looks pretty too, i added 4-5 more peanut butter cups"

MY REVIEW
thin4life
Reviewed Jul. 7, 2009

"This cheesecake is to die for! This one goes in my recipe file. I took this to a a meeting and everyone absolutely loved it."

MY REVIEW
corrinne5
Reviewed Jun. 16, 2009

"i whant to try it"

MY REVIEW
josiezanker
Reviewed May. 1, 2009

"My favorite cheesecake recipe! I've made many cheesecakes and this one always comes out ahead of the rest. The crust is delicious with the graham cracker crumbs and oreo crumbs. A must try!"

MY REVIEW
lmsadik
Reviewed Feb. 18, 2009

"This is a fantastic cheese cake. I've made it for holidays and special events at church and it always gets rave reviews!

Lisa
West Chester, PA"

MY REVIEW
dawnzles
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2009

"Please Post All Comments Made on this recipe"

MY REVIEW
sillypippi1
Reviewed Dec. 26, 2008

"Oh this was so good!!! I have had MANY compliments!!!"

MY REVIEW
O1JOEY
Reviewed Dec. 5, 2008

"I made this for birthday to bring in to work. It was soooo delicious. I also made it for my Fiances birthday as well. It's one of the best cheesecakes I've ever made and tasted :):):):)"

MY REVIEW
5hungrykids
Reviewed Nov. 30, 2008

"This was so good! It received many rave reviews! I am not much of a cheesecake person, but absolutely loved this! It is very rich, though, so eat small slices! This took a while to make, but well worth it!"

MY REVIEW
marqsmom
Reviewed Nov. 23, 2008

"I chose this cheesecake as my very first baked cheesecake for Thanksgiving last year. It turned out perfect and it is very good! I didn't add the chocolate on top; one, I didn't want to cover up the swirl design, and two, it really didn't need anyhing else. The cheesecake is creamy and rich...just the way a cheesecake should be. You definitely do not need a large slice of this!"

MY REVIEW
Foodygirl97
Reviewed Aug. 21, 2008

"I made this for my boss on my last day of work needless to say she had to share with everyoneI have never heard so many RAVE reviews!! Everybody loved it even those that didn't think they liked cheesecake but they did say it was rich but very good!!! I am making it again very soon for my son and my future daughter-in-law!!"

MY REVIEW
cbheatwole
Reviewed Apr. 28, 2008

"I really liked this cheesecake, but it is very rich. It's not real great for after a big meal! But it is delicious if you have an empty stomach"

MY REVIEW
3sistersbaking
Reviewed Feb. 6, 2008

"My little sister made this cheesecake and it was gone by the next morning! This was absolutely delicious!

Priscilla :)"

MY REVIEW
mheadley
Reviewed Jan. 30, 2008

"I have made this wonderful cheesecake several times and everyone always enjoys it so, one of my passions is making cheesecakes and this one turns out every time !!

marvin"

MY REVIEW
Nancy_NJ
Reviewed Dec. 27, 2007

"Wow! Thanks for posting it sounds and looks wonderful!!

NancySmile"

Loading Image