Back to Butterfinger Cookies

Print Options

 
 
 

Card Sizes

 
 
 
 Print
Butterfinger Cookies Recipe

Butterfinger Cookies Recipe

These great cookies don't last long—make a double batch! —Carol Kitchens, Ridgeland, Mississippi
TOTAL TIME: Prep: 15 min. Bake: 30 min. YIELD:48 servings

Ingredients

  • 1/2 cup butter, softened
  • 3/4 cup sugar
  • 2/3 cup packed brown sugar
  • 2 egg whites
  • 1-1/4 cups chunky peanut butter
  • 1-1/2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 cup all-purpose flour
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 5 Butterfinger candy bars (2.1 ounces each), chopped

Directions

  • 1. In a large bowl, cream butter and sugars until light and fluffy. Beat in egg whites. Beat in peanut butter and vanilla. Combine the flour, baking soda and salt; gradually add to creamed mixture. Stir in candy bars.
  • 2. Shape into 1-1/2-in. balls and place 2 in. apart on greased baking sheets. Bake at 350° for 10-12 minutes or until golden brown. Remove to wire racks to cool. Yield: 4 dozen.

Nutritional Facts

1 each: 96 calories, 5g fat (2g saturated fat), 5mg cholesterol, 83mg sodium, 10g carbohydrate (7g sugars, 1g fiber), 2g protein .

Reviews for Butterfinger Cookies

Sort By :
MY REVIEW
cruisingail User ID: 1553892 249727
Reviewed Jun. 23, 2016

"I reduced the brown sugar to 1/2 cup and didnt use a full bag of crushed butterfingers (found in bakery aisle by chocolate chips) Wasnt so sweet that way and I think made it a better cookie. I also used parchment paper and they didnt spread and were nice and chewy. Note: they harden after cooling so dont overbake. Mine were done in 12 mins. I also used a cookie scoop and they were perfect shapes and all were even that way. Alot easier than dropping from tbsp too!"

MY REVIEW
habenaroman User ID: 7905288 248431
Reviewed May. 20, 2016

"Loved 'em."

MY REVIEW
nitawyatt User ID: 3392776 247796
Reviewed May. 2, 2016

"Excellent cookie. I cut the white sugar by 2tablespoons as suggested. I used one whole egg instead of two egg whites. I used parchment paper on the cookie sheet. I also added 1/2 cup of chopped walnuts since i used creamy peanut butter. I cut the peanut butter to 1 cup."

MY REVIEW
cheezhed68 User ID: 1083106 233953
Reviewed Oct. 4, 2015

"No adjustments needed these cookies are wonderful!"

MY REVIEW
maball User ID: 4420592 216836
Reviewed Jan. 4, 2015

"Really good but almost overwhelmingly sweet-- this would be great without the butterfinger bars as a peanut butter cookie...."

MY REVIEW
nramsey User ID: 3436141 216372
Reviewed Dec. 30, 2014

"Delicious! Used creamy peanut butter and they were chewy and crunchy. Definitely recommend."

MY REVIEW
mbdumee@gmail.com User ID: 1289836 46761
Reviewed Sep. 18, 2014

"Best "peanut butter" cookie I've had! My husband loves Butterfingers and he really liked it as well."

MY REVIEW
delowenstein User ID: 3766053 28485
Reviewed May. 15, 2014

"I made these cookies for the first time-this a.m.! I did make adjustments to this recipe by adding 1 Tbsp. light corn syrup to the creamed mixture and I just used 3/4 cup CREAMY peanut butter! For me this worked well! I used the fun-sized Butterfinger candy bars and crushed them in my food processor-I measured out 1-1/4 cups total and I added about 1/8 to 1/4 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips! These cookies SPREAD! I'd started baking them first at 10 minutes, then I baked the 2nd sheet of cookies 9 minutes and the last sheet of cookies at 8 minutes! I used 2 teaspoons to drop the cookies on the greased baking sheets! Recipe made more than 4 dozen-I'd say I got at least 5 to 5-1/2 dozen cookies from this recipe! I'd used LESS peanut butter so that the cookies wouldn't be too stiff! The cookies were delicious and chewy! Carol Kitchens, THANK YOU for sharing this recipe! I took them to my hospital volunteer dept. (Nutrition) and to the Volunteer Resources 0ffice. The Nutrition Dept. tasted them and I got raves! I'm sure that I'll be turning to this recipe from time to time now! It's EXCELLENT! delowenstein"

MY REVIEW
cst38 User ID: 3433661 23471
Reviewed Jun. 18, 2013

"I drop by teaspoon, it,s faster and they do form uniform circles...though smaller. Huge hit by all. THEY MAKE THE BEST ICE CREAM SANDWICHES, with French Vanilla Ice Cream...to die for!!!"

MY REVIEW
AngieMM User ID: 4254253 47390
Reviewed Jun. 1, 2013

"These are my new favorite cookie. Follow the directions exactly, let them cool on the cookie sheet a minute before moving them and they will turn out great! I had to use fun sized Butterfingers, but just used 2.1 oz. x 5 and bought the same amount via ounces. Delicious!"

MY REVIEW
Felena User ID: 7255097 28484
Reviewed May. 7, 2013

"I've been making these cookies for years and they are always a hit. I even sell them at the Farmers Market. Someone asked about how many mini butterfingers should you use. I just use one pack and crumble them inside the individual wrapper and it makes the cookies taste awesome. I also use a small cookie scoop to scoop them out and they turn out great"

MY REVIEW
Jewels737 User ID: 7173108 51582
Reviewed Mar. 12, 2013

"Very tasty, chewy cookie.

However, I can't give it 5 stars because the dough was somewhat difficult to work with. I'm assuming it's because of all of the peanut butter, but I'm thinking more flour would help hold it together more, or perhaps a whole egg instead of the egg whites? My first batch broke apart and the cookies were huge and flat and grew together when made with 1 1/2" "balls" (they were impossible to form so I had to just pinch and drop on the sheet). So after my first batch, I used smaller pinches and lowered the baking time to 7.5 minutes-taking them out as soon as they started browning around the edges. They're a bit difficult to remove from the pan, even after letting them sit for a few minutes, so I'm thinking parchment paper would solve that issue (I baked these at my mom's house and she didn't have any).
They aren't pretty cookies...not by any means, but they sure are good. So, while my review may not be all that favorable, I will say that the taste of them definitely makes up for the appearance. My boyfriend demolished a plateful in one sitting, so I know they're good:)"

MY REVIEW
cee-jay User ID: 1579946 81915
Reviewed Nov. 26, 2012

"This looks like an excellent recipe to make use of leftover halloween Candy. Question: Does anyone know how many fun size bars I should use to equal the 5 the candy bars called for in this recipe?"

MY REVIEW
deann117 User ID: 6835185 28333
Reviewed Sep. 13, 2012

"These cookies are terrific and a new favorite in my home. Tried them 2 days ago and had to make another batch tonight."

MY REVIEW
kshea User ID: 2698812 202706
Reviewed Jun. 3, 2012

"My husband loves these!"

MY REVIEW
pscutler User ID: 1023528 49332
Reviewed Nov. 6, 2011

"These are wonderful cookies! I have made them repeatedly!"

MY REVIEW
Elkjers User ID: 4800643 202705
Reviewed Mar. 9, 2011

"I have been making this recipe for years and it has always turned out wonderful. I do substitute butter flavored shortening for the butter. I have also made these cookies using chopped up Snickers candy bars and they are equally delicious!!!"

MY REVIEW
parkshore User ID: 5612479 46759
Reviewed Nov. 18, 2010

"next time I will use 3 changes. shortening (do they mean Crisco in the blue can?), parchment paper and cake flour. my cookies were as flat as a wimmpy pancake and do not look great enough to give someone as a gift."

MY REVIEW
jpwoodwa User ID: 4916894 202704
Reviewed Oct. 3, 2010

"Great cookies! Make big dough balls cause small ones make the dough stick to the pan and burn when you bake them"

MY REVIEW
paulaf User ID: 834143 23468
Reviewed Mar. 2, 2009

"Yum! A new favorite cookie at our house and one I'll make again and again. Followed the recipe exactly and had no problems. Love this moist, chewy, wonderful cookie!"

MY REVIEW
mtnest_MO User ID: 84026 51579
Reviewed Aug. 25, 2008 Edited Apr. 19, 2014

"Oh, a thought--I used stick oleo instead of butter, which I think spreads more than oleo. Also, some recipes for peanut butter cookies call for NO flour, and they are good, so 1 cup is fine. Just have oleo at room temperature so that it is not cold, but do NOT melt it. Be sure to measure carefully. Extra sugar can make them more liquid. Be sure you have chunks of candy bar, not all tiny pieces. If they are too small they will melt and not stay in chunks. These will make neater balls after they have set for 15 minutes or so. Good luck!"

MY REVIEW
mtnest_MO User ID: 84026 81901
Reviewed Aug. 25, 2008 Edited Apr. 19, 2014

"I've made these cookies twice. The first time was not so great, but I learned that you do not flatten the balls like for peanut butter cookies and you cook them until browning around the edges. Then leave them on the pan and let cool 5-6 minutes on the rack, then you can remove them from the pan with a spatula easily. They are scrumptious! I like them better than any other cookie, now! I only used the 1 cup of flour and had great results.

mtnest"

MY REVIEW
Joscy User ID: 2694585 81899
Reviewed Aug. 11, 2008

"Have you tried this recipe again since you've added another cup flour? Did they hold their shape ok after baking? I look forward to trying them soon, following your advice. Thank you for the tip!

Sincerely,
Joscey from Oxford NY"

MY REVIEW
Stickygoo User ID: 3260036 81898
Reviewed Jul. 20, 2008

" I'm just a 60 year old want-to-be baker so take this for what it's worth

I tried this recipe and with 1 cup of flour my cookies were a disaster.
I did it again with 2 cups of flour and they came out much better, still nice, moist  and soft days later. I couldn't even keep them together when trying to form the dough into 1 1/2" balls with 1 C of flour.
Your thoughts?
"

Loading Image