Back to Favorite Baked Potato Soup

Print Options

 
 
 

Card Sizes

 
 
 
 Print
Favorite Baked Potato Soup Recipe

Favorite Baked Potato Soup Recipe

My husband and I enjoyed a delicious potato soup at a restaurant while on vacation and I came home determined to duplicate it. It took me 5 years to get the taste right! —Joann Goetz, Genoa, Ohio
TOTAL TIME: Prep: 1 hour 20 min. Cook: 15 min. YIELD:10 servings

Ingredients

  • 4 large baking potatoes (about 2-3/4 pounds)
  • 2/3 cup butter
  • 2/3 cup all-purpose flour
  • 3/4 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon white pepper
  • 6 cups milk
  • 1 cup (8 ounces) sour cream
  • 1/4 cup thinly sliced green onions
  • 10 Jones Dairy Farm Dry-Aged Bacon strips, cooked and crumbled
  • 1 cup (4 ounces) shredded cheddar cheese

Directions

  • 1. Bake potatoes at 350° for 65-75 minutes or until tender; cool completely. Peel and cube potatoes.
  • 2. In a large saucepan, melt butter; stir in flour, salt and pepper until smooth. Gradually add milk. Bring to a boil; cook and stir for 2 minutes or until thickened. Remove from the heat; whisk in sour cream. Add potatoes and green onions. Garnish with bacon and cheese. Yield: 10 servings.

Nutritional Facts

1 cup: 469 calories, 28g fat (17g saturated fat), 86mg cholesterol, 563mg sodium, 41g carbohydrate (10g sugars, 3g fiber), 14g protein.

Reviews for Favorite Baked Potato Soup

Sort By :
MY REVIEW
jeanc47 User ID: 7157598 256346
Reviewed Nov. 3, 2016

"I made it as directed and if you love pure potato soup taste, I think it's great. I used pink Himalaya salt, so I had to add more regular salt. I will try other additions when I make it again if I want more zip and zest. I would have loved to use California Baker Potatoes, but I can only get those when we're in North Carolina for the summer. They are the best tasting potato I have ever had. I don't see them in Florida and wonder where I can get them."

MY REVIEW
sstetzel User ID: 158954 254401
Reviewed Sep. 21, 2016

"With the dairy and potatoes, this is probably not a good recipe to freeze."

MY REVIEW
amosf User ID: 2942675 254393
Reviewed Sep. 21, 2016

"Can this be frozen ahead of time???"

MY REVIEW
chryck User ID: 8446983 244295
Reviewed Feb. 22, 2016

"Love this recipe!!!! I made very little changes. I did add more potatoes than it called for as well as used Old cheddar cheese(and lots of it ) for that sharp cheddar flavor. I believe that any recipe is a starting block and we add to it or take away things to make it our own. This recipe need very little adjustment to make my family beg for seconds! And with 5 kids to please, when they all want more, i know I have hit the jackpot with this one!"

MY REVIEW
C.A.D. User ID: 7091862 243091
Reviewed Feb. 2, 2016

"This recipe is a good start but is really quite bland. I added more salt and pepper, 1 can of chicken broth, 1/4 c chopped onion, and about 1/3 cup of cheddar cheese. So many people gave this a 5 star rating but go on to tell about all the extra ingredients they added. That's not really an accurate rating of the original recipe."

MY REVIEW
krdale User ID: 8679855 242337
Reviewed Jan. 23, 2016

"This recipe is flawless! I have shared it so many times!"

MY REVIEW
Wammie User ID: 7967389 241438
Reviewed Jan. 9, 2016

"Thoroughly impressed with this recipe. Winter in Wisconsin is starting to get cold & the smell of potatoes baking the oven just stimulates the salivary sense of what's to come. I didn't add as much sour cream as indicated & split the milk called for with 1/2 & 1/2 and milk. I also added chopped ham I had in the freezer in addition to the bacon. Chopped yellow onions & celery plus a couple drops of hot sauce is what I say "nailed it"!"

MY REVIEW
Krickcrack User ID: 6600355 237509
Reviewed Nov. 16, 2015

"Really easy and very good. I even had enough to share at work."

MY REVIEW
Roxiedill1123 User ID: 8578891 235831
Reviewed Oct. 28, 2015

"I have made this and it is totally delicious. Thank you for the recipe."

MY REVIEW
willowee User ID: 8459179 235819
Reviewed Oct. 28, 2015

"I have made this soup forever...still have the original magazine it was featured in many years ago!"

MY REVIEW
deearoberts User ID: 1960801 235720
Reviewed Oct. 27, 2015

"Try it with 1 can cream of chicken soup, 1 stick butter and swiss cheese instead of flour and cheddar cheese. Omit the 2/3 cup butter. Only 3 1/2 cups milk. 10 potatoes. Best ever."

MY REVIEW
Feen User ID: 1925557 235055
Reviewed Oct. 16, 2015

"Liked it very much. A good basic recipe that can be changed up. I subbed lite cream for 1 c of the milk- not sure if that was the sole reason it was so thick! I also added 2 chicken bouillon cubes, garlic, cheddar and bacon. Would be great with ham! Thanks for sharing the recipe!"

MY REVIEW
282778 User ID: 1442442 223099
Reviewed Mar. 18, 2015

"Great soup. Rich and hearty. My whole family really liked it, including my pregnant daughter-in-law who really isn't able to eat much. She had 2 bowls. I made minor changes based on reviews. I added 4 garlic cloves, 1 TBS chicken base, 1 tsp garlic salt and used 7 cups of milk. Next time I will use 8 cups as it was a little thicker than I would have liked. Not the fault of the recipe, I just prefer thinker soup. Highly recommend."

MY REVIEW
da1987cin User ID: 6176994 74077
Reviewed Jan. 2, 2014

"Delicious!! My whole family loved it!!"

MY REVIEW
proesner User ID: 102431 128088
Reviewed Dec. 14, 2013

"Substituted ham for bacon. Was good that way. Haven't tried it with bacon yet."

MY REVIEW
pansqueen User ID: 3945377 90747
Reviewed Oct. 21, 2013

"This is the BEST potato soup ever!!!"

MY REVIEW
kjcashwell User ID: 1982726 89749
Reviewed Mar. 20, 2013

"I made this soup to feed the 12 people in our office for lunch one day (doubled the recipe). It very quickly disappeared and I regularly have request to fix it over and over. I add garlic and onion powder for extra flavor."

MY REVIEW
lberry222 User ID: 4948624 32681
Reviewed Mar. 11, 2013

"Hubby loved it! Will definitely make again:)"

MY REVIEW
brigadoon581 User ID: 1693596 80958
Reviewed Mar. 9, 2013

"The absolute best baked potato soup ever! The only negative: there are never any left overs!"

MY REVIEW
kompers@wi.rr.com User ID: 1164962 74076
Reviewed Jan. 5, 2013

"This is the best potato soup I have ever made. We make this many times every winter and it please my kids and my parents."

MY REVIEW
mbhoneybee63 User ID: 4346557 50293
Reviewed Oct. 28, 2012

"This is a very thick and flavorful recipe and quite easy to make. I have made it twice. The first time I baked the potatoes in the oven and the second time in the microwave. Although both were quite good, the oven baked potatos did give this soup an added layer of flavor. The second time I used some of the bacon grease and brushed it on some day old french bread slices I had cubed and salted, peppered and added some crushed red pepper and baked at 400 degrees for about 15 min. to add as a garnish. This is a very tasty although calorie laden soup. Sometimes you just have to give in to the comfort you get from food!"

MY REVIEW
kgn1968 User ID: 6930217 74075
Reviewed Oct. 20, 2012

"we look forward to this many times all year round"

MY REVIEW
loves2cooktwinmom User ID: 6771565 127939
Reviewed Oct. 15, 2012

"Very good soup! Would not change a thing. Easy to make and my family and I loved it."

MY REVIEW
kathyjeanwaldrop User ID: 6268622 36801
Reviewed Jan. 7, 2012

"This is the best. It gives you the feeling of ah......I will dream the best dream soup."

MY REVIEW
chattik User ID: 1289727 81433
Reviewed Dec. 28, 2011

"This was so easy and first time out served to my BFFs for a lunch and what a hit. My husband wouldn't stop eating for two days!! This is a winner!"

MY REVIEW
emhogelin User ID: 3732713 89748
Reviewed Oct. 29, 2011

"Very bland at first, but I added double the seasonings as suggested by another review. I also added garlic salt, black pepper, and chopped yellow onion. It was delicious after that!"

MY REVIEW
zdb2010* User ID: 5656030 36800
Reviewed Sep. 22, 2011

"This is a good basic recipe but WAAAAAY too bland as-is. I added about double of all the seasonings plus a bunch of other stuff like minced onion, garlic salt etc. and also added a cup of shredded cheddar as well. I think if I hadn't done that it would have been pretty much a bland white sauce with chunks of potato. But I will definitely make again just adding the extra seasonings. We do tend to like stuff more spicy than some so maybe it's fine as it is for those with more bland palates!"

MY REVIEW
nussearvp User ID: 3348349 81424
Reviewed Jul. 4, 2011

"This is the only potato soup recipe I make now!"

MY REVIEW
kelsiem User ID: 4751963 33393
Reviewed Mar. 22, 2011

"The original recipe in the magazine has 7 cups of milk, which would solve the problem some had with the soup being too thick or paste like. It is the best potato soup ever. I too serve it to large groups."

MY REVIEW
hattis User ID: 5843675 50266
Reviewed Feb. 25, 2011

"I have been making this soup for the people at my church for over 10 years. Of course I have to multiply it by 5! It is the favorite soup on "soup night"! I can't count how many people have asked for the recipe and are now fixing it at home! Thank you Taste of Home for such wonderful recipes! I recommend this recipe to anyone who loves delicious thick and creamy comfort food!"

MY REVIEW
Nichole1013 User ID: 5825101 33392
Reviewed Feb. 14, 2011

"I absolutely love this recipe! My daughter had a birthday party with 2 other kids and we dicided to have soups! I had made this one before and loved it so I said I would make it. I doubled the recipe and came home with no leftovers. It went over really well!"

MY REVIEW
coffeewonder User ID: 5412995 81423
Reviewed Jan. 29, 2011

"This is delicious! I stirred the bacon in with the other ingredients and added extra cheese. Sooo good! It settles like lead in your stomach. I also kept adding salt which would fix the problem of the soup "tasting like paste" as some other reviewers commented. Next time I may add some bacon grease to make it more salty, which will only contribute to its heavy, heart-attack-in-a-bowl delightfulness!"

MY REVIEW
N_Cole User ID: 5599523 50261
Reviewed Dec. 19, 2010

"I'm going to have to agree with the person who compared it to paste. Very bland after doubling the salt. May try again with alterations."

MY REVIEW
lmh126 User ID: 2148575 93454
Reviewed Nov. 21, 2010

"Both my husband and I liked this soup very much! I may add a little more milk so it's a bit less thick, but loved the flavor."

MY REVIEW
kbabbitt User ID: 3341692 81419
Reviewed Nov. 1, 2010

"I loved this and so did my husband. We added 2 cups of frozen carrots and peas along with some celery just before serving (to keep the crunch)as well."

MY REVIEW
katlaydee3 User ID: 3741999 90740
Reviewed Oct. 26, 2010

"I guess I am in the minority. I thought this was awful and tasted like paste. Would not make again."

MY REVIEW
jamesandannie User ID: 1290182 32680
Reviewed Sep. 9, 2010

"This is the only potato soup recipe that my husband has ever enjoyed. It's very creamy and the bacon add just enough salt to flavor it with the cheese. I had to use cottage cheese instead of sour cream because I was out but it still tasted great!"

MY REVIEW
needsomezzzs User ID: 4392298 74074
Reviewed Aug. 8, 2010

"sooooo good. Definitely a keeper! I put the bacon right in with the potatoes."

MY REVIEW
DKM2 User ID: 5049165 32679
Reviewed May. 5, 2010

"I followed the recipe exactly and everyone loved it. My husband says it's the best soup he's ever eaten."

MY REVIEW
sldenney User ID: 742866 90737
Reviewed Mar. 21, 2010

"Since I didn't have green onions or cheddar cheese, I melted 1/2 pound of Velveeta in the white sauce and added freeze dried chives. I took it to a church dinner where they scraped the bottom of the pot!"

MY REVIEW
rn4babee User ID: 1304462 89746
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2010

"A correction to the previous review. I used fat free sour cream, not low fat."

MY REVIEW
rn4babee User ID: 1304462 56364
Reviewed Feb. 23, 2010

"Delicious, I used low fat sour cream,1% milk, reduced fat cheddar cheese which I mixed into the soup with low salt bacon. I used these ingredients due to high cholesterol and hypertension."

MY REVIEW
theresajacobs User ID: 3491528 89740
Reviewed Dec. 28, 2009

"I made this soup the first time I saw it in the magazine. What a find! My entire family loves it!! I double it & there is never any left."

MY REVIEW
CaraBeara24 User ID: 4671770 110253
Reviewed Dec. 19, 2009

"This soup was soooo yummy! I used 2 tablespoons of chicken bouillon like someone else suggested, and since we didn't have any potatoes baked, I just used boiled redskin potatoes. I will DEFINITELY make this recipe again!!"

MY REVIEW
Monnette01 User ID: 1167299 90689
Reviewed Nov. 3, 2009

"I've made this dozens of times - we love it! I use 1% milk and half the amount of butter to cut a bit of fat, and it's still great!!"

MY REVIEW
terri0307 User ID: 4308287 38472
Reviewed Oct. 7, 2009

"This is a family favorite....I have 4 boys and I have to double this recipe!! There are NEVER any leftovers!"

MY REVIEW
prak1 User ID: 3517313 36797
Reviewed Jan. 14, 2009

"I made this for my family & we all enjoyed it! I then took leftovers to work with me & now they all want the recipe!!

P Prak"

MY REVIEW
brenda lee User ID: 2711396 38471
Reviewed Dec. 21, 2008

"I made this soup on a cold snowy Sunday afernoon. I will make this again soon. Love the flavor!!!"

MY REVIEW
PBlackstock User ID: 1067612 89738
Reviewed Dec. 21, 2008

"Simply scrumptious! I KNOW I'll prepare this again. Can't wait to share it with family."

MY REVIEW
lilygirl User ID: 428297 38412
Reviewed Nov. 25, 2008

"In our area of the country we call that Dutch Potato soup. I don't have a recipe.  It's served in restaurants here often.  "

MY REVIEW
panan User ID: 1913598 127937
Reviewed Nov. 21, 2008

"My aunt made a potato soup with no milk or cream - more like broth. Anyone know of a recipe like this? think it had onions."

MY REVIEW
buckus29 User ID: 1626097 74073
Reviewed Nov. 12, 2008

"This soup is wonderful, however, I changed it a little bit and added the bacon and the cheese to the soup rather than putting it on top. I really gave it a great flavor.

Karen"

MY REVIEW
RD2Cook User ID: 1012768 93224
Reviewed Oct. 26, 2008

"This is one of my favorites!"

MY REVIEW
splitz User ID: 1030952 32677
Reviewed Sep. 27, 2008

"This is my favorite soup! I do alter the recipe a bit- no sour cream (just don't like sour cream normally), canned potatoes (make it faster to make), and a TBSP or two of chicken boullion...this recipe is also very easy to cut in half!!!"

Loading Image