"In my rush to make peanut butter cookies, I accidentally added maple flavoring instead of vanilla," admits Betty Ann Laakso of Orr, Minnesota. "The result was wonderful maple-flavored peanut butter cookies."
Baking mix makes these soft, moist cookies a snap to stir-up, yet they're pretty enough for parties. "I'm often asked to bring them to wedding and baby showers, and they're popular around the holiday's, too. I sometimes mix the dough the day before and chill it until I have to bake the cookies."