Share: Apple Butter This recipe was tested with commercially prepared apple butter. Featured Recipes Apple Butter & Onion Gravy This gravy is so creamy and good I could eat it like soup. But it's best draped over mashed potatoes and other Thanksgiving fixings. For reheating the next day, if it's too thick, just stir in a bit of milk. — Mindie Hilton, Susanville, California Harvest Ham Steak Sauteed onions top this smoky ham steak flavored with apple juice and apple butter. If you have some on hand, use homemade apple butter for a personalized touch. Soft Apple Butter Delights I won first place at a local apple bake-off with this original recipe. I especially like to take these hearty cookies to gatherings in fall. Related Tips Truvia Brown Sugar Blend This recipe was tested with Truvia brown sugar blend. Oat Flour As a substitute for 1 cup oat flour, process 1-1/4 cups quick-cooking or old-fashioned oats… Potato Gnocchi Look for potato gnocchi in the pasta or frozen foods section.