My boys went through a phase where they loved Butterfingers. We made Butterfinger shakes, muffins, cookies and experimented with different bars; this one was voted the best of the bunch. Make sure you have an extra candy bar on hand because it’s hard to resist a nibble or two while you’re chopping. —Barbara Leighty, Simi Valley, California
View all Subscriber-Exclusive Peanut Butter Recipes >
View all Peanut Butter Cake Recipes >
View all Peanut Butter Cookies Recipes >
View all Peanut Butter Sandwiches Recipes >
Please log in to add this to your recipe box
Easy & delicious dinner recipes ready in 30 minutes or less—plus tips and more!