Back to Grandma's Potato Salad

Print Options

 
 

Card Sizes

 
 
 
 Print
Grandma's Potato Salad Recipe

Grandma's Potato Salad Recipe

Our Fourth of July feast wouldn't be complete without this cool, old-fashioned potato salad. It's my grandma's treasured recipe. —Sue Gronholz, Beaver Dam, Wisconsin
TOTAL TIME: Prep: 45 min. + cooling Cook: 15 min. + chilling YIELD:24 servings

Ingredients

  • 6 pounds medium red potatoes
  • Water
  • DRESSING:
  • 1 cup water
  • 1/2 cup butter, cubed
  • 1/4 cup white vinegar
  • 2 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup sugar
  • 4-1/2 teaspoons cornstarch
  • 3/4 cup heavy whipping cream
  • 3/4 cup Miracle Whip
  • SALAD:
  • 1 small onion, finely chopped
  • 2 green onions, sliced
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1/2 teaspoon pepper
  • 3 hard-cooked large eggs, sliced
  • Paprika

Directions

  • 1. Place potatoes in a stockpot and cover with water. Bring to a boil. Reduce heat; cover and cook for 15-20 minutes or until tender. Drain. When cool enough to handle, peel and slice potatoes; cool completely.
  • 2. For the dressing, in the top of a double boiler or metal bowl over barely simmering water, heat water, butter and vinegar until butter is melted. In a small bowl, beat eggs; add sugar and cornstarch. Add to butter mixture; cook and stir for 5-7 minutes or until thickened. Transfer to a large bowl; cool completely.
  • 3. In a small bowl, beat cream until stiff peaks form. Stir Miracle Whip into cooled dressing mixture; fold in whipped cream. Stir in onion, green onions, salt and pepper. Add potatoes; toss lightly to combine. Refrigerate, covered, until chilled.
  • 4. To serve, top with hard-cooked eggs; sprinkle with paprika. Yield: 24 servings (3/4 cup each).

Reviews for Grandma's Potato Salad

Sort By :
MY REVIEW
Surprisegal 247600
Reviewed Apr. 28, 2016

"I have not made this, but I am an excellent cook, so I will give this 3 stars, since I think it looks like a good potato salad, with all the right elements. However, the dressing looks WAY too rich (whipping cream? butter?)!! And not enough eggs. My mom's formula for potato salad was "an egg to a potato." In other words, 5 potatoes, 5 eggs! Delicious!"

MY REVIEW
Bristoltn63 246941
Reviewed Apr. 11, 2016

"Delicious potato salad"

MY REVIEW
Scooterrocks 246890
Reviewed Apr. 10, 2016

"This is the recipe my Grandma used for years. Brings back great memories. Yummy??"

MY REVIEW
kirkloriwilli 234902
Reviewed Oct. 13, 2015

"Humm, this is the most unique and interesting potaoe salad recipe ive ever seen. I'm definitely interested in trying this ! Thanks for sharing."

MY REVIEW
wendyfaye 229415
Reviewed Jul. 12, 2015

"I made more potatoes and whipped two cartons of whipped cream with additional miracle whip and it was a success with people taking seconds and thirds, food home, and asking for recipe. What could be better than that!!!!!!!"

MY REVIEW
Dilli 228096
Reviewed Jun. 17, 2015

"I'll stick to my Hellman's Mayo recipe. Too much work without good results."

MY REVIEW
rebelwithoutaclue 226492
Reviewed May. 18, 2015 Edited Jun. 17, 2015

"Unusual bland taste. I sub in Hellmann's mayo for Miracle Whip and it still didn't taste right. Didn't realize they still made Miracle Whip? It's not what you call a flavor enhancer!!"

MY REVIEW
loraannmerritt 2248
Reviewed Jul. 4, 2014

"This is DELISH! Takes a while to make but its worth it!!"

MY REVIEW
NDachshund2 2218
Reviewed Jul. 29, 2013

"We all loved this creamy potato salad, the whipping cream was the difference!!"

MY REVIEW
Pamlico 5756
Reviewed May. 29, 2013

"I didn't actually try this recipe. My sister did, and she isn't a very good cook, so she didn't know the difference. The ingredients alone should give you a clue. It was awful! This is absolutely NOT grandma's potato salad."

MY REVIEW
omahataxidriver 5511
Reviewed May. 10, 2013

"Very Sweet and bland...not worth all the trouble of cooking the dressing, cooling it down, whipping the cream.. needed mustard or celery."

MY REVIEW
6668 2541
Reviewed Sep. 5, 2012

"It was too sweet for us."

MY REVIEW
mamahunt 5730
Reviewed Jul. 27, 2012

"I wanted to try something different. This was totally awesome family is picky about they're potatoe salads....this was a thumbs up for them all"

MY REVIEW
Rona74 2536
Reviewed Jul. 19, 2012

"This takes a little extra time, but is absolutely delicious!"

MY REVIEW
M.Simons 7777
Reviewed Jul. 17, 2012

"Made this recipe over the weekend because my daughter thought she might like it. Neither of us liked the frothy consistency of the dressing. Taste was O.K., but wouldn't go to all the trouble to make it again."

MY REVIEW
bobbecat 5498
Reviewed Jul. 16, 2012

"Labor intensive, and I did not think it was very good. Fairly blah, and definately not worth going thru all the work it takes. I won't make it again."

MY REVIEW
Ohio46 5727
Reviewed Jul. 4, 2012

"Pretty plain. Needs pickle, celery, seasonings. Might be OK for kids with not much taste preference."

MY REVIEW
onepennye 4904
Reviewed Jul. 2, 2012

"Although tasty, it isn't one I would make again. The original Best Foods is still the best and contains much less fat"

MY REVIEW
joyousdeeous 6265
Reviewed Jul. 1, 2012

" This recipe is very good!!!"

MY REVIEW
lvslwnrdr 2535
Reviewed Jul. 1, 2012

"I have not personally made "this" recipe but my mother-in-law shared a recipe for a cooked salad dressing and my children don't want their macaroni salad any other way. The cooked dressing IS worth the extra steps. My recipe is a little different and gives you the choice of lemon juice or vinegar (lemon for pasta, vinegar for potato is best). Miracle Whip is "salad dressing", not mayonaise. It is simply a different flavor option."

MY REVIEW
OldCookieCrony 7117
Reviewed Jun. 30, 2012

"Very good!"

MY REVIEW
sullee 5509
Reviewed Jun. 30, 2012

"I haven't tried this recipe. I am still looking for a recipe that my mom and grandmother used to make. My grandmother was 91 when she passed away in 1987. She handed that recipe down to my mother. Potato salad was the best i have ever had. Of all the recipe's i wrote down from my mother that was one that I didn't and one that I wish i did. I know that it had probably had pickle, I think some pickle juice, celery seed and probably miracle whip, eggs, paprika. Can anyone help me further on this"

MY REVIEW
joyousdeeous 3888
Reviewed Jun. 30, 2012

"I have enjoyed eating this recipe and it's delicious. However, I am not willing to go that many steps for a potato salad that is no better than my Mom's recipe. Let's face it, we all have our fave potato salad recipes."

MY REVIEW
MMDmitri 4036
Reviewed Jun. 30, 2012

"Your Grandma does make the best potato salad, thanks for the recipe!"

MY REVIEW
tsuop 5508
Reviewed Jun. 30, 2012 Edited Nov. 6, 2015

"This is identical to my Grandma's recipe, except for the corn starch, her's uses flour. I think the cornstarch would make it more smooth. My mother was famous for making this, now I have that honor!!"

Loading Image